My Aunt Kay is 81 years old and is beautiful. She grows more beautiful every year in the way that most Italian women do. Bella donna exists as an expression for a reason.

She has been a part of my life as long as I can remember. In the 1970s, our families lived only a few blocks away from each other in Dormont. Her three children were constant companions for me and my sister during those wonderful years.

We swam in Dormont pool, played football in the street, bought snow cones from Phil the ice cream man and had sleepovers. More than anything else, we shared meals. However, back then, the art of cooking for myself had not even begun to marinate in my mind.

My mother was not Italian, but she was the best cook I have ever known. I would go to restaurants, order dishes my mother would make and be disappointed in their blandness or sameness. My mother did not exclusively cook Italian dishes, but those she did were molto buono (very good).

Advertise with us

Sadly, I had only learned a few recipes from her before she passed away on Valentine’s Day in 2013. Luckily, marinara sauce was one of them.

When I made it known to family members that I regretted not learning enough recipes, my Aunt Kay volunteered to teach me a few odds and ends. Tiramisu was first but rather easy. I made it for my Italian Culture Club, where I teach, and received unanimous approval. The real prize, though, was learning her great-grandmother’s meatball recipe.

I should have known that cooking with Aunt Kay would be nothing like a cooking show.

Before I discuss the recipe itself, I need to make an English language digression. The word recipe comes from the Latin “to take.” But in English-speaking countries, “recipe” had more to do with medical prescriptions than food. Not until the early 1700s was it used in close to its current form. I will explain later why this is a relevant side note. (Full disclosure: I have been teaching English for 30-some years).

La mia bisnonna’s meatball recipe was written down by Aunt Kay because her great-grandmother just knew what goes in and when, where and how much. But even written down, the recipe is a riddle wrapped in an enigma shoved inside a gnocco.

Advertise with us

At first, I read the recipe and saw comfortable measurements like pounds and cups. Those I can manage. But then, like onions in soffritto, it gets dicier — “add fresh garlic” (no amount given), “salt and pepper to taste” and “a lot of fresh parsley.” What the what?

“Aunt Kay, how much is ‘a lot’?” I asked.

“Mar, you’ll know.” (Incidentally, Aunt Kay is the only person allowed to call me “Mar.”)

We move along. She is an active coach, not sitting in a chair, fingering rosary beads (not that there is anything wrong with that), calling out directions from across the room. No, she is more of a lovable drill sergeant.

Her commands are terse: “Now what are you doing?” “How are you going to do that?” “Put the spoon down and use your hands to mix!” “Now get out of my way for a second.”

Advertise with us

I swear I heard that last one about three times during the process! Surely anyone out there with Italian heritage has heard similar instructions from their olders-but-wisers.

Finally, the mixing is finished. All that is left is the frying. But are we done? What if the mixture is not right? How do you know?

It’s simple (at least for Aunt Kay): “Mar, take a piece (of uncooked meat!) and taste it.”

“What’s that? Really? But it’s raw!”

She looks at me in the same disappointed way I looked at my son when candy wrappers spilled out of his arm sling as he climbed into bed.

Advertise with us

“It won’t hurt you!” she says.

How many times have I heard that? But when the matriarch says, “Taste!” you ask, “How much?”

I take a pea-sized morsel and taste. Not bad, the garlic, the cheese, the seasonings with the meat – this has promise.

The final decision – to fry or bake? Baking is definitely healthier, but frying does have the upper hand with taste. It’s a personal decision to wrestle with, right up there with how big a plate of cookies do you take home from the wedding cookie-table, or do you leave Mass directly after Communion, when the priest says, “the Mass has ended,” or after the priest has walked down the aisle? Each to their own conscience, I say.

Our meatballs that day were indescribably perfect. I won’t even try. I will only say that they are not these piddly little meatballs in your grocer’s freezer. I’m thinking these meatballs could cure quite a few ailments; remember what I said earlier about the recipe/drug prescription connection!

Advertise with us

Like the true, wonderful woman she is, Aunt Kay (after trying one and giving her seal of approval), let me take the rest home. I didn’t argue.

Making meatballs with my aunt was only half the pleasure that I received that afternoon. We had lunch, we talked and reminisced and she gave wonderful advice. I love her more than she knows. Everyone should be as lucky as I was that day.

I wish there was a way to thank her for her selflessness, but she only said, “Don’t wait so long to visit next time.”

I heard my aunt also makes wonderful biscotti. Aunt Kay, if you are reading this article ... hint, hint!

Mario Oliverio, 57, is an English teacher who lives in Ross.