Eat’n Park asked its social media fans before Valentine’s Day to “Share Your Eat’n Park Love Story” and 131 people did. The people’s choice turned out to be Josh Hulslander and his daughter, Natalie, who have a standing Saturday morning breakfast date at the Eat’n Park in Natrona Heights.

“We started going when she was around 3 years old, and she will be turning 8 this April,” he wrote in his entry. “We sit at the counter as long as there are seats available. Before COVID, it was a great sight to see this little 5-year-old girl sitting at the counter with all of the older ‘regulars’ for breakfast. We both greatly look forward to our ’Daddy/Daughter’ days at Eat'n Park.”

The field was narrowed, by online voting, to five finalists, including a married couple who met working at the Irwin Eat’n Park, where they had their wedding photos taken, and a couple of five years whose first date included “Eat’n Park for milkshakes and coffee and hours of conversation (to make me feel like his best friend),” she wrote. “It's still one of the most romantic experiences of my life.” Plus a couple who on the first date at Chippewa’s Eat’n Park ordered “the same thing — Chicken Finger Salad Bar Dinner Deal with fries.” And a woman whose date put her engagement ring in her Homestead Eat’n Park fries ands she “ended up biting down on it, broke a tooth and swallowed it. Did manage not to swallow the ring. Still together 48 years later, wearing that same ring.”

But Daddy and daughter received the most votes and won a $50 gift card per month for a full year of monthly dates, as well as a lot of congratulations on Facebook. One person acknowledged their photo, from when Natalie was about 5, “is adorable.” Another dad and daughter reminisced about how they used to go to Eat’n Park every Sunday after church (“It was the best”). Another daughter, Bethel Park’s Valerie Goldbach Walker, shared about the restaurant on Route 88 near South Park, “My dad [Robert Goldbach] and I, until COVID and his passing in November, enjoyed eating breakfast there every weekday and he so loved the food and all the attentiveness he got from the nice waitresses!! All are missed!!”

Advertise with us

“It really surprised me the chord this struck in people,” said Mr. Hulslander, Dad, who lives in Fawn Township and works as an engineer in the quality department of a Saxonburg firm that makes lasers. “For me and Nat, this is just something we do,” going back to when Mom, Rebecca, had a regular Saturday morning meeting to attend.

Natalie is a second grader at New Kensington’s Mary Queen of Apostles School. She says, “Thank you for all the votes.”

The monthly prize should easily cover two of their cherished breakfast dates, which Dad says they will continue — “I’m hoping all the way through college.”

Bob Batz Jr.: bbatz@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1930 and on Twitter @bobbatzjr.