Q. The deer really ate me out of house and home this past winter. My rhododendrons, blue hollies and even my hellebores were destroyed. Can you suggest some plants that they will not eat?
Martha Rial, Post-Gazette
Butterflies love butterfly bush, but deer steer clear of it.
Click photo for larger image.
A. I always hesitate to publish a list of "deer-resistant" plants. As soon as I say that deer do not eat a given plant, I receive a report to the contrary (of course, it could be that the deer find these lists and begin eating the plants on them just for spite).
Our experience in the Penn State Cooperative Extension Demonstration Gardens in North and South parks is that they eat certain plants in one garden that they do not touch in the other, and vice versa. These gardens focus on annual flowers, but also include an assortment of perennial flowers and ornamental grasses. Both have full sun exposure and are open and unfenced. Rabbits, groundhogs and occasional two-legged vandals cause damage, too.
There are certain plants we do not try to grow anymore because they are always eaten in both gardens: hollyhocks (Alcea rosea), coneflowers (Echinacea purpureas), Joe Pye weed (Eupatorium spp.), gazania (Gazania rigens), sunflowers (Helianthus spp.), morning glory and relatives (Ipomea spp.), hyacinth bean (Lablab purpureus), petunias, Egyptian starflowers (Pentas spp.), portulacca (Portulacca grandiflora), black-eyed Susan vine (Thunbergia alata), pansies (Viola spp.) and black-eyed Susans (Rudbeckia spp.). We do grow Rudbeckia nitida 'Herbstonnne' at North Park with success, but it is planted in an area that the deer cannot easily reach.
Many plants related to vegetables do not fare well, either, including 'Bright Lights' Swiss chard and sweet potato vine cultivars 'Marguerite' and 'Blackie.' Surprisingly, 'Chilly Chili' ornamental peppers have gone without damage, as has perilla (tender plants used in Asian cuisine).
Other plants are damaged sporadically, including ageratum (Ageratum houstonianum), angelonia (Angelonia angustifolia), begonias, cannas, dahlias, heliotrope (Heliotropium arborescens), geraniums (Pelargonium hybrids, not including scented geraniums), coleus (Solenostemon hybrids), marigolds (Tagetes spp.) and nasturtiums (Tropaeolum majus). We try to grow these plants just about every year. Sometimes the deer eat them; sometimes they do not touch them.
Plants that have never been damaged include ornamental grasses of all kinds, and those with a pungent fragrance (foliage or flower), including root beer hyssop (Agastache rupestris), butterfly bush (Buddleia spp.), blue-mist shrub (Caryopteris x clandonensis), spider flowers (Cleome spp.), carnation/sweet William (Dianthus spp.), lantana (Lantana camara), sweet alyssum (Lobularia maritima), four-o'clocks (Mirabilis jalapa), nemesia (Nemesia spp.), scented geraniums (Pelargonium spp.), Russian sage (Perovskia atriplicifolia), salvias (Salvia spp.), goldenrod (Solidago rugosa 'Fireworks'), Dahlberg daisy (Thymophylla tenuisecta) and verbena (Verbena spp. and cultivars).
Other plants they do not seem to bother are those that are toxic or that have a milky sap, including butterfly weed (Asclepias spp.), angel's trumpet (Brugmansia and Datura spp.), spurge (Euphorbia spp.) and castor bean (Ricinus communis).
Other plants that have done well in the demonstration gardens include snapdragon (Antirrhinum spp.), marguerite daisy (Argyranthemum spp.), cockscomb (Celosia spp.) tickseed coreopsis (Coreopsis verticillata & C. rosea cultivars), cosmos (Cosmos spp.), twinspur (Diascia spp.), incarvillea (Incarvillea spp.), shasta daisy (Leucanthemum x superbum 'Becky'), bush zinnia (Melampodium cinereum), hardy banana (Musa basjoo), flowering tobacco (Nicotiana spp.), African daisy (Osteospermum spp.), New Zealand flax (Phormium spp.), fan flower (Scaevola aemula), dusty miller (Senecio cineraria) and zinnia (Zinnia spp.).
Anecdotal evidence suggests that deer prefer many types of shrubs, including euonymous (Euonymous fortunei cultivars), hydrangeas, blue hollies (Ilex x meserveae), mountain laurel (Kalmia latifolia), azaleas and rhododendron (Rhododendron spp.), roses and yews (Taxus spp.).
Shrubs often reported to be resistant include boxwood (Buxus spp.), forsythia, American holly (Ilex opaca), doghobble (Leucothoe spp.), spicebush (Lindera benzoin) and Japanese pieris (Pieris japonica).
You might take a walk and see what your neighbors are growing successfully. Talk to the gardeners in your neighborhood or landscape professionals that care for neighbor's properties. Deer appetites vary from location to location. The only sure way to keep deer from browsing in your yard is an 8-foot-high fence, whether electric, woven wire or plastic deer netting.
You can also fence off individual plants to protect them from deer browsing. This is especially helpful with young plants because it gives them a chance to grow to a mature size. Be sure to string the deer netting or fencing on posts far enough away from the plants that deer cannot reach over it or nibble through it.
Repellents can also help reduce deer browsing. These products have unpleasant fragrances or tastes and generally must be reapplied after rain. It is important to rotate among different repellents: Follow a taste-based repellent with a scent-based one to keep the deer from getting used to one and ignoring it. Be sure to read the label thoroughly; not all repellents are labeled for use on edible crops.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.