Tony Tye, Post-Gazette
Young trees are protected, but not staked, at this tree farm. It's usually best to let trees move with the wind.
Click photo for larger image.Q. This year, my wife and I planted several new trees. Some red oaks that we planted in our driveway seem to be bending with the prevailing wind. We did not stake them, in the belief that it is better to allow the trees to bend. Which is the proper method: stake or not?
A. To stake or not to stake -- that is the question that continues to cause debate and probably will for years to come. Since each planting situation is different, there is no one-size-fits-all answer.
A conversation with the questioner revealed that the trees are not being blown out of the ground or tipped over by the wind, just that it is sculpting their crowns. This is perfectly natural for trees planted on an open, windy site. Staking them would not make a difference. You may be able to counteract some of the one-directional growth with a little judicious pruning, but that is how trees grow on a windy site.
You do not always need to stake newly planted trees. It's unnecessary if they are planted in solid, reasonably level ground and have rootballs that are appropriate for the height and trunk diameter of the tree (approximately 1 foot of rootball per inch of diameter as measured by a caliper).
You are correct in thinking that it is better for a tree to move with the wind. Research has shown that unstaked trees develop a stronger, properly tapered trunk. Trees that are rigidly staked so that they have minimal movement in the wind tend to develop a trunk that is thicker above the point of staking and smaller below. This is the inverse of the way a trunk should grow and makes it more likely to snap in a windstorm or under the weight of snow and ice.
There are situations when staking is recommended, however. Bareroot trees and trees with undersized rootballs both benefit from being staked for one year after planting. This gives them an opportunity to regrow enough of a root system to anchor them firmly. Trees that are planted on steep slopes, loose soil or very windy sites can also benefit from being staked for the first year, to give them a chance to become established.
If it is necessary to stake a tree, the stake should be removed after a year. If the tree has not rooted in firmly by then, look for other factors interfering with its proper establishment. These include:
Planting too deeply or not deeply enough. The root flare -- the point where the trunk flares out as it meets the roots -- should be visible just above the soil line.
Not removing artificial burlap from the root ball; roots cannot penetrate it enough to support the tree properly or absorb sufficient water and nutrients.
Putting high-nitrogen fertilizers in the planting hole, where tender new roots can be burned.
Too little or too much soil moisture, allowing developing roots to dry out or rot.
Stakes should be driven into undisturbed soil on three sides of the root ball. The wire that ties the stake to the tree should be run through a piece of hose where it contacts the tree to prevent damage to tender young bark. Staking kits usually include tubing or you can use an old hose. When you stake the tree, do not pull the support wires so taut that the tree is too tightly bound to move with the wind.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.