When I was around 14, I read Vance Packard’s now-classic exposé “The Hidden Persuaders.” It was, at the time, an eye-opening peek into what the author claimed to be a new and sinister collaboration of psychologists with marketers, advertisers and others bent on manipulating consumers into buying their products.
Packard’s book described all sorts of subtle techniques including strategic shelf placement, package design and product naming as elements in a grand scheme to engage consumers’ most private motivations. The goal was to influence behavior in ways that favored corporate interests, even at the expense of the consumer’s own.
It also described “subliminal” TV advertising, a technique by which the seller’s product image or message would appear on screen for just a fraction of a second — presumably enough time to register with viewers’ subconscious — and affect their buying behavior.
good journey
Of course, like Capt. Louis Renault in “Casablanca,” I was shocked, SHOCKED, to read that such respectable experts — people whom most of us trusted to act more professionally — would engage in such devious behavior. At the same time, though, I thought it would be exciting and rewarding to become one of them myself. So a few years later, when I was off to the College of Wooster, I decided to major in psychology.
The problem was, at least back in the early ’60s, that psychology was not well-established as its own academic discipline. It had been a rogue offshoot of philosophy, and had only recently become a separate academic department. Its faculty members deeply envied the established sciences and wanted their own work to be seen in the same way that physics, biology or chemistry were viewed. But as part of its effort to mimic the other sciences, it became almost comically rigid in its teaching and research, much of which involved laboratory rats.
Read More
That wasn’t the direction I wanted to go. So, by the time I had to decide what to do after college, I applied to graduate schools with programs in communication.
One of them was the University of Pittsburgh, which had secured graduate fellowships in communication research from the National Institutes of Health, administered by its Department of Speech and Theatre Arts.
They offered me a fellowship. And it came at a time when the military buildup for Vietnam was peaking. So my choice became clear: combat service or graduate school. It wasn’t a difficult choice.
Later, as I was approaching the conclusion of my doctoral program, I was asked if I would like to become a member of Pitt’s regular faculty as an assistant professor. Although my earlier career aspiration had been to become a practitioner of influential communications with some powerhouse commercial or government agency, the offer seemed attractive, so I accepted. And I made TV the focus of my teaching and research.
However, the dean saw things differently. One day, as I encountered him in a hallway, he said, “My boy, television is not an academic discipline. It’s a trade. That’s why we have Point Park [University].”
What he meant, in other words, was I would not be able to build a case for tenure at Pitt based on my work there. But around that same time, I was being recruited by Brooklyn College to teach in their TV-radio department, where television was central to their curriculum. So I accepted their offer and moved to New York.
I don’t regret that move. But Brooklyn College, and the entire City University of New York system, was in deep crisis at the time. A convergence of severe budget cuts and open admissions made working there untenable. Everyone was always in a grouchy mood.
So after four years of feeling abused, I left Brooklyn and returned to Pittsburgh, where I still owned a house, and resolved never to teach again. Instead, I wanted to work in the “real” world.
And, after a few months, I was offered a job as an executive speechwriter at PPG — largely because my previous job at Pitt had been in its speech department.
During my interview, I was never asked whether I had actually written any speeches, which is a good thing because I hadn’t. But I learned how to do it on the job, and I remained there for 12 years until a new CEO declared that PPG’s shareholders were paying us to sell products, not give speeches.
So, in 1992, I left the company, and from then on became self-employed, working part-time on projects for an assortment of public and private organizations until 2022, when I finally retired.
Looking back, I never did become the hidden persuader for consumer products to which I had previously aspired. But I was able to marshal my writing to support a variety of clients. And I have Vance Packard to thank for guiding me along that path.
Peter Longini, a McCandless resident, is a member of La Roche University’s Lifelong Learning Memoir Writing Program.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.