The idea of a Pittsburgh botanic garden sprouted like white trillium in the fertile imagination of Frank Pizzi and five or six others in 1988.

Like trillium, a wildflower that takes several years to flower in our native forests, a series of outdoor display gardens doesn't happen quickly. But 22 years? That's more like the sauerkraut Mr. Pizzi and friends shared that evening at Max's Allegheny Tavern on the North Side: It comes from slow, hard work whose result looks and tastes nothing like the leafy cabbage it started with.

This summer, volunteers spent several Saturdays cutting trails through woods on the 452-acre site in North Fayette and Collier that is the Pittsburgh Botanic Garden. In the spring, they will start to plant native trees among the tulip poplars, red and white oaks, sugar and red maples, elms, cherry trees and dogwoods that cover the site.

Within two years, this section is to be open as the Appalachian plateau and cove forest (naturally) and Eastern European woods, part of Phase 1 of the garden's master plan. Within five years, there will also be a visitors center, Asian woods and pond, English woods and a family garden including the Fred Rogers Garden of Make Believe. Officials project 300,000 visitors per year by 2015.

Advertise with us

Greg Nace, hired as the garden's president in April, reveled in the first signs of actual garden creation.

"I came to the realization, oh my God, we have a garden!" he said this summer.

The trails were even more satisfying for Mr. Pizzi, curator of horticulture and grounds at the Pittsburgh Zoo, and Lindsay Bond Totten, who was the botanic garden president until 2008. Both former board members continue to support the nonprofit organization they helped create.

"I'm so thrilled," Ms. Totten said. "It was 20 years of heavy lifting. I felt like it was time for someone else with the energy to take it the next leg."

But what does this mean to you? Why does Pittsburgh need a $32 million-plus botanic garden?

Advertise with us

The short answer is that every other sizable city has one, including Chicago, Cleveland, Morgantown, even Youngstown. Philadelphia and the surrounding Delaware Valley has 32 of them, including one of the best and biggest in the country, Longwood Gardens. Mr. Pizzi, who grew up in the Philadelphia suburb of Narbeth, said his hometown had a head start on his adopted home.

"Philadelphia has a history of public horticulture and gardening going back to the 1700s. Gardening outside of vegetables wasn't as widespread in Western Pennsylvania."

Phipps Conservatory, whose former director was among the garden's organizers, added "botanical gardens" to its name in the mid-1990s. Phipps is not currently involved in the botanic garden but may be someday, said executive director Richard V. Piacentini.

"From what I understand, it will be created in such a way that it will be very different from Phipps," he said.

With its indoor glasshouse and small outdoor gardens on 15 acres, Phipps cannot take the place of a public display garden, Mr. Pizzi said.

Advertise with us

In truth, the Pittsburgh Botanic Garden got its start long before horticulturists and public gardening experts started talking about it over beer and bratwurst in 1988. Seventeen years earlier, the McGill family sold about 85 acres of farmland and woods toward what would become Settlers Cabin Park. Allegheny County had more land than it needed for the park and in the late 1990s offered the parcel to a Florida developer to build a golf course. When those plans fell through, county Commissioner Larry Dunn offered it and adjoining land to the botanic garden.

How to give the garden a Pittsburgh identity

The Pittsburgh Botanic Garden now under way in Collier and North Fayette will have many of the same features as older public gardens in eastern Pennsylvania, Atlanta, Chicago, Los Angeles, etc. Parterre, children's and Asian gardens are all popular attractions and will be well represented there. But what will stamp it as PITTSBURGH's botanic garden?

How about ethnic fruit and vegetable gardens reflecting the immigrants who settled and continue to shape this old coal patch/steel town? Think of them as garden versions of the nationality rooms at the University of Pittsburgh.

I got the idea from a TV documentary about H.J. Heinz and the Sewickley Italian Garden Tour organized by Mary Menniti and The Italian Garden Project. Mr. Heinz got his start selling produce from his German parents' vegetable garden. The retired Italian immigrants featured on the tour grow the same varieties of tomatoes, figs, beans, peaches and other produce that their fathers and grandfathers did, using centuries-old techniques from the old country.

Advertise with us

This is the way our ancestors gardened. With seeds and advice from local gardeners and the financial support of local corporations, foundations and nationality groups, visitors would discover a piece of Pittsburgh they'd never forget. And we would all know why Nonno's tomatoes tasted so good.

Ms. Totten and other board members were delighted with its size -- in the top 10 for U.S. botanic gardens -- its proximity to the Parkway West and its mostly level, handicapped-accessible land.

"The creeks looked clear, it was flat on top. It seemed perfect," she said.

Then they discovered the unseen damage that nearly a century of underground and strip coal mining and oil wells had done to the land. In 2004, Hurricane Ivan flooded the mines, and drove home just how bad it was, with acid runoff and subsidence. Experts said it would require years and millions of dollars in mine reclamation and remediation to create a garden that could use on-site water.

Elizabeth McGill Ellis, 75, of Allentown said her family had owned the land since the mid-1800s but did not own the mineral rights. Growing up here, she said the sulfurous water was fit for chickens and other livestock but they couldn't drink it.

Advertise with us

"My dad brought back jugs of water from my aunt's house in Oakdale," she recalled.

Her father, William J. McGill, had always hoped the land would be reserved for public use.

"When my dad died in 1988, he was sad that they hadn't developed it," Mrs. Ellis said.

She and her mother, Ethel Henderson McGill, were proud that the botanic garden decided to reclaim their land and make it this country's first truly sustainable botanic garden. Design work was under way when her mother died in 1999.

"I hope she died knowing that the farm was going to be used to benefit people," Mrs. Ellis said.

Advertise with us

The reclamation work is slow and expensive and will total millions of dollars. Garden officials said the massive reclamation project is the main reason it has taken so long for the botanic garden to get to this point. Government and foundation grants will cover its cost. Fundraising for garden development should be easier, garden officials believe, and will begin in earnest next year.

Board chairman Bill Worms said when he joined the board four years ago, garden officials were still looking for a company that could remove the remaining coal while also reclaiming the land and treating the acidic groundwater. Mashuda Corp. of Cranberry has been at work for two years now.

Turning a coal mine into a self-sustaining botanic garden is a major accomplishment and perfectly fits Pittsburgh's growing "green" reputation, he said.

"This is a feel-good story. We're taking land that is unusable and scarred and making it better," said Mr. Worms, a vice president in marketing at Bayer Materials Science. "I'm disappointed that more of Pittsburgh isn't behind this."

Though he grows tomatoes and other vegetables at his home in Robinson, he doesn't consider himself a garden expert. He believes the Pittsburgh Botanic Garden will have something for everyone, including an ornamental garden for wedding receptions and other celebrations, places where families can learn and play in the dirt, and plots where people can learn how to grow vegetables, native trees and shrubs and other types of plants. And there will be plenty of pristine woods for avid hunters like Mr. Worms.

Advertise with us

"If I don't shoot a deer or even see one, I'm still happy to be outdoors," he said. "My worst day in the woods is better than my best day in the office. ... This can be a getaway, a place where people can hike and not be disturbed by anyone."

Reconnecting people with the earth, especially parents and children, is the job of Cindy Tyler, owner of Terra Design Studios. A Homestead native and veteran designer of children's and family gardens, she aims to create spaces where children can climb and dig and learn.

"Kids learn through natural play," she said. "Many of them don't know where their food comes from."

Though her family garden won't look like the sets of "Mr. Rogers' Neighborhood," it may have familiar characters such as Daniel the striped tiger and X the Owl, and draw on Mr. Rogers' educational strategies. Parents will have to get involved, too.

"We want them to be engaged, not just sit on a bench and watch their kids run around," Ms. Tyler said.

Advertise with us

At the Pittsburgh Zoo, children are quicker than their parents at grasping the connection between plants and animals that use them for food and shelter, Mr. Pizzi said. They understand it instinctively when they're surrounded by nature, whether it's a botanic garden or a natural forest.

"Our parents used to say to us: 'Just go outside and play!' Nobody does that anymore," he said.

"Kids need to simply go outside and interact with bugs and birds. And maybe actually get their hands dirty."

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.