When St. Francis of Assisi was granted approval by Pope Innocent III to form a new religious order within the Catholic church in 1209, he didn’t know a thing about baseball.
Those original Franciscan friars were required to live in extreme poverty, not allowed to own property, and beg for food while preaching in city squares and marketplaces, meeting the people where they spent their everyday lives.
good conversations
The rules are a little different for modern-day Franciscans. Destitution isn’t required. Nine years ago, however, Friars Casey Cole and Roberto “Tito” Serrano, both members of the Order of Friars Minor, were assigned to figure out the modern equivalent of public squares.
Friar Casey has built a base of 259,000 subscribers on his YouTube channel but felt a need to get out in the real world and, like the first Franciscans, meet people where they are. He and Friar Tito planned a pilgrimage across the country, stopping at each Major League Baseball stadium along the way and calling themselves the Bleacher Brothers.
Pittsburgh on June 3 was their eighth stop on the journey, which began in Miami on May 25 and is set to wind up in Denver on July 30. The goal?
“There isn’t necessarily a concrete goal,” Friar Casey said. “It is to have an encounter with people, to listen, maybe if they want to tell us something. What we’ve found is that we’re not encountering a ton of people that aren’t already faithful. We’re finding a lot of Catholics and active Christians who are inspired by what we’re doing and find it really fascinating. So we can say, ‘Awesome, now you go do it as well. You go evangelize.’ So that’s been about 60 to 70% of our interactions.”
Other interactions can be hilarious. After all, these are two men walking around baseball stadiums and tailgates wearing full brown Franciscan habits. The beers in their hands as they stood in the concourse at PNC Park only helped them blend in so much.
They frequently are approached by drunk young men intrigued by the garb. Some people think they are dressed in Jedi costumes from “Star Wars.” Others assume they’re fans of the San Diego Padres.
“Actually, the Padres are fans of us. We’re the original,” Friar Casey quipped.
More people than might be expected recognize their garb and know exactly what the friars are doing. Still others recognize Friar Casey from his YouTube channel, which he says gained a ton of traction during the COVID-19 pandemic.
The earnest interactions are meaningful, though. At one stop, Friar Casey says a man approached him saying he hadn’t been to church in 25 years, but he’d been watching some of his videos and was getting back into it.
He asked what he had to do to get back, and Friar Casey told him he needs to go to confession.
“He’s like, ‘All right, how can I do that?’” Friar Casey said. “I said, ‘Well, I can do that.’ So beer in hand, we went to the corner and I heard his confession.”
At the pair’s stop in Detroit, a group of young, 20-something women, who were “clearly having a good time,” according to Friar Casey, shouted across the section at the friars. They were unsure what to think heading into the interaction, but the women just wanted to pray, right there in the stands.
They say concession workers often ask them to pray for them, as well.
At this point, the only downside to their travels has been the rigors of the road. They say at most of their stops, a church or group of fellow friars want to host them. In most cases, they want to throw some sort of party or dinner.

“Not everything can be a party,” Friar Casey said. “We met some other friars in Buffalo, and they had doughnuts for us. They were huge, delicious doughnuts, and it’s like, ‘Thank you, but please stop.’”
In the end, Friars Casey and Tito likely won’t know how successful their trip has been. There is no bar for the amount of people they need to talk to, and there likely won’t be many follow-up correspondence with those they’ve met along the way.
More likely, if the friars do convince some people to go back to church, they won’t know. That’s all right with them. For this summer, they’ve found a way to get back in the proverbial town square, and that’s good enough.
“I think some people immediately, hopefully, think, ‘Oh, that’s still a thing” or “I should get my life together’ or ‘That’s a sign,’” Friar Casey said. “I don’t think we’ll see the fruit of this in our experience. People will take it back to their lives. Maybe small conversations will become something else years later.”
Follow them at https://breakinginthehabit.org.
Mike Persak: mpersak@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDPersak.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.