Q. We have a magnolia tree in our front yard. It is 12 years old and we have never had this problem before. There are yellow jackets or honey bees flying all through it, and it looks like they are laying eggs under the leaves and on twigs. I have sprayed it several times with a mixture of captan, malathion and carbaryl, but the bees are still there. What is going on?

A. The "eggs" you think the bees are laying are actually magnolia scale insects. Magnolia scale is a common pest of saucer magnolia (Magnolia soulangiana), star magnolia (Magnolia stellata) and cucumbertree magnolia (Magnolia acuminata).

It is understandable that gardeners have a hard time believing these "bumps" are living insects because they never move. Once the maturing scale insect inserts its mouthparts into a twig or small branch, it spends its entire life in the same place. Magnolia scale (Neolecanium cornuparvum) is the largest scale insect in the United States. The yellow jackets and bees are there (and probably flies and ants) to consume the sugary honeydew they produce. Honeydew is a polite term for insect excrement.

This pest resides on the tree year-round but goes unnoticed until it starts producing large amounts of honeydew, a result of this insect's sugary diet. Scale insects feed by inserting piercing-sucking mouthparts into the portion of a plants' vascular system responsible for transporting the carbohydrates and sugars produced by photosynthesis.

Advertise with us

Honeydew can be a real annoyance when it drips on the lower leaves and anything unfortunate enough to be under the magnolia. It also attracts nuisance insects such as yellow jackets, ants and flies. To make matters worse, a black sooty mold fungus often grows on the honeydew. Although it is unattractive, sooty mold does no real damage to the tree.

It is helpful to understand this pests' life cycle in order to control it effectively. Magnolia scale warrants control, not only because of the mess it creates but also because it can cause severely infested branches to die. They are usually present in large numbers, and it does not take long for a sizable population to build up.

Adults are covered with a waxy covering that makes them impervious to insecticide applications, so you have a narrow window of time when the young nymphs (immature insects) are susceptible. Newly hatched scale nymphs are also known as crawlers because it is the only point in their life cycle when they are mobile. There is one generation of magnolia scale a year in our climate.

Controlling magnolia scale is a two-step process. First, apply a horticultural oil spray just before the tree leafs out in spring to kill the overwintering nymphs. They are quite small and difficult to see. Horticultural oil suffocates the pests, rather than poisoning them, and it will greatly reduce the number of young produced in late summer. Horticultural oil is more refined and lighter than dormant oil (Volck oil), and there is less chance of burning tender new foliage if you slip up and spray as the tree begins leafing out in the spring.

The timing for the second step is critical because only the newly hatched crawlers are vulnerable to insecticides. The product you have applied sounds like a home orchard spray that combines a fungicide and insecticides. Captan is a fungicide and is not labeled to kill insects of any kind. Malathion and carbaryl (Sevin) are both labeled to control scale crawlers and both are toxic to bees and yellow jackets, too. You probably did kill yellow jackets, bees and wasps with the spray, but more keep coming for the honeydew.

Advertise with us

Magnolia scale is in its crawler stage in late August and early September in our area. Of course, insects do not live by the calendars that govern our lives; their development is based on temperature and moisture. It is always best to make sure you see active crawlers before applying insecticide sprays.

The crawlers are quite small, but can be seen upon careful inspection. A hand lens or magnifying glass will help. Begin checking your magnolia in late July. Concentrate your scouting on last year's and the current year's growth. Make your first insecticide application when you first see the small crawlers moving around.

Orthene (acephate), Sevin (carbaryl), Bayer Advanced Power Force Multi-Insect Killer (cyfluthrin), horticultural oil, Bayer Advanced Garden Tree & Shrub Insect Control (imidacloprid), insecticidal soap, Bio-Neem (neem), and malathion are all registered for control of magnolia scale crawlers. Depending on the insecticide, you may need to make repeat applications at the intervals suggested on the product label.

Bayer Advanced Tree and Shrub Insect Control has shown to be very effective in controlling soft scale insects. This product is applied as a soil drench rather than sprayed onto the tree. It is absorbed by the roots and moves through the tree's vascular system. However, it is too late for this product to be effective for your tree this year. It takes time for the active ingredient to be distributed throughout the tree, and it should be applied in spring as the tree is leafing out or shortly thereafter. Choose one of the other products to control this year's crawlers, and consider using the Bayer product next spring.

It is hard to say how these immobile pests came to live on a magnolia that has been problem-free until now. A bird that perched on an infested magnolia and then perched on your tree may have carried them. Although magnolia scale can be controlled, it is an ongoing process. You will have to scout and be prepared to control this pest every year.

Advertise with us

Some people have decided to replaced susceptible magnolias with less problematic trees. There is a lovely magnolia called sweetbay magnolia (Magnolia virginiana) that is resistant to magnolia scale. It also puts out its main flush of flowers in June, so they are not spoiled by frost as often as saucer and star magnolias. Sweetbay magnolias have a wonderful lemony fragrance. They tend to put out a few flowers here and there throughout the summer, so you can enjoy the fragrance for an extended period.

Other small trees that are less problematic include serviceberry (Amelanchier spp.); fringetree (Chionanthus virginicus); 'Winter King' hawthorn (Crataegus viridis); sourwood (Oxydendrum arboreum); and Japanese stewartia (Stewartia pseudocamellia).