Admit it: You know you like to curl up in bed with them.
House Beautiful, Veranda, Traditional Home, Elle Decor, Architectural Digest, the middle-aged woman's (ahem) erotica, where full-color fantasies of Napa Valley hideaways or Connecticut farmhouses -- complete with silk velvet sofas, limed-oak paneling, Fortuny cotton pillows and hand-knotted Oushak carpets -- are splashed on pages of the glossiest, heaviest paper imaginable.
But during the recent economic downturn there's been a thinning in the ranks, especially at your local newsstand. Once plump with ads and articles promoting designer faucets and faience pottery, shelter/lifestyle magazines have been decimated by the recent recession and housing meltdown. The venerable House & Garden? No more. Southern Accents, Cottage Living, Home, O at Home, Domino, Country Home -- all gone.
Now, though, as the economy struggles to regain its footing, there are signs of life. At House Beautiful (circulation 800,000), projected ad pages for February 2011 are up 18 percent over February 2010, and ad pages for 2010 overall went up 9.23 percent. At Veranda (440,000), advertising pages are up 32 percent for January/February 2011 from a year ago. At Time Inc.'s This Old House -- whose demographic includes many "serial renovators" -- ad pages were up 41.27 percent for the January/February 2011 issue over January/February 2010, according to the Media Industry Newsletter.
Could 2011 be the year that the escapist, aspirational shelter publication rebounds? Or, in the face of newer online alternatives -- Rue, Lonny, Designsponge.com -- will the print product finally join Life and Colliers as a staple at garage sales?
Naturally, shelter magazine editors don't think so, and the latest crop of covers reflect a certain bullishness: "American Glamour NOW!" is the headline on Veranda's February cover -- a rustic straw basket casually stuffed with hydrangeas against the backdrop of a dramatic double staircase and tall windows looking out to green woods.
"We are staying true to what Veranda is," says Dara Caponigro, the magazine's editor and a former editor of Conde Nast's young, hip-yet-girly Domino, whose demise last year prompted shrieks of anguish in the interior design blogosphere.
Veranda provides "a read that cannot be replicated" in any other medium in quite the same way, she says, given its exquisite production values, high quality paper stock and full color photographs of extraordinary living spaces.
Since Ms. Caponigro became editor-in-chief in September, newsstand sales have gone up 5.5 percent and advertising pages have gone up 14 percent, Hearst officials noted.
"Ours is a super-engaged reader who wants to be transported and inspired," Ms. Caponigro said, noting that the March magazine's "well" -- industry parlance for the featured articles in the back of the magazine -- will feature a historic house in Nashville and a chateau created by Belgian designers Alain and Brigitte Garnier.
It's "livable luxury," and it's what readers want, recession or not, she claims. "Hermes is having its best year in many years," she noted, in reference to the French handbag, luggage and silk scarf purveyor.
Indeed, print is still viable in the shelter market because "these are, by definition, bedroom magazines," said Dominique Browning, former editor of the now defunct-but-still revered House & Garden. "You don't curl up with your computer. Print still has that portability and accessibility and seductiveness."
Still, Ann Maine, editor of Traditional Home (950,000 circulation), owned by Meredith Corp., notes that her publication "has evolved over the past two, three years beyond a print magazine to a brand, with websites, books, events, tweeting, Facebook -- we're doing all of that."
Ms. Maine noted a new partnership with the hip online shelter site Lonny.com to launch Trad Home -- a Web version of her magazine that emphasizes a traditional design aesthetic, but one aimed at a younger audience. It will be published in May and September. Unlike some online magazines that essentially replicate their print content, Trad Home will contain original content that Lonny will share and vice versa, she said.
House Beautiful, founded in 1896, is the oldest continuously published magazine in the U.S. "We're a utility, not just a magazine," said Newell Turner, its editor.
Mobile users can "interact with the brand" at the magazine's mobile site and its Q&A format -- initiated by former editor Stephen Drucker -- has proved popular with readers. (Q: "Aren't white floors a luxury in a house with kids and a dog?" A: "We used antique wide-plank pine and stained it with a non-toxic German finish ..." etc. etc.)
Hearst's luxury lifestyle magazine Town and Country has undergone more churn. Mr. Drucker, who was such a success at House Beautiful (newsstand sales went up nearly 20 percent after he took over in October 2005), recently stepped down from T&C after 10 months for reasons that are still not clear because ad pages went up 7.2 percent in 2010 after a precipitous 45 percent decline in 2009. He was replaced by Jay Fielden, former editor of Men's Vogue -- another casualty of the recession.
Still, Town & Country has changed since the days of Pamela Fiori, who transformed the magazine from a stuffy chronicler of WASP-y Social Register society to a lively, colorful magazine about do-gooders and entrepreneurs. The three top-selling covers during Ms. Fiori's 17-year tenure were of Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis, Audrey Hepburn and Grace Kelly.
It's not clear whether Mr. Drucker's recent cover, with Ina Garten, the wildly popular author of the "Barefoot Contessa" cookbooks, posing with Nora Ephron, wildly successful movie director and author, went over as well with the Town and Country demographic as those female icons of the 1950s and 1960s.
Still, the magazine is also taking steps to digitize its content, launching "the Luxury City Guide App" for the iPhone and iPad so affluent readers can get inside information on shopping, restaurants, hotels, spas and other amenities in cities they're visiting.
An app for House Beautiful and Veranda are also in the works.
"Magazines can't just keep doing the same old thing over and over again. We have to keep evolving and becoming something new," said Mr. Turner, House Beautiful's former design director, who succeeded Mr. Drucker in the fall.
To that end, the magazine is aggressively promoting its brand, which includes a "Kitchen of the Year" (a working kitchen set up at Rockefeller Center), and augmented by a television show, "Flipping Out" on Bravo.
Celebrity chef Tyler Florence also has a new column in the magazine, and an app is in the works, as well. Indeed, on the digital front, unique visitors at HouseBeautiful.com for December were up 64 percent, and page views were up 87 percent over the year.
Will all of this be enough to lure a newer, younger generation of readers who have flocked to such hip online design sites as Designsponge.com, Rue and Lonny? After all, House Beautiful's typical reader, according to Mr. Turner, is "in her 40s. She lives in a pretty, comfortable suburb. If she could paint or play the piano she would, but she doesn't, so she expresses herself creatively by decorating."
That reader could not be further from the demographic now reading online design blogs.
"We don't know that woman anymore," said Grace Bonner, the 29-year-old editor of DesignSponge.com, who admits, "I rarely look at shelter magazines other than Martha Stewart Living because of its huge emphasis on crafts, which are extremely popular with our younger women readers who don't have gardeners or designers but want to tackle these things on their own."
"The problem with print magazines is that they went too heavily on the aspiration," added Ms. Bonner, who would know: She used to write for House & Garden. "This generation is not as interested in aspiration as much as real attainable tips and skills that they can apply to their own style."
It is also perhaps telling that, after House & Garden closed in 2007, editor Dominique Browning didn't stay in the shelter magazine industry either. Instead, she wrote a book, "Slow Love: How I Lost My Job, Put on My Pajamas and Found Happiness," and now posts at her eponymous blog, dominiquebrowning.com, and at slowlovelife.com, which has its share of lovely images of pottery, orchids, art and food.
But these days, Ms. Browning says, she's less interested in writing and editing content about beautiful spaces.
"I'm more preoccupied with this question: How do you live in all these beautiful spaces?"





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.