It's nearly impossible to have dogs and a nice front lawn.
As my colleague Sandy Feather recently wrote: "A dog can be trained to go in an area of your yard set aside for that purpose -- if you can train yourself to accept that the grass in that section is not going to be perfect." She goes on to suggest removing the grass altogether and putting down bark mulch or pea gravel in that spot.
We have a section like that at our house; it's a steep slope mostly covered with English ivy in the back. But our three dogs aren't mountain goats, and having a perfect front lawn isn't worth watching them roll down the hill.
So we're left with the question: Where should they pee at 6 a.m. when there's no time for a walk? The answer is usually our small, flat front lawn. Considering how often they use it as a potty, the lawn doesn't look too bad when the snow melts. This spring, I counted about two dozen dead spots in a lawn that measures about 35 by 20 feet.
My usual approach is to attack with a thatching rake and tear out the dead grass, followed by about 50 pounds of pelletized limestone to raise the soil pH. (A local turf expert told me years ago that Western Pennsylvania lawns tend to be acidic because of the high clay content.) Then I rake mushroom manure and peat moss into the bare spots and overseed the entire lawn, followed by starter fertilizer.
This year, after spending a weekend with the thatching rake, I decided to ask Ms. Feather whether my approach made sense. As a Post-Gazette garden columnist and Penn State Cooperative Extension agent, she knows much more than I ever will about gardening and lawn care. Here is what she said:
"When was the last time you had your soil tested? I do not recommend applying limestone and fertilizers without testing the soil first so you know how much of what your soil needs. Since the issue with dog urine is nitrogen rather than acidity, I do not see that applying limestone would make much difference. Perhaps the availability, but nitrogen availability is not as limited by pH as some nutrients and goes down as pH gets lower.
"It does make sense to rake out and reseed the dead areas, then mulch with compost. Be careful with mushroom manure as it can be 'hot' if not composted prior to use. It is also high in salts, which can be deadly to new seedlings. Finally, if your soil pH is low, mushroom compost can help since it has an average pH of 8.0. Perhaps incorporating it into the top few inches of soil prior to planting would be the best use.
"Peat moss tends to dry out and become water-repellent once it does, which is not a good situation for seedlings. Plus, if your soil pH is low, it tends to acidify.
"Finished, homemade compost with a near neutral pH is a better choice for mulching grass seed. Some communities collect leaves in fall and compost them, then make the finished compost available to residents for a nominal fee. I think some communities still offer it for free if you haul it."
So, I guess I'll find another use for my mushroom manure and peat moss, and get a soil test. Here's how:
In Allegheny County, consumer soil test kits cost $12 each and come with detailed instructions for taking a good soil sample and information. Customers ordering multiple kits at one time pay $9 each for the additional kits. Send a check made payable to: Penn State Extension, 400 N. Lexington St., Pittsburgh 15208. Write Attn. Soil Test Kit in the lower left corner of the envelope.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.