John Beale, Post-Gazette photos

Blue Echeveria and Pink Diamond Tulips in bloom in Phipps as part of the Spring Flower Show "In the Tropics," running through April 23.

Click photo for larger image.

'In the Tropics'

Advertise with us

Where:Phipps Conservatory and Botanical Gardens, Schenley Park.

When: Through April 23. The conservatory is open daily from 9:30 a.m. to 5 p.m. and on Fridays from 9:30 a.m. to 9 p.m.

Admission: $7.50 for adults, $6.50 for seniors 62 and over, $5.50 for students with ID, $4.50 for children ages 2 to 12. Children under 2 and Phipps members are admitted free.

Information: Call 412-622-6914, or see http://www.phipps.conservatory.org/

Classes and Lectures:

Advertise with us

Phipps holds events with spring flower show

The spring flower show is traditionally the most eagerly awaited and heavily attended of the seasonal shows staged in Phipps Conservatory's great Victorian glass house. And little wonder. Pittsburgh winters, although usually not arctic, are really grim. Maybe more snow would help conceal the dreariness of the landscape and a little sun would help dispel the grinding grayness of the winter months.

The spring show not only promises that better days are coming but also provides an antidote to the seasonal bleakness and a recharging surge of hope. The current show, however, seems to take much of its character from the emptiness and tedium of the winter itself. This is all the more unfortunate and paradoxical, in that the show is titled, "In the Tropics."

The concept here was the mingling of two very distinct and antithetical plant types, the tropical and the flowering spring bulb. This promising idea was developed by Phipps' director of horticulture, Karen Daubmann, and guest designer Scott Scarfone, Beaver County native and principal of Baltimore's Oasis Design Group.

The idea was promising, but its realization is oddly and sadly devoid of memorable horticultural effects or much that lifts the winter-diminished spirit. We are far from the ebullience and abundance of past spring shows.

Advertise with us

What went wrong here? Judging the show at its opening is an uncertain business since so many of the plants carry buds still tight and green. However, the main problems seem to be inattention to detail, occasional indifference to matters of scale and a rather wayward color sense.

Perhaps the most successful of the displays is in the South Room, whose design is loosely based on the landscape style of Roberto Burle Marx, all vivid slashes of strident color set within sumptuous foliage.

Tropical and spring flowering plants are well mingled in the center bed, an attention-claiming riot of texture and color enlivened by a decorous stream that flows into a surprisingly large, empty pool at the end of the bed. The lack of some enlivening greenery, maybe nothing more than umbrella plants and water hyacinths, and the resultant weak foreground are disturbing.

Blossoms surround the waterfall in Phipps' East Room.

Click photo for larger image.

Advertise with us

Far more damaging to the effect of this installation is the newly opened view to the south end of the room. Until recently, large mango and banyan trees stood here. They were removed because of their aged untidiness and because that end of the room will soon form part of the entrance to the new Rain Forest. The great openness of an undifferentiated light-filled space overwhelms the planted beds below. Surely at least a few tropical plants of significant height could have been found to be placed at the far end of the bed as a means of anchoring and consolidating this installation.

The intense need for some sort of terminal feature here is the best argument for reconstruction of the elegant pergola that once rose along the curving ramp at the planting bed's edge. Designed by Pittsburgh's Ralph Griswold, the pergola was a particularly handsome bit of hardscape.

The East Room's installation includes a far less successful blend of tropical and flowering plants. The tropical plants just seem out of place. However, the overall effect is varied and lively and repays some examination. The return of the waterfall is welcome, as is the removal of the small structure at the rear, a sort of theatrical prop that only occasionally works well as a design enhancement.

Elsewhere in the show, the overriding impression is a sort of garish vapidity. The Serpentine Room manages well enough with a number of discreet vignettes, but the planting is sparse and not especially effective either as to color or contrast of textures. Here, as elsewhere, the small sizes of the material considerably weakens the possible effect.

Daffodils will also be part of Phipps' spring flower display, which runs through April 23.

Advertise with us

Click photo for larger image.

The less said about the Sunken Garden Room and the Broderie Room, the better. The former is marked by a system of partitions, which although certainly architectural in appearance and function, are at war with the actual architecture of the room.

The most conspicuous element of the scheme are the awkward tulip-planted archways over the walks, which are echoed by Podocarpus hedges in the sunken center bed. Here, the rigorous geometry of the entire installation is distilled in small checkerboard beds of tulips, not unlike the "moderne" gardens of the 1920s and '30s.

The Broderie Room boasts a color scheme of rose, lavender and purple among which it was a happy inspiration to introduce blue-gray Echeveria as ground-hugging companions to the tulips filling the curvilinear beds. The overall appearance is marred by the introduction of palms, themselves not a bad idea, in large modern pots of the most intense, saturated blue. The flowering plant that could stand up against this aggressive color does not exist.

The palms are disturbingly yellowish, suggesting some sort of deficiency in their diet. They are only one example among many evident in the show of what certainly appears to be inferior quality of the plant material.

Advertise with us

In fact, the permanent collection has not looked so poor in recent memory. The Fern Room reveals brown, dry fronds on a number of plants, including the few remaining great tree ferns. Even the Cactus Room shows signs of deterioration, while in the Victoria Room, the banana trees are predominantly yellow and brown. Again, it is not out of place to ask "Why?" and then to ask how the conservatory can undertake the planting of a very large new room, the Rain Forest, and yet allow what is already on view to be shown in such condition.

An "Authority" Tulip springs into action in Phipps' East Room.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.