The Beltzhoover Elementary School revitalization project is full speed ahead.

The 60,000-plus-square-foot former schoolhouse has sat at the highest point in the neighborhood on Cedarhurst Street for more than a century. After Pittsburgh Public Schools closed the school in 2004, it was dormant until Beltzhoover Consensus Group purchased the building in 2018.

Now that developers have submitted proposals on how to repurpose the historic building, the BCG will begin evaluating each one before making a final selection and getting started on the renovations.

BCG member and lifelong resident of the neighborhood Jennifer Cash Wade explained that the group initially did not want to have a housing component to the project. But after assessing the needs of the Hilltop communities, which include Beltzhoover, Knoxville, Bon Air and Allentown, they decided to have senior housing on the first and second floors of the building. The lower level will be reserved for community and commercial space and “perhaps some kind of medical facility,” she said.

Advertise with us

Additionally, she said the BCG owns two lots next to the building and will work with the Urban Redevelopment Authority to acquire vacant lots around the schoolhouse, where they will construct affordable housing. The Beltzhoover school is also within walking distance of the city’s Warrington Recreation Center, McKinley Park, which recently received over $1 million in improvements, and South Hills Junction, a major stop for several Port Authority buses and light rail trains.

Despite such assets, the neighborhood suffered from decades of disinvestment after the collapse of the steel industry and the continued departure of middle class Black families from Pittsburgh. With the population loss, the city pursued aggressive demolition of dozens of abandoned houses in Beltzhoover, which left lots vacant with a need for new construction.

Ms. Wade emphasized the importance of the school project would be to restore not only the building but also a part of the city.

“It was once a very vibrant community,” she said. “I mean, there was no need to go outside Beltzhoover. There was a grocery store. We had a post office. We had different shops. We had a doctor’s office. We had a dentist’s office. We had a bakery, a dry cleaners. There were several little markets and corner stores.

“It’s just the beginning of a major revitalization in bringing Beltzhoover back to what it once was.”

Advertise with us

Purchasing the Beltzhoover School was a competitive task. When the school district shuttered the building, several interested developers came forward. A member of the consensus group approached Ms. Wade, a real estate agent, and Jacqueline Wilson, a PhD. in administration and leadership studies in nonprofit management and CEO of TRAC Services for Families, formerly Three Rivers Adoption Council.

The BCG worked with city Councilman Bruce Kraus to buy the building and soon the URA, Heinz Endowments, Neighborhood Allies and the Birmingham Foundation all were partnering with the group to jumpstart the project.

“The community itself basically capitalizing on that asset with multi-family potential is great,” said Aaron Sukenik, executive director of the nonprofit Hilltop Alliance. “"This level of investment could also bode really well for other complex projects, like renovating many existing vacant properties. It could really be a turning point for bringing investment and attention into the neighborhood.”

He noted the last major redevelopment project like this in south Pittsburgh was the Hillcrest Residences, a 66-unit senior living apartment complex in Carrick on the former site of a Giant Eagle. The project was in the works from 2011 to its opening at the end of 2017 and cost nearly $16 million.

At the same time, there is a citywide shortage of affordable housing. A 2016 assessment presented to the city’s affordable housing task force estimated a need of more than 17,000 such units — this long before the stiff competition to purchase a home in 2021. Meanwhile, some communities have been defensive against such development while other neighborhoods are in favor but have extremely limited land area.

Advertise with us

“Here [in Beltzhoover] you have a community that doesn’t have that supply constraint and does have that interest and support,” Mr. Sukenik said. “I think there’s tremendous opportunity with those two being aligned.”

Ms. Wilson was optimistic about renovations beginning in the first quarter of 2022, and Ms. Wade said the BCG had “no doubt” the full project would be completed in three to five years.

“I knew Beltzhoover when it was a thriving, family oriented beautiful community,” Ms. Wade said. “And we are one and two generations deep in our membership [in the BCG]. It’s extremely important because this is our community. We’re proud of it. We love it. We want to see it flourish again.”

Tyler Dague: rdague@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1569 and on Twitter @rtdague.