In the good old summer time, gardening tools don't have to be particularly stylish: Muddy trowels and well-worn work boots always can be hidden away in a shed or garage. But as cold weather approaches and plants move indoors, the humble watering can takes center stage.

With more gardeners buying tools on the Web -- online garden-supply sales have quadrupled in recent years, to $1.4 billion in 2004 from $312 million in 2001, according to Forrester Research Inc. -- we went shopping for the latest watering cans that would look good indoors and wouldn't leak all over our carpets. We selected five models, then handed them over for testing to a panel of amateur gardeners in Chicago. We wanted to know whether the cans would be easy to handle and aim, even when lifted overhead to water hanging plants.

For gardeners sensitive to the special needs of their potted plants, there are other issues. Hardy plants can be watered with a steady, direct stream, says Charlie Nardozzi, a horticulturalist with the National Gardening Association. Fragile or weak-stemmed plants should ideally be watered with a "rose," a showerhead-like attachment that creates a light spray. Overwatering is the main cause of plant death, Mr. Nardozzi cautions. ("When in doubt, don't water.")

The most eye-catching was the Radke Copper Watering Can, at $36, from garden retailer Smith & Hawken. Our panelists liked the spherical shape and autumn color, but its narrow, semicircular handle proved somewhat hard to grip, especially when watering hanging baskets. While one panelist liked the "rustic" look of Yardiac's galvanized metal can, the rest agreed that it was too big for indoor use. When full, the $30 can was difficult to lift up to table-level plants, and its thick stream flooded delicate blooms. Worse, the spout leaked at the bottom of the spray rose, trailing water down to the bottom of the spout. The Dramm Swiss watering can from Home Harvest, at $18, had a clean, elegant shape, and its heavy-duty plastic body felt reassuringly solid. But our panelists reported that water shooting too quickly from its straight spout doused a few countertops and tables.

Advertise with us

The Good Grips Indoor Pour & Store Watering Can from Oxo, at $14.99, won't be mistaken for an art object (one panelist pronounced its look "blah"). But everyone liked the can's solid, wide handle, which made it easy to carry when full. The curved spout delivered water exactly where we wanted, and its removable plastic rose could be clipped inside the top of the can when not in use. With the lowest shipping charge of all our orders, the Oxo was our Best Value.

The last can we tried was made by Haws, a British company that has been making them since 1886. Its $50 Indoor Watering Can seemed like a classic: The curved handle felt comfortable and made the can easy to control (one panelist, an engineer by training, praised its "great weight distribution"). Another panelist loved the narrow stream that could be aimed right into a small pot without spilling. All our judges agreed that the powder-coated steel exterior (with removable brass spray rose) made the can attractive enough to leave on a kitchen counter or coffee table. It's our Best Overall.

STORE/PRICE/PHONE: Garden Hardware Haws Indoor Watering Can $50 888-476-4426 gardenhardware.com

QUALITY: Best Overall. Slim, slightly curved spout delivered water in a narrow, easy-to-target stream. Brass spray rose can be attached for watering delicate plants, and curved side handle fit well in the hand for easy maneuvering.

SHIPPING COST/TIME: We paid $12.95 for shipping via UPS Ground (the only option offered); our package arrived in seven business days.

Advertise with us

RETURN POLICY: Return within 60 days for refund, exchange or credit.

PHONE/WEB EXPERIENCE: Available on several Web sites, but Garden Hardware has the best selection: a range of sizes and colors in eight different styles (including copper and heavy plastic).

COMMENT: Medium (2 pints) held enough water for three large houseplants. Also available: 4-pint version and 1-pint, which seemed impractical.

STORE/PRICE/PHONE: Oxo Good Grips Indoor Pour & Store Watering Can $14.99 800-545-4411 oxo.com

QUALITY: Best Value. Wide handle made the can easy to carry when full and allowed user to adjust easily to watering plants at different levels. Clear plastic spout can be turned back around over the can for easy storage.

Advertise with us

SHIPPING COST/TIME: We chose $5 standard shipping, the least expensive option of all our orders; the can arrived in three business days.

RETURN POLICY: Return for replacement or refund anytime.

PHONE/WEB EXPERIENCE: Gray was the only color available at the time of our order; other colors (blue, yellow, orange and green) will be available in November.

COMMENT: Three-quart capacity is convenient for watering a a large number of houseplants. Spray too heavy for delicate blooms.

STORE/PRICE/PHONE: Smith & Hawken Radke Copper Watering Can $36 800-940-1170 smithandhawken.com

Advertise with us

QUALITY: Round body and circular handle gave the can an elegant, decorative look. Curved spout poured water in an easy-to-control stream. But narrow handle was hard to grip and can tended to tip forward when full.

SHIPPING COST/TIME: We paid $7.95 for standard shipping which took eight business days.

RETURN POLICY: Return within 60 days for refund or exchange.

PHONE/WEB EXPERIENCE: "Story" and "Care" links below the product photo provide additional info. Web site also carries a few Haws watering cans.

COMMENT: We ordered the large (11/2 quarts), which was sufficient for five or six small houseplants; also comes in extra large (1 gallon).

Advertise with us

STORE/PRICE/PHONE: Home Harvest Dramm Long Reach Swiss Watering Can $17.95 517-332-5016 homeharvest.com

QUALITY: Heavy-duty plastic felt sturdy, but water had a tendency to shoot out of the straight spout. Overall look is sleek, and the 2-liter size was easy to carry even when full.

SHIPPING COST/TIME: FedEx Ground shipping cost us $8.29 and arrived in two business days.

RETURN POLICY: Return for exchange or refund. Customer must e-mail or call for authorization.

PHONE/WEB EXPERIENCE: Website is being updated, which led to glitches -- a spray rose promised with our order didn't come, and we couldn't pick a color.

Advertise with us

COMMENT: Company rep said they'll send any mising parts ASAP to customers who call and ask.

STORE/PRICE/PHONE: Yardiac Galvanized Sprinkling Can, $29.95 866-927-3422 ardiac.com

QUALITY: Galvanized metal was lightweight, with appealing, old-fashioned look. But handle was unsteady, spout leaked and the spray rose wouldn't twist off.

SHIPPING COST/TIME: We paid $7.95 for shipping via UPS Ground, and our order arrived in four days.

RETURN POLICY: Return for refund or exchange by phone or email within 30 days.

Advertise with us

PHONE/WEB EXPERIENCE: Site sells fancier models, as well as Dramm watering can we had ordered through Home Harvest for $4 less.

COMMENT: A company rep said that the spray rose screws on very tightly by design, to avoid leaks.