“Right plant, right place” is a key principle for gardening success.
Choosing plants suited to the available light, water, space and soil greatly improves the chances that they will thrive. Most nursery plant tags provide this information. If they don’t, a quick online search using the plant’s botanical name will usually fill in the gaps. When it comes to soil requirements, however, the most common phrase you are likely to encounter is “moist, well-drained soil.”
Unfortunately, few gardeners are blessed with the well-drained, loamy soil that most plants prefer. More than half of the soils in the United States are predominantly clay, and soils in southwestern Pennsylvania are no exception.
Soil is comprised of sand, silt and clay. Clay particles are the smallest of the three and are so fine that individual particles are invisible to the naked eye. When wet, clay compacts easily, leaving little pore space for air and water. As a result, clay soil is heavy and dense, slick and sticky when wet, and hard as brick when dry. It drains poorly, causing water to pool on the surface. Plant roots may rot during prolonged wet conditions and struggle to penetrate the soil during dry spells.
It is no wonder that clay has a reputation as one of the most challenging soil types for gardeners. Yet there is no reason for despair.
Clay soils are generally quite fertile because they retain nutrients well — often better than sandy soils. While fertility is not usually the issue, a soil test is essential to determine pH levels and identify any nutrient deficiencies. A basic soil fertility test kit is available through the Penn State Extension Agricultural Analytical Services Laboratory, either online or through your local county extension office.
To improve soil structure and promote better water infiltration, drainage and root growth, avoid compaction and add organic matter regularly. Minimize foot traffic and equipment use in planting areas. Never work clay soil when it is wet, and avoid excessive tilling. Apply a fresh layer of compost in spring, and in autumn, top-dress beds with shredded leaves, grass clippings and other garden debris that will break down over winter. Mulch with organic materials such as bark, sawdust or wood chips that will gradually decompose and enrich the soil.
Soils tend to revert to their native state without ongoing care. Meaningful improvement takes time, consistent effort and patience.
Choosing the right plants is equally important. Many trees, shrubs, and perennials — particularly native species — tolerate and even thrive in clay soil. Plants with vigorous or adaptable root systems often perform well. Avoid species that are already difficult to grow in our area or that require narrowly defined growing conditions. Clay soils can fluctuate between very wet and very dry, so plants must be able to tolerate those extremes. Incorporating native plants that are well adapted to local conditions also provides food, shelter and habitat for pollinators and other wildlife, strengthening the local ecosystem.
Deer browsing is a common problem in our region. There is no such thing as a deer-proof plant, and the tender foliage of even the most deer-resistant plants needs protection when young. In the sample of native favorites below that perform reliably in clay soil, an asterisk marks those generally considered to have some degree of deer tolerance.
Trees
American holly* (Ilex opaca); American sweetgum* (Liquidambar styraciflua); Eastern arborvitae (Thuja occidentalis); Eastern redbud* (Cercis canadensis); flowering dogwood (Cornus florida); honeylocust* (Gleditsia triacanthos); red maple (Acer rubrum); river birch* (Betula nigra); swamp white oak (Quercus bicolor); white fringetree* (Chionanthus virginicus).
Shrubs
American beautyberry (Callicarpa americana); arrowwood viburnum (Viburnum dentatum); downy serviceberry (Amelanchier arborea); ‘Gro-Low’ fragrant sumac* (Rhus aromatica); ninebark (Physocarpus opulifolius); red twig dogwood (Cornus sericea); shrubby St. John’s wort (Hypericum prolificum); smooth hydrangea (Hydrangea arborescens); spicebush* (Lindera benzoin); sweet pepperbush (Clethra alnifolia); winterberry (Ilex verticillata).
Perennials
Beardtongue* (Penstemon digitalis); black-eyed Susan* (Rudbeckia fulgida); blazing star (Liatris spicata); blue false indigo* (Baptisia australis); garden phlox (Phlox paniculata); New England aster (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae); oxeye sunflower (Heliopsis helianthoides); purple coneflower (Echinacea purpurea); sneezeweed* (Helenium autumnale); spiderwort* (Tradescantia virginiana); swamp milkweed* (Asclepias incarnata).
For additional recommendations, see “Gardening in Heavy Clay Soil” from the Missouri Botanical Garden’s William T. Kemper Center for Home Gardening at missouribotanicalgarden.org.
Maureen Karl is a Penn State Master Gardener. This volunteer program supports the outreach mission of Penn State Extension and provides research-based information on best practices in sustainable horticulture and environmental stewardship. For more information, contact the Penn State Extension of Allegheny County at alleghenymg@psu.edu or 412-482-3476.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.