West Virginia and the complicated bonds between mothers and daughters have long occupied Jayne Anne Phillips' imagination. They were central to her Pulitzer Prize-winning novel, “Night Watch,” and they are once again at the heart of her revelatory new book, “Small Town Girls: A Writer's Memoir.’’
Set largely in Buckhannon, W.Va., where Phillips grew up, “Small Town Girls” isn't a traditional memoir. Rather, it's a collection of 22 interconnected essays that meditate on family, memory and place, while also exploring the cultural, economic and political forces that have shaped — and often damaged — her home state.
“SMALL TOWN GIRLS: A WRITER’S MEMOIR”
By Jayne Anne Phillips
Knopf ($28)
Longtime readers of Phillips won't be surprised that West Virginia occupies center stage. Much of her fiction, including “Night Watch,’’ is rooted in the landscapes and people of Appalachia. Here, however, she strips away the protective veil of fiction and examines her own life with a confessional candor that would make a 1970s singer-songwriter blush. If Joni Mitchell worked in prose instead of song, she'd be Jayne Anne Phillips.
Phillips notes that West Virginia has always existed in a kind of political and cultural purgatory. Created in 1863 by Virginians who opposed the Confederacy, it became a state that was neither wholly northern nor southern. Once a mountainous paradise, it was subsequently exploited by out-of-state timber and coal interests that decapitated mountains, poisoned waterways and extracted wealth while leaving little behind.
She revisits the notorious Hatfield-McCoy feud, a bloody conflict that left 13 dead and nine imprisoned. To outsiders, the feud became shorthand for a backward and violent Appalachia, a stereotype that still lingers. Phillips shakes her head at the modern commodification of that history, from the Hatfield-McCoy festival to the 1,000-mile ATV trail system that bears the families’ names.
“History,” she writes, “should be more than a tourist destination.”
good writer
Buckhannon was beautiful when she was a child, more a thriving college town than a coal town, she recalls. Downtown bustled and local families owned the stores and restaurants. But by the early 1960s, even a 10-year-old girl could see the changes underway. The women had “dead eyes,” the children were unwashed, and the men were angry and defeated, drinking away welfare checks in local taverns.
Her own family wasn't immune to the state's economic decline. Her father, Russell, a World War II veteran who had once co-owned a concrete business, eventually found himself selling cars.
Yet the undisputed emotional center of “Small Town Girls’’ is Phillips' relationship with her mother, Martha Jane Thornhill Phillips. Smart, ambitious and compassionate, Martha appears in nearly every essay. As an elementary school teacher, she keeps peanut butter crackers on hand for hungry children and scrounges mittens for students whose families cannot afford them. She pursues graduate studies while raising a family, though she never completes her dissertation.
Phillips leaves little doubt about the depth of their bond. One chapter opens with the old saying, “A son will leave and take a wife; a daughter's a daughter all her life.”
Elsewhere, she writes that “a woman who loses her mother aches” and that “a woman with no mother or daughter is a woman alone on earth.” During childhood trips to the beauty salon with her mother, Phillips notices that men were discussed, “but never as objects of desire.’’
The book's final and most devastating pages recount Martha's death from cancer while living with her daughter in Massachusetts. Phillips reflects on witnessing her mother's final breath: “Every detail of her struggle will stay with me, nothing buried, nothing even out of sight.”
Some of the book's most revealing passages emerge indirectly, through Phillips' essays on the writers and cultural figures she admires. Her appreciation of Stephen Crane becomes, in part, an act of self-definition. She praises Crane's courage and his insistence on writing about poverty, war and extremity because such subjects throw human values into sharp relief — qualities evident throughout Phillips' own fiction.
Likewise, her tribute to the late West Virginia writer Breece D'J Pancake, who died by suicide at age 26, reveals her own sensibility: an aching devotion to the dignity of working-class people shaped by loss, displacement and longing.
“Like many writers, Breece didn't belong in the place where he was born,” she writes, a sentence that seems to describe Phillips as much as Pancake.
The book also contains affectionate essays on seemingly disparate influences, from Barbara Stanwyck's matriarch in “The Big Valley” to British supermodel Jean Shrimpton. Yet all of these portraits ultimately circle back to Phillips herself: a young woman from the hills of West Virginia trying to imagine a larger life.
“I have patterned my life on escape and redemption,” she writes. “Escape being flight, movement, self-reliance; redemption being the circling back, the writing, the saving of a version of events that is emotionally real.”
By the end of “Small Town Girls,” Phillips arrives at a hard-earned realization: There is no true escape. There is only the act of remembering, and the attempt to redeem what memory preserves.
Steve Halvonik is a former Post-Gazette reporter and editor, and author of the children’s book “The Cupcake Bandit.’’





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.