Bill Wade, Post-Gazette
Tree pruned by the electric company on Kleber Street in Brighton Heights.
By Susan Banks, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Nobody, including the electric company, likes the look of trees harshly pruned under electric lines. That may sound shocking -- no pun intended -- but it's true.
Edward R. Hasselkrus, University of Wisconsin
"Regent" Japanese tree lilac.
Click photo for larger image.Related article
Matching the plant with the space
Vote now
Have roadside trees in your neighborhood been poorly trimmed by utility or municipal crews?
[Poll ends 10/21/06]
Jennifer Arkett, manager of vegetation management for Duquesne Light, admits those pruning cuts don't look nice. But they are done correctly, meaning to industry standards, and alleviate the problem of wire interference while doing no harm to the tree.
Don't blame the light company, she says. Blame the homeowner or municipality who planted an incorrect tree in that spot. The best solution seems to be to choose a tree that won't overgrow its allotted space in the first place.
Of course, planting incorrect trees under wires is something that has been going on since the invention of the telegraph in 1844, says Ms. Arkett. Too many consumers have the mind-set that, because it takes years for a tree to mature, they won't be around to deal with the fallout when it gets too big.
"People don't really know [about the trees they select]," says Ms. Arkett. "It's so easy not to look ahead. Too many people live in the short term, especially when it comes to trees."
And, unfortunately, it's left to the municipality or utility to deal with the tree once it becomes a problem.
In these days of shrinking budgets, there are still a few municipalities that attempt to "curb" the planting of incorrect tree species.
Although the City of Pittsburgh has no money to plant trees, it will allow homeowners to do so at their own expense. Before that happens, officials require that the space be assessed by the Forestry Division, which must approve the tree choice. (For more information, call the Department of Public Works, Forestry Division, at 412-665-3625.)
In Mt. Lebanon, residents are prohibited from planting anything within the street right of way, which is typically about 25 feet back from the center line of the street, says Rudy Sukal, superintendent of public works. The municipality has about 10,000 street trees, a head forester and three full-time employees. They remove, prune and plant trees as necessary, using primarily Hedge maples (Acer campestre) in areas around power lines.
Crafton, meanwhile, requires its residents to apply for a permit to plant in utility right-of-ways and must approve the tree selection.
Sewickley has a very active Tree Commission, which meets once a month. Residents must apply to have a tree planted in utility right-of-ways. The choice then must be approved. Either the resident or the borough will plant the tree.
Sewickley is one of the few municipalities that has a tree budget of about $65,000 to $70,000, used to plant more than 100 trees a year.
"We have a general listing of approved trees," says borough manager Kevin Flannery. "We look to see if it's a compatible tree for that particular block."
Sewickley strives to make sure there are a wide variety of species represented on their quiet tree-lined streets.
Most other municipalities polled have no ordinances on the books regarding planting curb-side trees, which leaves the choices and the blame for overgrown trees squarely on the homeowner.
But no matter who makes the choice, says Ms. Arkett of Duquesne Light, when the tree becomes a problem and the utility company shows up to prune, neighbors are apt to blame the arborist for a lousy-looking job.
"We have the responsibility to maintain a safe and reliable electric service. A V-cut doesn't look natural to me either, and I'm a utility arborist," says Ms. Arkett with a sigh. "[With correct choices] we have all the power in the world to keep this from happening."
There are hundreds of kinds of trees available that can be used in urban spaces. And there's no shortage of help available when choosing one. Both Duquesne Light and the City of Pittsburgh are willing to assist homeowners in making proper selections. Local nurseries are another place to get good, reliable information.
Homeowners can also get a free publication, "Landscape Tree Factsheets," edited by Henry D. Gerhold, Norman L. Lacasse and Willet N. Wandell. It's available through Penn State by calling 1-877-345-0691.
Good street trees to plant
Here is a partial list of trees, compiled by the Pennsylvania Urban and Community Forestry Council, of small trees that can be planted under utility wires. For the complete listing go to pubs.cas.psu.edu, click under Publications and search for trees and utilities.
Choke cherry
Crabapples: 'Adams,' 'Centurion,' 'Harvest Gold,' 'Prairiefire,' 'Red Barron' and 'Sugar Tyme.'
Dogwoods, Kousa and hybrids 'Celestial,' 'Constellation,' 'Milky Way,' 'Stardust' and 'Stellar Pink.'
Hawthorne varieties: 'Crimson Cloud,' 'Ohio Pioneer' and 'Winter King.'
Japanese tree lilacs: 'Ivory Silk,' 'Regent' and 'Summer Snow.'
Magnolias galaxy
Magnolia star
Maples: Amur, paperbark and trident
Serviceberry varieties: 'Autumn Brilliance,' 'Cumulus,' 'Majestic' and 'Robin Hill.'
Medium-sized trees that are OK near utility wires but should be planted at least 15 feet away:
Birch 'Heritage'
Cherry varieties: 'Accolade,' 'Kwanzan,' 'Okame' and 'Rosy Cloud.'
Goldenrain tree
Honey locust
American hornbeam
Red horsechestnut
Maple varieties: 'Crimson King,' 'Olmsted,' 'Norwegian Sunset' and 'Queen Elizabeth'
Pagoda tree varieties: 'Halka,' 'Regent' and 'Princeton Upright'
Yellowwood
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.