In the world of horticulture, nothing created more of a buzz than the purchase and eventual demise of famed Heronswood Nursery, a mail-order operation in Kingston, Wash.
Founded in 1987 by plantsman extraordinaire Dan Hinkley, the nursery had for many "plant geeks" become a Mecca of sorts on the West Coast. The photoless, book-like catalog that Mr. Hinkley wrote each year was some of the finest reading available on newly discovered and unusual plants.
Of course, I have to also note that many of the plants offered for sale wouldn't begin to survive in our Pennsylvania climate. Having ordered from them, I can also say the merchandise was small. Still, gardeners tend to be dreamers, and the Heronswood catalog was as close to nirvana you could get on a cold winter's night.
Six years ago, Mr. Hinkley sold his business to George Ball of the W. Atlee Burpee family. At the time, he said he was overwhelmed with the everyday work of the nursery.
Heronswood sputtered along until May 2006 when Mr. Ball closed the Washington operation and moved what remained to Warminster, Bucks County. The result was complete hysteria in the gardening community. Everybody had something to say: Bloggers burned up the Internet and garden writers churned out miles of opinions, and most of it was anti-Ball.
The mailings of the "new" Heronswood catalog for 2007 reignited the controversy, and regardless of where you come down in the argument, you must admit that the new catalog is a pale pretender to the old.
For better or worse, the color catalog now resembles other upscale mail-order nursery offerings such as White Flower Farms. The catalog also has shrunk considerably in the breadth of plants offered.
But the simple facts remain: Mr. Hinkley decided to sell the operation, and Mr. Ball, the new owner, had the right to do with it what he wanted.
Tony Avent, owner of Plant Delights nursery, another popular mail-order emporium, says that most mail-order operations have a life expectancy of about 10 to 15 years. Heronswood as we knew it survived longer. For that, gardeners should remain thankful.
Here's the lesson: If you find a mail-order nursery you love, patronize it and spread the word. Only making money will keep it open. Besides, purchasing plants through the mail is a great way to get interesting and rare specimens for your garden. Most of these operations have return policies, and once you start getting boxes on the porch, there is no going back.
Here are some of the catalogs that have arrived in my mailbox lately, including a few favorites:
Arrowhead Alpines, Box 857, Fowlerville, MI 48836; 1-517-223-3581 (www.arrowheadalpines.com): I love this catalog, which has loads of unusual and rare plants. As a bonus, they are coming from a colder climate than ours, and so most of them will survive here. Lots of reading, no photos, so this is definitely for the plant nut who doesn't need pictures.
Bluestone Perennials, 7211 Middle Ridge Road, Madison, OH 44057; 1-800-852-5243 (www.bluestoneperennials.com): This is where you go to fill in those bare spots in the garden. The company has a wide selection of the more common perennials, and it usually sells them in groups of three, which all gardeners know is the correct number to plant to achieve a pleasing grouping.
Brent and Becky's Bulbs, 7900 Daffodil Lane, Gloucester, VA 23061; 1-804-693-3966 (www.brentandbeckysbulbs.com): I've ordered from here for years. Very interesting bulbs and tubers on the inventory.
Busse Gardens, 17160 245th Ave., NW, Big Lake, MN 55309; 1-800-544-3192 (www.bussegardens.com): If you want some cold-hardy plants, well then, Minnesota is the place to go. This line-illustrated catalog is filled with perennials.
Fairweather Gardens, Box 330, Greenwich, NJ 08323; 1-856-451-6261 (www.fairweathergardens.com): $5 for a two-year subscription. The Aquilegia flabellata v. pumila 'Kurilensis Rosea' is calling my name. This lovely catalog combines great descriptions with color photographs. Worth the price even if you don't buy anything.
Forest Farm, 990 Tetherow Road, William, OR 97544; 1-541-846-7269 (www.forestfarm.com): $5. Another great read for those truly interested in plants. This thick offering, the size of a paperback novel, is sparsely illustrated with line drawings. It has no photographs, but there are scads of rare and unusual plants to peruse.
Girard Nursery, Box 428, Geneva, OH 44041; 1-440-466-2881 (www.girardnurseries.com): Another of the great nurseries that are speckled throughout Lake County in the Cleveland area. Well known for its azaleas and conifers, this is the place to look for great accent plants. It sends out a stapled plant list for those who don't like to shop online.
Heirloom Roses, 24062 Riverside Drive NE, St. Paul, OR 97137; 1-800-820-0465 (www.heirloomroses.com): $5. A great catalog to drool over for rose lovers, and who doesn't love roses? The categories include English, winter-hardy, fragrant, old garden and miniatures, to name just a few. Lovely color photographs, and the roses are own-root as opposed to grafted varieties. Own-root roses tend to survive Pittsburgh winter weather better.
Heronswood Nursery, 300 Park Ave., Warminster, PA 18974; 1-877-674-4714 (www.heronswood.com): Although not the Heronswood of old, this catalog has some nice offerings, including some interesting hellebores and arisaema collections. The prices are reasonable, and most of the plants will survive in our zone.
Klehm's Song Sparrow Farm & Nursery, 13101 East Rye Road, Avalon, WI 53505; 1-800-553-3715 (www.songsparrow.com): Long a place to get special peonies, Klehm's has also grown into a purveyor of rare and specialty perennials, trees and shrubs. Great selection of hosta and daylilies, along with many very interesting woody ornamentals.
Logee's, 141 North St., Danielson, CT 06239; 1-888-330-8038 (www.logees.com): If you are in the market for tropical plants either for containers or for use as annuals in the garden, Logee's is the place to go. It is a large selection of very interesting and unusual plants. However, you can save some cash by buying the more common plants locally.
Nor'East Miniature Roses, Box 440, Arroyo Grande, CA 93421; 1-800-426-6485 (www.noreast-miniroses.com): These little plants really do well in my garden. Many people grow them in pots. However you grow them, they are definitely worth some space. This little catalog is a great introduction.
Oakes Daylilies, Box 268 Corryton, TN 37721; 1-800-532-9545 (www.oakesdaylilies.com): If you aren't a collector, this is the place to get great-big whompin' daylilies at a great prices. The plants are huge, and the selection is large. This well-illustrated catalog is a good place for beginners or those wanting to fill in the garden.
Plant Delights Nursery, Inc., Juniper Level Botanic Garden, 9241 Sauls Road, Raleigh, NC 27603; 1-919-772-4794 (www.plantdelights.com): Catalog price: 10 stamps or a box of chocolates. Yes, owner Tony Avent is serious -- perhaps about the chocolates and certainly about his plants. But you'd never know it.
This catalog is probably one of the most anticipated of the season; it's chock-full of interesting plants and hilarious commentary. Or as the plantsman himself says, "The majority of the text was written by Tony Avent, who is solely responsible for its absurd nature and content."
White Flower Farm, Box 50, Litchfield, CT 06759; 1-800-503-9624 (www.whiteflowerfarm.com). Almost everyone is familiar with this 56-year-old operation. Although I find the plant material fairly mundane and the prices high, it's a beautiful catalog, which counts for something.
Peony "Burnished Bronze" from Klehm's.
Click photo for larger image.More spring gardening news:
Inspiration for gardeners, gadgeteers at Cleveland show
Growing with Phipps: Yes, it's frosty outside, but you can grow tropical fruits inside
Q&A with Sandy Feather: Rose bush shows symptoms of damaging midge
Gardening news briefsSpike the garden with tropical flowers
Helleborus x nigercors 'Green Heron' from Heronswood Nursery.
Click photo for larger image.
Klehm's Song Sparrow Farm & Nursery catalog features the peony 'Tecumseh.'
Click photo for larger image.
On the Heronswood Nursery cover is the new 'Paris polyphylla.'
Click photo for larger image.
Arrowhead Alpines features cones from the conifer Abies koreana x lasiocarpa.
Click photo for larger image.
The spring catalog for Tony Avent's Plant Delights Nursery features his trademark off-the-wall humor.
Click photo for larger image.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.