For avid gardeners, buying plants through mail-order catalogs and their Web sites seems so appealing. Their selection of flowers, shrubs and vegetables is vast -- much more extensive than at the average garden center. And you can't argue with the convenience of clicking the mouse and having boxes of peonies and primroses show up at your door.
But there are downsides. For one thing, mail-order plants generally aren't a bargain, especially considering the puny pots most of them come in. It can take weeks for orders to arrive, and when they do some of the flowers and shrubs may be a bit disheveled or downright damaged from the shipping. And almost none of your purchases will resemble the luscious color photos of fully grown plants that enticed you to order them in the first place.
Still, Americans placed 5.6 million orders to mail-order garden companies last year, up 7 percent from 2003, according to the Mailorder Gardening Association. This year even Home Depot, the largest retailer of garden goods, has gotten into the mail-order act.
To discover just how much mail-order plants can vary in size, price and quality, we ordered columbines, an old-fashioned perennial flower, from five retailers. We then planted them in our garden and let them settle in for a few weeks. For an expert opinion, we also showed them to Mark Fisher, a foreman at New York's Brooklyn Botanic Garden.
Though we had requested a $10.25 potted columbine from White Flower Farm, the plant we received was a "bare root," a mail-order way of sending plants in a semi-dormant state, and a form of plant we've had mixed success with in the past. (A customer-service representative said the company can't promise in which form it will send a plant because "we do not know how we are shipping it until the order is packed.")
Burpee, an ancient name in home-garden supplies, sent us six spindly columbines in tiny pots for $18. After a few weeks in our garden they have barely grown. We also weren't thrilled by the pair of columbines from Wayside Gardens, which cost us $4.95 each. Though they were bigger than the Burpee plants, one of the two didn't have any green leaves growing from its thin stem. (A customer rep later told us it can take four to six weeks for leaves to appear.) Our set of three columbines from Smith & Hawken, for $29, had clearly been transplanted recently to larger pots and remained in their tiny "plug" state; the roots hadn't grown into the surrounding soil.
The big surprise was our order from Home Depot. The big-box retailer sent us lush columbines in the same size pot in which you'd buy columbines at its stores (though they are shipped directly from Altman Plant, a big commercial grower in California). Mr. Fisher of the botanic garden was equally impressed by these columbines, calling them "very substantial, vigorous, flowering-size plants." They are our Best Overall, and at $17 for a set of three, are our Best Value as well.
STORE/PRICE/PHONE:
B> Home Depot Columbine Collection $16.99 for three plants 800-553-3199 homedepot.com
QUALITY: Best Overall, Best Value. Columbines were the largest and most fully grown of all we ordered. The pots were a generous 4" diameter by 4" deep.
SHIPPING COST/TIME: We paid $5.91 for shipping. Shipment is delayed until warm enough in customer's area.
RETURN POLICY: Request for a refund or replacement must be made within two weeks.
PHONE/WEB EXPERIENCE: Finding the plant section amid the power tools and lawn furniture could be made easier.
COMMENT: Bare-bones Web site gave no information on the variety of columbines offered nor on growing requirements, such as how cold a winter they will tolerate.
STORE/PRICE/PHONE:
Burpee Columbine Songbird $18 for six plants 800-888-1447 burpee.com
QUALITY: Healthy looking, yet tiny plants. Each "cell" of the six-pack container was just 2" across by about 2" deep.
SHIPPING COST/TIME: Shipping cost us $3.95. Shipment is delayed until warm enough in customer's area.
RETURN POLICY: Will refund full price or provide a replacement within a year if the buyer is dissatisfied
PHONE/WEB EXPERIENCE: Cleanly designed Web site offers all necessary information on growing zones, plant spacing, etc.
COMMENT: Plants may not bloom this year due to their immature size, but they were among the least expensive columbines we found.
STORE/PRICE/PHONE:
Smith & Hawken Columbine Collection $29 for three plants 800-940-1170 smithandhawken.com
QUALITY: Plants were tiny "plugs" that were set into 3" by 3" pots; the roots hadn't started to grow out of the plugs, indicating the plants were immature.
SHIPPING COST/TIME: We paid $7.95 for shipping. Shipment is delayed until warm enough in customer's area.
RETURN POLICY: Will refund money or send a replacement within 30 days if a plant "fails to thrive."
PHONE/WEB EXPERIENCE: The Web site, while informative, froze several times while we placed our order.
COMMENT: A spokeswoman acknowledged that our shipment wasn't good, but said the company hasn't had any complaints about its columbines prior to ours.
STORE/PRICE/PHONE:
Wayside Gardens Columbine Music White $4.95 800-213-0379 waysidegardens.com
QUALITY: One of our plants had no leaves and looked sickly; the other had green leaves but was scrawny. The pots are 3" across by about 4" deep.
SHIPPING COST/TIME: $6.95 for standard shipping. Shipment is delayed until warm enough in customer's area.
RETURN POLICY: Will refund money or replace a plant for any reason within one year.
PHONE/WEB EXPERIENCE: Ordering online was easy, though the Web site is filled with plenty of promotions and come-ons.
COMMENT: Columbines are currently sold out. Customer service say plants are sold dormant or near-dormant, and that leaves take four to six weeks to appear.
STORE/PRICE/PHONE:
White Flower Farm Maxistar Columbine $10.25 800-503-9624 whiteflowerfarm.com.
QUALITY: We requested a potted plant but got bare roots, which take longer to get established. But the roots seem healthy and are sprouting leaves in our garden.
SHIPPING COST/TIME: Standard shipping cost $6.95. Shipment is delayed until warm enough in customer's area.
RETURN POLICY: Will refund the money or replace any plant "that fails to meet your expectations."
PHONE/WEB EXPERIENCE: An attractive Web site that has plenty of educational information, from soil prep to tips for Southern gardeners.
COMMENT: Company cannot guarantee whether customers receive pot-grown or bare-root plants when it supplies them in either version, said a service representative.
Internet Buying Tips
Ordering plants by mail isn't a straightforward as ordering, say, a sweater from L.L. Bean or a book from Amazon.com. Most plants don't come in standard sizes, brands or configurations, and some online retailers compound the problem by failing to give enough information about their goods. So here are some things to look out for:
CHECK THE POT SIZE. That can often -- but not always -- tell you how big a plant is. If the site doesn't say, ask for more information. A plant may no longer seem like a good buy if it comes in a tiny "cell pack" container. Watch out for terms like "quart pot" or "half-gallon pot"; some retailers use pots that aren't true to standard sizes. Also note that mail-order plants are often dramatically smaller than their in-store counterparts, so they may not make a big impression this year, if at all: Some perennials won't even bloom in their first season in your yard.
BEWARE OF "BARE ROOTS." These are plants that haven't been planted in any soil. While this is an acceptable way of shipping plants, they require more watering and generally take more time to get established.
READ THE FINE PRINT. Some garden-supply Web sites don't prominently tell you that a plant isn't right for your growing zone, or that what looks like a demure flower in the close-up photo will grow into a 5-foot-tall bush. Also check out how much sun or shade a plant requires, and whether it's more suited to a dry area or a streamside bog.
SHOP AROUND. The price of standard items such as tulip and daffodil bulbs, for instance, can vary drastically from seller to seller, so don't order at the first Web site you visit. (In fact, for many common plants you may be better off buying at a store.) Shipping charges also differ and can be steep, cutting into any savings a Web site may be advertising.
CHECK THE WEB. If you can't locate an unusual plant at the mainstream catalog companies such as Wayside Gardens, Burpee and White Flower Farm, search online. The Internet is filled with plant purveyors, some of them tiny operations with no ad budget, and one of them is bound to be offering what you are seeking.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.