When Dan Gladis and Jami Szalla moved to the city neighborhood of Arlington, it was a return home.
Ms. Szalla had grown up on the South Side Slopes and had helped her parents, owners of The Green Front Inn Bar & Restaurant on Carson Street, with the family business for years. She moved away to Edinboro for college and met Mr. Gladis at a conference in Harrisburg. They soon started dating.
Mr. Gladis, a native of Aliquippa, wasn’t exactly used to traversing the steep patchwork streets high in the Slopes, but Ms. Szalla jokingly said he was persuaded to go on another date with her after seeing the city view from her parents’ house.
Now back in Pittsburgh years later, they kept wishing there was something else in the business corridor along Arlington Avenue, which doesn’t have very many businesses. Rainy Days Hair Salon had been humming along for decades along with convenience store Chuong’s Market. Eggs & Moore diner opened up over two years ago, but to the couple, something was missing.
“A coffee shop is where we would do a lot of our dates rather than a lot of restaurants or bars,” she said. “Just seeing more and more when we moved back to the area, we would love to have one in walking distance to us.
“And it got to the point where it’s like, ‘We can keep saying how great it would be, how great it would be’ till we’re blue in the face, but it gets to a point where, well, let’s do it. We can’t be the only ones thinking it would be nice to have something here.”
In December, after several setbacks, the couple opened Hilltop Coffee just two blocks from their house.
Ms. Szalla explained the idea for a coffee shop was not new. The two had been in a relationship for seven years and had created a business plan for fun in year two. They had talked about it as a goal in five or 10 years, but she made the “mistake” of telling a friend in the neighborhood.
The word got out as David Pudup, owner of Day & Night Heating & Air Conditioning, had retired and was looking to rent out his Arlington Avenue storefront.
“So our five- to 10-year plan turned into, ‘Oh, we’re talking to Dave next week,’” Ms. Szalla said.
The couple got funds together, signed the lease in January, contacted a contractor and were ready to begin work on the space last March. Things were coming together, and they planned a July opening. The coronavirus pandemic had other plans.
“We immediately halted work,” he said, “and waited out before we submitted architectural drawings.”
The city’s Department of Permits, Licenses and Inspections approved their application after a two-month delay. The two held a tiny wedding in his mother’s backyard, and construction began that same week. Already the coffee shop’s opening date was pushed back to September.
The couple were three or four weeks from opening when the PLI department alerted them that it had made a mistake and shouldn’t have approved their plans. Ms. Szalla had just left her job. They ended up calling City Councilman Bruce Kraus, whose district includes Arlington, and he reached out to PLI on their behalf. The department ended up approving the plans as is, saying the designs had been misread, according to Mr. Gladis, eliminating costly revisions.
Once the finishing touches were completed, Hilltop Coffee finally was ready to open when they faced another curveball. In December, Gov. Tom Wolf announced new public health restrictions that closed indoor dining facilities.
“That announcement from Gov. Wolf came three hours after we had announced our opening day,” Mr. Gladis said. “So it really has been quite a year of timing.”
Fortunately, Hilltop Coffee planned to serve mostly to-go orders, and Mr. Gladis emphasized they wanted to be as safe as possible for themselves and customers.
The coffee shop opened Dec. 12, and expectations were low, Ms. Szalla said. But energy was high. She recalled folks had been excited about the new business, walking by to check on progress, and Mr. Gladis said people even stopped in the window to chat with their contractor.
They went through 10 pounds of coffee on the first day and sold out of baked goods. Mr. Gladis noted that coffee shops typically go through 2 to 4 pounds of coffee. Ms. Szalla’s mother showed up at the opening, and they sent her to get more milk.
“Arlington can sometimes think of itself as a bit of a forgotten neighborhood, and so if we’re hoping there’s any takeaway from us opening it’s … if the city is not going to do X, Y and Z and other folks aren’t, then, darn it, we’re going to do it ourselves,” Mr. Gladis said.
The java is local sourced as well. The couple chose as their supplier Creative Coffee, a Downtown roastery. Baked goods sold at Hilltop Coffee come from 350 Bakery on the South Side Slopes. Ms. Szalla said the bakery owners live within walking distance. Some older patrons recalled the days when the location was a candy shop, noticing portions of the old wallpaper kept up to honor the history of the building.
“My aunt had stopped by and said when she first moved here, there were businesses all up and down Arlington Avenue and how exciting it might be that — with the diner and with us — it might start something … where you don’t have to go try to find parking somewhere, drive or, for a lot of people, walk down the hill,” Ms. Szalla said.
Katelyn Shiring, owner of Rainy Days Hair Salon, said that with the salon, Eggs & Moore and Hilltop Coffee, she had seen “a bunch of new faces.”
“Maybe people will recognize us as Arlington and not South Side Slopes,” Ms. Shiring said. “Hopefully, we’ll get a little more help with the community, let alone just being forgotten.”
Amy Rethage, owner of Eggs & Moore, was excited about Hilltop Coffee, saying she immediately went over to buy a gift card. She referred to the opening as “long-awaited” and said there were already instances in which the two businesses had helped each other.
“I think that it’s definitely an excellent thing to have, nice little neighborhood places to go, because it just gives the area another element that we didn’t have at all,” Ms. Rethage said. “I just see it being all good.”
She had been with the diner when it was under a different name and ownership, but she decided to keep it going because there were so many regular customers. She admitted she had always assumed Arlington was isolated from the rest of Pittsburgh.
“Arlington is a nice little community back here, and I was amazed at how it does sort of get you everywhere,” she said. “You can get to [the] South Side, you can get to Carrick, you can get to Mount Oliver. It doesn’t just end back here as one would think if you’re not from the area.”
Mr. Gladis said he and his wife were becoming more familiar with faces and orders and were pleased with the response so far in spite of the pandemic. For instance, they already have had to upgrade their pastry display.
“We definitely feel the love,” he said, “and we want people to feel the love back from us, walking in the door, and feel like, ‘Oh, I’m going to a neighbor’s house to get some coffee.’”
Tyler Dague: rdague@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1569 and on Twitter@rtdague.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.