Q. We live in an urban setting -- small lots, pavement, etc. -- and we want to plant two trees. The Bradford pear (Pyrus calleryana) was recommended, but I understand that they have problems with splitting and messy fruit. We are looking for alternative suggestions.

Bibliography

"Dirr's Hardy Trees" by Michael A. Dirr, Timber Press, 1997.

"Landscape Tree Factsheets" by Henry D. Gerhold, others, Penn State University, 2001.

Advertise with us

"Manual of Woody Landscape Plants" by Michael A. Dirr, Stipes Publishing, 1998.

"Taylor's Guide to Trees" by Susan A. Roth, Houghton Mifflin Co., 2001.

"The Year in Trees" by Kim E. Tripp and J. C. Raulston, Timber Press, 1995.

A. Trees suitable for urban settings are those that tolerate poor, compacted soil, reflected heat from pavement and buildings, reduced space for rooting, and possibly deicing salts, pollution and drought. They should also stay within bounds without requiring heavy pruning to do so.

Bradford pear trees are often recommended in such situations because they tolerate urban insults without flinching, and because they are attractive trees. They are smothered with flowers in early spring, have excellent fall color, and very few problems with insects and disease. Bradford pear trees grow 45 to 50 feet tall, so they are medium-sized rather than small trees.

Advertise with us

You are correct that they tend to split during storms or under the weight of snow and ice once they mature because of their sharply upright growth habit. Their limbs attach to the trunk at a steep angle, which is much weaker than a limb that attaches closer to a 45-degree angle.

The splitting problem can be addressed by cultivar selection ('Aristocrat,' Chanticleer or 'Cleveland Select,' and 'Respire' have better branching structure and are less susceptible to breakage).

Another problem with Bradford-type pear trees is that they are overplanted. It is not wise to rely so heavily on one species of tree because if an insect or disease problem attacks them, we stand to lose many trees from our urban forest. We obviously have not learned this lesson from the demise of the American elm due to Dutch elm disease.

There are other attractive trees that tolerate urban conditions. You do not mention size limits, but because Bradford pear trees grow 45-50 feet tall, I will suggest some larger trees along with those that stay under 35 feet. I have included a brief bibliography with this article so that you can read more about these trees.

Hedge maple (Acer campestre) is an attractive maple that sports dark green glossy summer leaves that turn yellow in fall. Hedge maples grow 30 to 45 feet tall with a comparable spread. They tolerate urban conditions very well, including drought, soil compaction and air pollution, but they do require well-drained soil. They tolerate full sun or light shade.

Advertise with us

Serviceberry (Amelanchier spp.) is one of our loveliest native trees with four seasons of interest. They get 15 to 25 feet tall, depending on the species, and often grow as multitrunked specimens. They are one of the first trees to bloom in April when they are covered with pendulous white flowers. The fruits that follow ripen from green to red to purple-black. They are quite tasty, and are highly preferred by many birds. Serviceberries also have excellent fall color, ranging from yellow and orange to deep red shades. They are standouts in the winter landscape with their silvery smooth bark marked with dark striations. They tolerate full sun to partial shade, and prefer an evenly moist, well-drained acidic soil. Fringetree (Chionanthus virginicus) blooms mid- to late May with fragrant white flowers borne in 8- to 10-inch panicles. This tree is a real traffic-stopper when it is in full bloom. Fringetrees grow to about 15 feet tall, with a slightly wider spread. They are usually multitrunked. The blue fruits resemble small plums. The clean, dark green summer foliage can take on an attractive yellow fall coloration. The bark on mature trees becomes ruggedly furrowed and is attractive in its own right. They grow best in full sun to partial shade. Although they prefer a moist, acid soil that drains well, they are adaptable to less than ideal conditions.

'Winter King' Hawthorn (Crataegus viridis) is a beautiful, dense tree that grows 25 to 35 feet tall. Because it has thorns, it may not be the best choice as it could scratch pedestrians walking by. It blooms with attractive white flowers in May, followed by eye-catching red fruits that persist well into winter. Birds find this tree attractive, both for the fruit and the well-protected nesting sites it offers. 'Winter King' also has attractive exfoliating bark that peels back to reveal a rich orange-brown color inside. These trees are best in full sun. They are quite adaptable to soil type as long as it is well drained.

Kentucky coffeetree (Gymnocladus dioica) is one of the larger trees on the list, growing 60 to 70 feet tall with slightly smaller spread. This tree tolerates poor, compacted soil, drought and reflected heat. It has huge bipinnately compound leaves that can grow 3 feet long and 2 feet wide. Coffeetree blooms in late spring or early summer with 6- to 12-inch long panicles of greenish-white flowers that are not especially showy. The fruit is a large pod containing several large, round hard seeds encased in a sticky yellow pulp. The seeds persist on female trees through the winter, and they can be messy over time as they gradually fall. The common name comes from early settlers using the roasted seeds as a coffee substitute (raw seeds and pods are toxic). It does best in full sun.

Goldenraintree (Koelreuteria paniculata) is an excellent small lawn tree. It grows 30 to 40 feet tall with an equal or greater spread. Goldenraintree blooms in late June or early July with large panicles of yellow flowers, one of the few trees with yellow blooms. It is quite adaptable to soil type as long as drainage is good, and it is very tolerant of heat, drought and air pollution. It does best in full sun and can develop a good yellow fall color.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.