Something unusual caught Kim Butler’s attention when she stepped out of the office at Calvary United Methodist Church one recent sunny Monday afternoon. She could see the sanctuary through an open door a few feet away — It seemed unusually bright in there. Someone must have left the lights on, she thought.
So Ms. Butler, a committee chair and volunteer at the North Side church walked into the 127-year-old sanctuary to check it out. She discovered the illumination came not from the artificial lights hanging from the church’s vaulted oak ceiling, but from the sun’s rays striking the west-facing, stained-glass window.
good light
That window, known as the Apocalypse window, rises above the church’s choir loft at the back of the sanctuary. It’s one of three massive windows created by artist Louis Comfort Tiffany that dominate the church’s worship space, and on this day, at this moment, it glowed with a brilliance that amazed her. She saw golden light blazing through the wings of an angel near the window’s apex. Blue glass depicting water shimmered and seemed to move. A shaft of light passing through the window cut across the sanctuary and splashed upon the altar, bathing a small cross in rainbow colors.
“I’d never seen anything like it,” she said. “It was so brilliant.”
The Apocalypse window is no ordinary piece of stained glass artwork. It has been impressing viewers since its completion in 1895. That year, a Pittsburgh Post reporter wrote that the window displayed a richness and depth of color that “baffles description and is said to be the finest window in this country or in Europe.”
Ms. Butler was fortunate to view the window in its sun-drenched glory. It’s an experience the church wants to share with others on Tuesday when the sun lingers in the sky longer than any other day of the year. On that day, Calvary is reestablishing a tradition put on hiatus during the pandemic, and reconnecting with its community, by inviting visitors to step into the historic sanctuary from 4 to 7 p.m. for a “Summer Solstice Open House.” People can see for themselves the windows created by an artist who was exploring radical new methods of utilizing glass and light. The event is sponsored by the Allegheny Historic Preservation Society, which for three decades has supported the church’s preservation.
It’s tempting to think of Calvary United Methodist Church as just a museum, as the Tiffany windows are just one aspect of its historic status. Calvary was built more than 125 years ago near what was once known as Millionaire’s Row, and the church’s membership roll included department store magnate Joseph Horne and the industrialist Scaife family. It was a congregation with the will and resources to build a mini cathedral inspired by the full-sized cathedrals of Europe.
The tallest of Calvary’s two elaborately decorated spires rises 175 feet over the intersection of Allegheny and Beech avenues. Stone gargoyles peer down from stone perches, ready to ward off evil. Inside, hand-carved pews await worshippers. Pew pads and the material covering them have been in place since the church’s opening. The oak ceiling high above forms a dark, warm canopy.
The church, however, is more than a collection of its architectural elements. Calvary remains a house of worship, and the building serves as an essential community center in the city’s Allegheny West neighborhood. A number of groups meet there, including the Allegheny West Civic Council and organizations assisting people with gambling and alcohol addictions. A square dance organization do-si-dos in the basement each week. Music teachers conduct lessons at the church, and Calvary serves as an incubator for small businesses. A car washing business now utilizes church space in the parking lot, and a catering business that started in the church kitchen years ago has since moved to its own location; another catering business is just getting started there.
The Summer Solstice event serves as a reminder that Calvary is in a “unique position to fill these needs as a community church,” said Calvary’s pastor, the Rev. Larry Homitsky. It just so happens that this community gathering space comes with some spectacular windows.
David Grinnell is chair of Calvary’s Church Council, which coordinates the activities of the congregation, and he’s been studying the history of the windows for a couple of years. He’s learned a few things about Tiffany and the manner in which he designed and built his creations.
Shortly before he joined the church’s choir for rehearsal on a recent Tuesday evening, Mr. Grinnell stood below the north-facing Resurrection window and noted how the setting sun set it aglow. “Look at the landscape and the foliage,” he said. Indeed, those sections of the window seemed vibrant and alive.

Tiffany studied European stained glass windows, which featured figures painted on glass. “He saw what they were doing and said, ‘We can do better,’” Mr. Grinnell said. Tiffany figured out how to manipulate glass to create a wide range of hues and three-dimensional effects. Some describe it as “painting with glass” instead of “painting on glass.” Look closely at Calvary’s windows and you can see how Tiffany folded and layered glass to mimic the folds and shadows in Apostles’ robes. The only painted portions of the Calvary windows are human faces, hands and feet.
Like the church’s other Tiffany windows, the Resurrection window is divided into three sections or lancets. In the left lancet, three heavily draped women walk sadly to Jesus’ tomb. According to the resurrection story in Luke, they are Mary Magdalene, Joanna and Mary, mother of James.
“This window is important to us,” Mr. Grinnell said. “We like to be inclusive. Not many windows have women, other than Mary. We have women.”
In fact, Tiffany did more than depict women — He employed a number of female craftspeople to design and create his windows. This was a significant move in an era when females were confined to mostly teaching and nursing jobs.
Diversity at Calvary extends beyond gender, Pastor Homitsky said. Those who utilize the church include people of other faiths — Jews, Hindus, Orthodox Christians, Buddhists. All have been welcomed into the church for a variety of events over the decades. When Stella Kalaris of the beloved North Side ice ball cart “Gus and Yiayia's” died in 2016, well-wishers entered Calvary to pay their respects and attend an Eastern Orthodox Trisagion Service — a call-and-response prayer led by a priest.
Calvary identifies as a “Reconciling Ministries Church,” which means the congregation recognizes the value of everyone, including members of the LGBTQ+ community. Mr. Grinnell points out the church’s slogan on a sign facing Allegheny Avenue. “You Are God’s Beloved & You Are Welcome Here,” it reads.
This motto led to a uniquely Pittsburgh moment a few years ago when the Steelers played a Sunday home game against the Cleveland Browns.

Heinz Field sits less than half a mile south of the church, and on this day a bus load of Browns fans parked a few blocks away from Calvary and were making their way down Allegheny Avenue to the stadium when they happened upon the church. Some of the Browns fans were Methodists, so they decided to pop in for the 11 a.m. service.
Rev. Homitsky is accustomed to looking out at the congregation on game days and seeing a lot of black and gold, but on this occasion he was surprised to see one section of the sanctuary filled with orange and brown.
He did what any God-fearing Pittsburgh pastor would do. He made certain the lost souls in his congregation knew they were welcome, at least until kick-off time.
“Every prayer is heard until 1 o’clock,” he said. “Then, you’re on your own.”
The church erupted in laughter and applause, and after the service Steelers fans mingled joyfully with Browns followers.
“I don’t even know how the game came out,” Rev. Homitsky said. “The game was not the highlight of that day.”
Steve Mellon: smellon@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.