Beware, all you self-anointed garden gurus, Jeff Gillman has arrived to dispel myths, rumors and just downright bad information given out by the so-called experts. Along the way he has managed to create a highly readable, intelligent and scientifically based discussion on the benefits and, yes, drawbacks of organic gardening in his new book, "The Truth About Organic Gardening" (Timber Press, $12.95 paper).

Mr. Gillman is an associate professor in the department of horticultural science at the University of Minnesota, where he researches plant production and teaches courses on nursery management and pesticide use. He also is the author of "The Truth About Garden Remedies."

Both of his books should be required reading for anyone who touts organic methods as completely "safe."

However, he doesn't espouse the indiscriminate spraying of pesticides and fungicides, either synthetic or organic.

Advertise with us

The answer, as he sees it, resides somewhere in the middle.

"The problem I find is with the synthetic [gardeners], they will read the label and be very careful in how they are applying it. If it says organic, they just feel it's safe to throw around," he says. "As far as organic gardeners, the ones who just ignore pesticides are fine. The problem is the ones who feel that if it says organic it's safe to use, and that's not always the case."

Many people equate organic with safe, which is not always true.

He cites Rotenone, an organic pesticide that is extremely toxic, as an example of something that is quite dangerous but organic. Or, as he says in his book after listing the pros and cons of its use: "Why would any sane person use this pesticide?"

Even things such as insecticidal soaps and the much-touted organic product Neem can cause problems. Soaps can burn leaves if not applied carefully, and Neem can cause allergic reactions in some people.

Advertise with us

The other variable is that many of the organic compounds can require multiple applications, where the use of a synthetic often can nip the problem with one spritz and could make a lesser impact on the environment.

Educate yourself before you do anything, says Mr. Gillman.

And his book makes that easy. Chapters such as "Understanding Pesticides," "Weed Control," "Insect Control" "Disease Control" and "Organic Practices and Our Ecosystem" lay everything out clearly, giving readers the benefits and drawbacks of each example.

"The bottom line is 99 percent of the time [chemical use] is not necessary, it's just that someone wants to save a plant that they have no business saving. We could control a lot of problems in our garden if we just let the plant die," he says.

Keeping the garden healthy through the use of renewable organic fertilizers and proper watering will stem many problems before they start. Choosing plants that don't need a lot of coddling is another way to make gardening easier. Some crops, like hybrid tea roses, for instance, are extremely difficult to grow organically. "It's possible, but it would be a bear," he says.

Advertise with us

He also looked into products available to gardeners, such as mycorrhizae fungi, touted as a way to enhance the growth of plants without chemical fertilizers, and hydrogels, which when added to potting mixture are supposed to reduce watering, and came up with some surprising advice: Save your money.

"The hydrogels just do not save you from watering. ... I'm just telling you what the research says."

As for mycorrhizae fungi, "You don't even know if you are buying live fungi," he says. "If it makes you feel good, go ahead. It sure won't hurt anything."

Which is really what Mr. Gillman wants -- First, do no harm.

Mr. Gillman also has a degree in entomology, so you might not be surprised that he's a proponent of these varied and useful creatures. He wonders why so many feel compelled to kill every bug out there.

Advertise with us

"You have to ask yourself, 'Why are you killing these insects anyway? Are they really doing that much damage? Why can't we let the plants lose some of their leaves? Why is that so bad?' "

As for insects in the garden, he points out that some are better than others. He sees them as a useful way to control insect pests, in some instances. Again, education is the key.

"If we have a plant that is always full of insect and disease problems, do we really need to grow that plant in the garden?" he asks. "I want [gardeners] to think about what they are doing. That may mean they make choices I don't make, but that's OK if they consider the consequences of their actions."