Q. We have a big silver maple (Acer saccharinum) that lost two large limbs in the recent storms. Although we have cleaned up the mess on the ground, we are concerned about the jagged tears left on the tree itself. One limb snapped off pretty cleanly, but the other tore down the bark on the trunk. Should that be pruned or painted in some way?
A. It would be wise to hire a certified arborist to evaluate the tree and perform any corrective pruning required to ensure the tree's health and safety. Although it is fine for home gardeners to prune small trees, up to about 20 feet tall, larger trees should be left to professionals to prune them properly and safely.
Trees damaged in storms may appear to be fine to the untrained eye. Arborists can evaluate their structural soundness and determine whether the tree should be pruned or removed altogether. A good example is the large old American elm (Ulmus americana) that stood outside Phipps Conservatory until storm damage last June required its removal. The tree had been twisted enough by the wind to make it hazardous, even though it looked fine to the casual observer. A number of people protested that tree's removal.
However, as a result of that storm damage, it could have come crashing down on a calm, sunny day. The consequences could have been tragic. No one likes to lose established trees, but once they have been damaged by a storm, they often become more of a liability than an asset.
It is possible that an arborist can clean up the stubs left by the broken limbs and trim the area of bark torn when the one fell. The tree may be fine and you may be able to enjoy it for many years to come. However, silver maples are fast-growing trees that are notoriously weak-wooded. The fact that those limbs broke during a storm could be an indication of interior rot that was present before the storm hit. You should have a certified arborist examine the tree to determine if it safe in the long term.
Every year when storms hit, well-meaning but untrained individuals attempt to clean up fallen limbs and damaged trees, often with disastrous results. Trees that have been damaged by a storm are often twisted, and that twist may not be readily apparent. The second a chain saw touches the tree, it releases that tension and the tree snaps back with unexpected speed and force. It is best to allow trained professionals to deal with the damage.
Homeowners should never attempt to remove tree limbs from downed power lines. Certified arborists take a special course to become certified in pruning near power lines, and they use specialized equipment to ensure their safety.
As for pruning small trees damaged by recent storms, remove broken limbs back to side branches that are one-third to one-half the diameter of the main branch. It is best if the side branch faces outward so you do not encourage the tree to grown back in on itself. This will result in a crossing branch that will need to be removed at a later date.
If it is necessary to remove a broken limb back to the trunk, do not cut it off flush with the trunk. Instead, locate the branch collar, a slight swelling where the branch attaches to the main trunk. Make your cut to the outside of the branch collar so that it remains intact. This enables the tree to heal the pruning cut over completely in a few growing seasons. If you remove the branch collar, the wound may never heal properly.
If a broken limb has torn the bark down the trunk of the tree, use a sharp knife to trim the tear into a lengthwise football shape, paralleling the tree trunk. Clean up torn edges so that the entire margin of the wound is smooth. Although complete healing depends on the severity of the tear, this treatment makes it easier for the tree to callus the wound over on its own.
Avoid using any kind of wound dressing. A tree can heal a clean, properly made pruning cut on its own. Pruning paint can actually interfere with the healing process and trap too much moisture, which can lead to interior decay in the future.
Send questions to slf9@psu.edu or by regular mail c/o Penn State Cooperative Extension, 400 N. Lexington St., Pittsburgh 15208.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.