Q. All of my roses have black spot. They are not all planted close together, but some on each side of the house and another out farther into the yard. One is a climbing rose and it has black spot so badly that every leaf has fallen off. This rose is about 4 years old and it is severely infected every year. I have searched online to try to find ways to "cure" this problem. I have picked off all infected leaves and stems (the climber now has just one long stem, no leaves, no blooms). I have also used several fungicides that state on the label that they will treat black spot, but nothing seems to work. Do you have any suggestions?
A. Black spot is the most common disease encountered with roses of all kinds: climbers, hybrid teas, floribundas, miniature roses, etc. It is a fungal disease that causes black spots on infected leaves. Those leaves turn yellow and fall prematurely. It is not uncommon for infected roses to be completely defoliated, like your climber. Purple spots on the canes (stems) indicate that they are also infected with black spot.
The disease is caused by the fungus Diplocarpon rosae. It overwinters on fallen leaves and on infected canes. Black spot is a disease that has many cycles of infection through the growing season. It is favored by the kind of warm, wet weather and high humidity we have had this spring and early summer. As long as environmental conditions remain favorable, black spot will continue to infect the new growth on your roses.
It sounds as though you have done a good job implementing cultural controls, such as removing infected leaves and pruning out infected canes. Although these practices will not "cure" black spot, they go a long way toward removing diseased material that acts as a source of further infection. Be sure to rake up and remove those leaves that have fallen to the ground, too. It is also good that you planted the roses in various spots, rather than planting them all together in one area.
Other cultural controls include allowing plenty of space around roses to permit good air circulation. This helps the plant dry off as soon as possible after it rains. Also, be sure to water the soil and avoid wetting the plants when you water.
Another important, non-chemical control for black spot is to grow resistant varieties. Resistant does not mean immune, and resistant varieties can become infected when environmental conditions are very favorable for the disease to develop, especially if they are planted in proximity to susceptible varieties.
Some resistant hybrid tea roses include: 'Charlotte Armstrong,' 'Chrysler Imperial,' 'First Prize,' 'Forty-Niner,' 'Miss All-American Beauty,' 'Mister Lincoln,' 'Olympiad,' 'Peace,' 'Pink Peace,' 'Portrait,' 'Tiffany' and 'Tropicana.'
Resistant floribundas and grandifloras include 'Angel Face,' 'Betty Prior,' 'Carousel,' 'Europeana,' 'First Edition,' 'Goldilocks,' 'Ivory Fashion,' 'Love,' 'Montezuma,' 'Pink Parfait,' 'Queen Elizabeth,' 'Razzle Dazzle,' 'Rose Parade,' 'Sonia' and 'Sunsprite.'
Resistant shrub-type roses include the 'Carefree' series. The climbing rose 'New Dawn' is also considered resistant.
Unfortunately, cultural controls may not be enough to keep black spot in check when environmental conditions are so favorable for the disease to develop. There are a number of fungicides labeled to control black spot. However, fungicides must be used preventively to protect new growth before it becomes infected. Once a leaf is infected, no fungicide will "cure" it; the spots and/or yellowing do not go away.
You must make repeated applications, at the intervals recommended on the label of the fungicide you are using, as long as the weather remains favorable for the development and spread of black spot. You do not need to spray when we have hot, dry weather, as we often do in July and August. Fungicides labeled to control black spot include Daconil 2787 (chlorothalonil), Dithane (mancozeb), Cleary's 3336 (thiophanate methyl), Funginex (triforine) and ziram. Organic gardeners can use copper-based fungicides to control black spot.
Black spot does warrant control. Infected plants lose their leaves prematurely, and they do not have the opportunity to store nutrients and carbohydrates to carry them through the winter and give them energy to sprout into new growth next spring. Roses that are repeatedly defoliated are weakened and become less winter hardy.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.