Q. A landscaper told me I should mulch my trees out to the dripline and forget about growing grass under them. Is that really a good idea?

A. To reduce the competition between your trees and the lawn, it is a good practice to eliminate the grass and spread mulch out to the dripline (the ends of the trees' branches).

Turfgrass and trees compete for the same water and nutrients. It is a misconception to think that tree roots are very deep in the soil. The fine feeder roots occupy the top 6 to 18 inches of soil, while grass roots occupy the top 6 inches. Whichever plant was in place first tends to have the most dense root system, to the detriment of the other. Although a tree's roots extend far out beyond the dripline -- perhaps twice its circumference -- mulching to the dripline creates space where there is no competition.

Just as important, mulching trees out to the dripline keeps lawn mowers and weed whackers safely away from the trunk. Mechanical damage to the trunk and surface roots creates an entrance for insect and disease problems. Young trees have very tender bark that can be easily damaged or girdled by weed whackers. The tree's vascular system that transports water and nutrients is just under the bark. There is no way to repair the damage if that is destroyed, and the tree will die.

Advertise with us

Also, trees and turfgrass have different cultural requirements. Many of the trees we commonly grow -- maples, oaks, dogwoods, magnolias and conifers -- prefer a slightly acidic soil. Turfgrass prefers a neutral pH between 6.5 and 7.0. Applying limestone to raise the soil pH into the optimal range for the grass can cause an iron deficiency in trees. There may even be plenty of iron in the soil (our clay soils tend to be rich in such micronutrients), but it remains tightly bound to the soil particles when the soil pH is too high.

Established trees do not necessarily need to be fertilized at all, as long as they are putting on a reasonable amount of growth annually and have no obvious symptoms of nutrient deficiency. Turfgrass does best when fertilized regularly through the growing season, which can be too much for the trees.

Too much nitrogen fertilizer makes trees more susceptible to insect damage, particularly those insects that feed with piercing-sucking mouthparts such as scale, aphids, true bugs and spider mites. The excess nitrogen makes the trees more nutritious for the insects, which often results in an explosion in the pest population. Too much nitrogen can also make a tree more susceptible to disease problems.

Although mulching a lawn tree out to the dripline does not completely remove it from fertilizer and limestone applications, it does reduce their impact somewhat. All fertilizer and limestone applications for trees and lawns should be based on up-to-date soil test results.

Still another consideration is that some of the herbicides used to control weeds in turfgrass can have a negative impact on trees. Be sure to read and follow label directions on lawn herbicides and if they are hazardous to trees, apply them very carefully.

Advertise with us

Mulching benefits trees in other ways. It reduces weeds, maintains soil moisture and moderates soil temperature. As it breaks down, mulch adds nutrients and organic matter to soil. This results in an improved soil structure that absorbs water and holds nutrients better.

To mulch properly, apply a 2- to 4-inch layer of shredded hardwood bark out to the dripline. Do not allow the mulch to touch the bark on the trunk. Mulch piled up around the trunk can damage the bark and create a haven for bark-gnawing rodents such as voles and mice. Replace mulch as it breaks down, but do not automatically reapply a thick layer of mulch every year. Make sure you really need it.

If you just want to freshen the appearance of mulch in the spring, rake it out thoroughly. If it still looks rough, topdress with a thin layer of new mulch.