On May 16, 1938, Fred Goodman, a beleaguered Jewish garment worker from the Bronx, wrote his first letter to Pittsburgh Judge Henry Ellenbogen. Goodman had just lost his father, and his mother and brother were anxious to leave Vienna, Austria, where the threat of antisemitism loomed large.

Goodman sought help from Ellenbogen, a fellow Austrian Jewish immigrant with powerful political connections, to aid his family’s emigration. In the letter, Goodman relayed his family’s plea to Judge Ellenbogen to support their immigration efforts.

“You don’t have to worry that we will become a burden to you,” they wrote.

This letter is one of 574 letters and telegrams newly digitized by Senator John Heinz History Center’s Rauh Jewish Archives in the Henry Ellenbogen Papers, a collection of documents and correspondence between Judge Ellenbogen and European Jews attempting to obtain papers to immigrate to the U.S. before and during the Holocaust.

Advertise with us

Staff at the archive, which has housed the 44-box Henry Ellenbogen Papers for 25 years, began the process of digitizing its letters and telegrams in May 2023 through a grant from Judge Ellenbogen’s daughter, Judi Ellenbogen. The new additions to its digital archive collection will make studying Western Pennsylvania’s Jewish history more accessible to researchers and communities living outside the area.

Judge Ellenbogen was born in Vienna in 1900 and immigrated to Pittsburgh in 1921. After attending Duquesne University Law School, he served in the U.S. House of Representatives from 1932 to 1938 and on the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas from 1938 to 1977.

Between 1934 and 1943, Judge Ellenbogen supported European Jews and their American Jewish sponsors, such as the Goodman family, by directing them to humanitarian organizations like the Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society. He also often wrote to government officials to advocate for individual immigration cases at a time when strict quotas prevented many Jews from immigrating to the U.S.

According to Eric Lidji, director of the Rauh Jewish History Program & Archives, the inspiration for digitizing letters from the Henry Ellenbogen Papers came from his daughter, Judi Ellenbogen. She had been reading a history book about The New Deal and World War II when “she felt that her father, his life and his story would have been appropriate in there,” Lidji said.

Lidji explained that Ms. Ellenbogen wanted to make her father’s documents more accessible outside of Pittsburgh so that historians could access these primary sources and incorporate them into their future research.

Advertise with us

Ms. Ellenbogen first discovered her fathers letters while transporting a large trunk of his papers from Miami to Pittsburgh after his death in 1985.

“I didn't know when he was alive that that these letters existed,” Ms. Ellenbogen said, explaining that her father and his generation talked very little with their children about the Holocaust.

“I knew that he had got my relatives out. But I didn't know anything else. My father was a man who did not talk about his achievements,” Ms. Ellenbogen said.

To this day, Ms. Ellenbogen finds the letters “heartbreaking.” “The other night, I read one, and at one point, I put it down. And it's not the first time I've read it. I said to my husband, I can't take it anymore. And so I've read all the letters. And they are very, very moving,” she said.

Lidji believes that the digitized documents highlight historical parallels between hardships faced by Jewish holocaust refugees and refugees coming to the U.S. today. “I personally found it very moving and insightful to literally watch step by step what it takes,” he said.

Advertise with us

Although Lidji acknowledges that American immigration policy has changed dramatically since the 1930s, “that combination of real humanity and the bureaucracy interacting with each other, I think is a timeless experience for people,” he said.

In addition to its historic parallels with immigration, Lidji thinks that the collection could lend its audience a rarely-considered perspective on the antisemitism of late 1930s Germany. “I think a lot of people, when they're thinking about the Holocaust, their mind actually goes to the most iconically horrific parts of it. But the experience actually touched a lot more people than that. There were people who never went to the camps, who were involved in it,” Lidji said.

Catelyn Cocuzzi, the project archivist in charge of scanning the collection’s documents, was moved by the humanizing nature of the letters. In the last five years, Cocuzzi has worked with many archival collections of family documents. She found the Henry Ellenbogen Papers particularly moving because of the backdrop of the Holocaust.

“I always like to say it's like a time machine,” Cocuzzi said. “I think all collections have that ability, but this one in particular just — it really grabbed a hold of me.”

Neither Lidji nor Cocuzzi have assessed how many people Judge Ellenbogen successfully supported in immigrating to the U.S., which they believe demonstrates an important part of their approach to archival digitization.

Advertise with us

“A lot of people who love history are very accustomed to the history being presented to them in the form of a story,” Lidji said. “And it's less common to actually sit down and look at the primary source material, which is what historians look at when they're writing history.”

A researcher would need to trace each correspondence in the collection to produce a succinct number of successful and unsuccessful cases. But Rauh Jewish Archives has a different focus for this collection. “One of the things that we love as archivists is that experience of localizing down to whatever document you're looking at and just listening to it and trying to hear what it has to say,” Lidji said.

Rauh Jewish Archives has organized the collection to encourage researchers to practice “localizing down” by creating filters to arrange the documents to follow overlapping correspondences, as well as individual ones. “Sometimes you'll be able to figure out where someone ended up…Sometimes the correspondence kind of trails off, and you'd have to go do some additional research to figure out what happened to the person,” Lidji said.

For Fred Goodman’s family, the journey was long and tedious. By June 1939, his brother had fled Vienna for the U.S., but Mr. Goodman had still been unsuccessful in getting his mother out of the country.

At the end of a June 1, 1939 letter to Judge Ellenbogen, he wrote:

Advertise with us

“Permit me to thank you from the bottom of my heart for all your kind efforts in my behalf and please continue to give me in the future whatever assistance you can, so that, if possible, we all could be united here.”

Hearing the news of Goodman’s mother, Judge Ellenbogen wrote on her behalf to Deputy Commissioner of Immigration and Naturalization, Edward Shaughnessy, and Sen. Robert Wagner of New York.

A March 16, 1940 letter from Deputy Commissioner Shaughnessy to Senator Wagner confirmed that Judge Ellenbogen’s efforts had worked: The visa petition for Mr. Goodman’s mother had been approved.

They would soon be reunited.

Elena Eisenstadt: eeisenstadt@post-gazette.com.

Advertise with us
(Courtesy of Rauh Jewish Archives, Heinz History Center)