The snow softly falls on a herd of deer in your backyard. It’s a beautiful scene, but we all know the damage deer can do to a garden. The question is: How can we peacefully co-exist with deer in our landscapes?
Several tactics can decrease the damage caused by deer in the landscape:
• Selecting plants less appealing to these herbivores.
• Employing deer repellents.
• Using fencing to keep deer on the outside looking in.
Why do deer eat what they eat?
Deer have favorite plants that please their palates, including tulips, hostas and Eastern arborvitae (Thuja occidentalis). However, if deer get hungry enough, they will eat anything, including deer-resistant plants.
Observe areas of your garden to determine the route and plants deer frequent. They return to locations where they have found food before. Evaluate which plants have occasional or minimal damage versus those that deer decimate.
Their food sources change with the seasons and local geography. A plant not commonly browsed during the summer is more at risk in long, cold winters. Deep or persistent snow covering the ground will also cause deer to seek plants previously unscathed.
Deer damage has a rough or torn appearance. It does not look cleanly clipped. Deer have no upper incisors and must grasp and tear leaves and buds from plants. Damage is more likely to occur when deer populations are high and environmental conditions are stressful, especially when we experience cold temperatures and snow cover. They are creatures of habit and often return to the same area.
What are deer-resistant plants?
Deer-resistant plants have common characteristics such as hairy or rough stems and leaves, or the presence of aromatic compounds in the stems or leaves.
Aromatic plants including herbs and shrubs such as boxwood (Buxus spp.) and bayberry (Morella pennsylvanica) are not to deer’s liking. The texture of lamb's ear (Stachys byzantina) and ornamental grasses deter browsing by deer.
A Rutgers University website (njaes.rutgers.edu/deer-resistant-plants/) rates plants according to deer resistance. Another good resource is the Plant Finder found on the Missouri Botanical Garden’s website (missouribotanicalgarden.org).
How about deer repellents?
Deer repellents can be helpful in dissuading deer from feeding on plants by coating foliage in scents and tastes that deer find distasteful. Repellents may not work where deer traffic is heavy. Act early to reduce damage.
Use rubber gloves when applying the repellent and apply the product from a height of 6 feet since deer browse from the top down. Use repellents when temperatures are above 40 degrees; they have minimal effect in the winter as application in freezing temperatures is difficult.
The University of Maryland Cooperative Extension tested eight name-brand deer repellents and found they all had similar effectiveness levels. Concentrates are available and are most cost-effective if you need to spray frequently. The results can be found at extension.umd.edu.
Deer repellents need to be continuously reapplied, and deer can acclimate to a repellent’s scent or taste. Keep monitoring whether the repellent is working and switch brands if deer start munching on treated plants. Use repellents early and often for best success.
Add fencing to keep deer out
First, check in with your municipality for guidelines on the height and placement of fencing. Get any applicable permits before installing a permanent fence. Appropriately designed fencing is the most effective method to keep deer at bay.
Know that deer will find a 4-foot fence a nuisance and can easily jump them. A 6-foot fence can still be easily scaled by deer, but a solid fence, such as stockade or board-on-board style can be effective as deer don’t relish the idea of jumping a fence when they don’t know what’s on the other side. An 8-foot-tall mesh fence will generally keep deer out, but they are able to jump them if motivated. It’s the most commonly recommended fence height for deterring deer.
Another option is a double fence. Choose an attractive 4- or 5-foot split-rail lined with mesh or chain-link, picket or board-on-board fence to surround an area of the garden. Erect a second fence of the same height inside of the first one. The inner fence can be made of less expensive material, either mesh or wire. This method takes advantage of the poor depth perception of deer, and you won’t need a larger, more dominant fence in your landscape.
Combine methods for best success
No one option is going to magically make deer disappear. Fences can be a major expense. Repellents require consistent application. Plants that deer disdain, including peonies and lilacs, can still be browsed by fawns or very hungry deer. Once deer find a tasty garden, getting them to leave is a challenge.
But, with determination and effort many gardeners are peacefully co-existing with deer in their landscapes.
Denise Grabner is a Penn State Master Gardener. This volunteer program supports the outreach mission of Penn State Extension and provides research-based information on best practices in sustainable horticulture and environmental stewardship. Information: alleghenymg@psu.edu or 412-482-3476.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.