Michael Bennett remembers feeling goose bumps when the small group of teachers, corrections officers and teens in khaki jumpsuits assembled in the Contact Visiting Room at Allegheny County Jail spontaneously broke out in song.

It was spring 2017, and the Troy Hill resident was still fairly new to teaching creative writing classes to the jail’s teenage occupants through Chatham University’s Words Without Walls program. Established in 2009 to give those in the judicial system a creative outlet, it recently had been expanded to include incarcerated juveniles through their high school English classes. Mr. Bennett, who earned an MFA in creative nonfiction from Chatham, was among those helping them fill slim chapbooks with poems, stories and songs.

Even in jail, kids must be educated according to state standards. In Pittsburgh, Allegheny Intermediate Unit runs a full five-day high school at the jail known as the Academic Institute, with schedules designed to meet graduation requirements.

The kids move between classes in groups, and each of the five classrooms looks like any other learning space except for one small detail: One wall is three-quarters glass while another separating two classrooms doesn’t go to the ceiling. That’s so a corrections officer always can listen and see in, explains Jay Moser, who’s been principal since 2014.

Advertise with us

During each semester, students gather to pass out their work and take turns reading it in front of a mic. That particular day, Mr. Bennett recalls, some decided to also sing songs. One was so catchy that the whole room joined in on the chorus.

The reality of incarceration is being under constant duress. So to see the teens share a few moments of joy outside of Pod 7E, where those under 18 are housed on Second Avenue, was so inspiring, he says. “It was as close to a party as you could get at the jail.”

It got the teacher thinking. He and AIU colleague Kristine Autenreith, who has taught English at the jail for more than a decade, shared a disappointment that no one got to hear the students’ work outside the jail walls. Perhaps, they pondered, they could build on that energy and get the kids to do something more collaborative.

They asked students for input. Ideas flew, followed by requests for permission. By fall semester in 2018, with Warden Orlando Harper on board, they had a project: a play called “ACT 33: Echoes From Pod 7E Maximum Security.”

Mr. Bennett originally thought a series of monologues in the vein of Anna Deavere Smith’s “Notes From the Field” might work so the kids wouldn’t have to worry about plot. It was a total failure. “They were hesitant to share personal stories because it made them vulnerable to stress from various sources.”

Advertise with us

So they changed gears, prompted in part by reading excerpts from August Wilson plays, including “Jitney.” They were onto something.

Mr. Bennett says, “The idea of creating characters totally shifted their energy” and made them more willing to speak about conflicts on and off the pod.

Working on smartboards and dry-erase boards, the teachers helped their students understand literary elements such as character development, dialogue, audience and plotting. But the kids are responsible for every word on the page. That includes the play’s title, which refers to the law that allows them to be charged in adult courts.

Passed in 1995 as an amendment to the Pennsylvania Juvenile Act, Act 33 allows kids under the age 18 to be automatically tried as adults for serious felonies such as robbery, aggravated assault and voluntary manslaughter.

As a result, on any given day in Western Pennsylvania, anywhere from a handful to more than a dozen youth between the ages of 15 to 17 are housed in the Allegheny County Jail while facing what’s known as “direct file” charges in criminal court, says Mr. Moser.

Advertise with us

Writing a play can prove formidable to even seasoned professionals. It’s even more daunting when it involves a group of writers with varying voices and opinions — and when said group is constantly changing. Some juveniles, Ms. Autenreith notes, are on the pod only for a few weeks, others for more than a year. Some rotate in and out.

“A lot of people would think about all the reasons it couldn’t be done,” she says. Mr. Bennett thought about all the reasons it should.

The teens, she says, very much wanted to get their voices heard. The only time many of them get any recognition is when their mugshot is shown on the news. “They wanted people to know that they’re also intelligent thinkers. They wanted people to know they exist.”

In all, 45 juveniles ended up contributing over the course of the nearly two-year project. They finished a three-act draft with seven characters in early March 2020 and even got the perfect theater company interested in a live reading that spring, followed by a live performance in the fall: Homewood’s Alumni Theater Company, a performing arts program serving Black youth in grades six through 12. A grant from Heinz Endowments would help with the cost.

Executive director Hallie Donner says she jumped at the chance because the script was so moving and gets to the heart of what’s happening with real teenagers. The fact it was written by kids incarcerated at the time makes it even more touching.

Advertise with us

“It gives you insight into the minds of these characters who have something very important to say,” she says.

Mr. Bennett couldn’t have been happier. “Their whole mission is to amplify Black voices,” he says, and all but one of the “ACT 33” playwrights were Black — a fact that speaks to the disparities between Black and white youth, he says.

Then came COVID-19, and the project with Alumni Theater screeched to a halt. After the reading was put off and then put off again, they eventually decided to go with a virtual reading instead of a live performance. It premiered through streaming on Facebook Live on Jan. 16 and can be viewed on YouTube.

Brent Jernigan, a 17-year-old junior from Penn Hills who has been with ATC since fourth grade, plays Maniac, an inmate charged with a double murder.

As a young African American in Pittsburgh, he’s grown up hearing stories in the news about kids who commit crimes and end up in jail. The play, he says, gives people a chance to see what they’re going through.

Advertise with us

“It’s a story you don’t often hear, or that people don’t want to hear,” he says.

The reading was directed by Pittsburgh native and Chatham grad Alona Williams, who has been involved with ATC since the sixth grade. Directing on Zoom was more challenging than she thought, especially since they had few rehearsals. “But the words and the story are important.

“These real-life things people go through deserve a platform,” she says. She hopes, along with Mr. Bennett and Ms. Autenreith, there will be lots of positive feedback so the play, which is still in early draft, gets even better and its writers are uplifted. Plans to show a recording of the play at the jail are in the works, and the teachers also hope to get a copy to the families of the contributors, four of whom have died since leaving the jail and are memorialized in the credits.

An even bigger goal, said Words Without Walls program coordinator Sarah Shotland, is to bring the play to life on a stage, so the writers and audience can experience “that magic of theater.”

Licia Lentz, the AIU’s director of alternative education, says she hopes the reading will help initiate conversations about needed changes and improvements to the juvenile justice system. “I am ready for those who will say how dare you give them a voice, because their voices got stifled before they even got there.”

Advertise with us

Because the project took so long, Ms. Autenreith was sure the kids at some point would tire of it. “But the intensity they had, and their passion, really surprised me,” she says.

She also was struck by the level of introspection the play generated. The depth of discussion during the process — “Why would a character do that? Is it morally right? What’s the smart thing to do?” — echoed that of a counseling session. The students decided what felt authentic.

Stephon, a former juvenile inmate who contributed to the work and participated in a Q&A after the virtual reading, called the play perfect. “They had it down to a T,” he said, adding, “I hope people hear this and understand there are problems in jail.”

Just last week, Ms. Autenreich says, a former student was returned to jail. One of the first things out of his mouth was “What’s going on with ‘Act 33’?”

“It’s their identity now,” she says. “It’s not our project, it’s theirs.”

Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay.