Tony Spadaro’s parents ran a popular Italian American eatery on Route 22 for nearly 20 years before it closed in 2009. And like most kids of family-owned restaurants, he helped out in various jobs.

He also grew up eating more meals than he could count at Dick’s Diner, which Richard Snyder opened in 1946 in Murrysville on what was then the new William Penn Highway bypass. A classic metal railway car, it was most likely constructed by the same Elizabeth, N.J., company that built the Gateway Diner in nearby Wilkins, Jerry O’Mahony Diner Co., which manufactured about 2,000 roadside dining cars between 1917 and 1952. After the Gateway Diner’s closing, its shell was restored and relocated to Dolly’s Diner in North Apollo, Armstrong County.

Designed to look like railroad rolling stock, O’Mahony diners were long and narrow, measuring roughly 10-15 feet wide by 40-54 feet long. Even though they looked like freight cars, they were prefabricated as diners and transported to the site.

“A Jerry O’Mahony dining car is more than just a casual dining place,” a brochure reads. “It is a type of place people enthuse about and return to frequently.”

Advertise with us

So when Spadaro became a co-manager of Dick’s Diner six months after the Snyder family sold it in 2023 to Jim Fox III, owner of the chain Fox’s Pizza Den, it was like coming full circle.

“I came here as a little kid,” the Murrysville native says.

A lot has changed between then and Aug. 18, when the diner celebrated its 80th anniversary with 80-cent slices of its famed apple pie.

For one thing, it looks very different, having been modernized and enlarged several times to allow for more customers and more efficient cooking. (Original railcar layouts looked cool during their heyday in the 1950s and ’60s but were very cramped.)

For another, back when Spadaro was a kid, you never would have found something as trendy as chicken and waffles on the menu, let alone a caramel iced latte. But as they say, the more things change, the more they stay the same.

Advertise with us

Dick’s is still a favorite place for locals to grab a quick breakfast or linger over lunch, he says, and it’s a friendly space where everyone feels like family, even if it’s their first visit.

When he was growing up, people talked about the diner as if it were a person.

“It was always, ‘What’s going on at THE diner,’ or ‘Let’s meet at THE diner,’” Spadaro recalls.

That feeling has never gone away, he insists, and not just because they have a lot of the same customers from back in the day.

“In this day and age, some [restaurants] forget about customer service and the basics of why you go out to eat,” he says. “When you go out, you want to be waited on and feel important.

Advertise with us

“People feel comfortable here because they’re part of a community. They feel it’s ‘their’ place. It’s iconic.”

General manager Erik Retzer, who grew up in New Kensington, agrees the diner is a local institution with a cult following.

“There have been a lot of first dates here. People have gotten engaged, baby showers — it’s generations of families,” he says.

The giant (and free) parking lot off Route 22 also adds to its appeal, and the view of traffic whizzing by from the diner’s many windows makes a meal feel dynamic.

Fox, who took the reins of the pizza and sandwich chain after the death of his father, Jim Jr., in 2022, says it didn’t take much prodding when he was approached about buying the diner in 2023. Like Spadaro, he has been going there since he was a kid growing up in Murrysville — he remembers sitting at the counter with his father — and he wanted to keep it in the community. Since he lives just 3 miles down the road, he still eats there at least once a week.

Advertise with us

Initially, however, he planned to buy the building and find someone else to run the business.

“It wasn’t something I drove by and said, ‘I want to buy this diner.’”

In the end, he decided to “give it a shot” despite the fact the building was in need of some major TLC.  “Everyone loves that place.”

Fox spent about $600,000 to put in new ceilings, replace the wiring and HVAC, update the lighting, and install a new counter by the entrance. He also replaced its booths with tables and chairs, replaced the carpeting, added stone details to pillars in the dining room, and upgraded and expanded the kitchen equipment.

“It needed a full renovation,” he says. “It was one of those things where COVID hit and it was bad times for restaurants and a lot of things got overlooked.”

Advertise with us

Because a diner is only as good as its food, he also took a critical look at the menu by sampling the dishes and upgrading the quality of many ingredients.

One side dish, in particular, got a big boost. Because Fox is in the pizza business and can get meat products at a more reasonable cost, Dick’s now serves thick-cut Sugardale premium bacon with breakfast platters and tucked into sandwiches.

“We probably tried 30 different kinds before choosing it because if you own a breakfast place, you gotta have great bacon,” he says.

Two other dishes Retzer points to with pride are the homemade stuffed cabbage rolls and the hot turkey platter, which is made with turkey breast roasted on site and served with homemade gravy. New dishes include Belgian waffles with fresh berries and cream, biscuits and gravy and a Philly cheesesteak. Most items are priced under $14, and kids meals are $6.

You can get a simple tossed salad or avocado toast, or order your chicken or fish grilled instead of fried if you’re counting calories. You also can fuel your morning with a mocha, cappuccino, vanilla latte or cold brew.

Advertise with us

Despite the changes, Dick’s still offers mostly unpretentious, hearty meals made in its upgraded kitchen. Think hot meatloaf with gravy, homemade chicken potpie, a New York City-style Reuben sandwich, corned beef hash and eggs, Swiss steak, and patty melt burgers.

And talk about fast: Thanks to a new point of sale system that allows orders to go straight to a kitchen display system, every meal comes out in under 11 minutes, says Retzer.

While food runners also help expedite service, Retzer delivers the vast majority of orders himself, often with a cheery, singsong announcement like: “Who’s got the liver?” or “Who ordered the pot pie?” Occasionally, he’ll shoot an Instagram reel if someone seems especially delighted with a certain dish or piece of pie.

“We like whooping and hollering it out,” he said. “Everyone is so happy about it.”

He offers a very Pittsburgh analogy for the fun atmosphere and camaraderie among employees and customers.

Advertise with us

“They do their thing, and I do mine. They’re like the Allegheny and Monongahela [rivers], and I’m the Ohio that brings it all together.”

While the modern interior — and its box-like exterior, for that matter — doesn’t exactly shout “diner,” it’s a bright and cheery place to grab a burger or butter a plate of pancakes. There’s still a long, central lunch counter with seating for 15. It’s just topped with cream-colored laminate instead of the polished stainless steel of old and is outfitted with high-backed counter chairs instead of swivel stools bolted to the floor.

“People have to have an open mind to the old-school concept,” says Retzer, who was a product foreman at U.S. Steel for 22 years before being hired by Fox, a childhood friend.

To that end, the diner now boasts four online platforms for placing orders: Door Dash, Grubhub, Uber Eats and an upgraded website. It’s helping to shift the customer demographic to a younger crowd that will keep the business going.

That said, many customers are regulars who have been going to Dick’s for, well, forever.

Advertise with us
Judy Gillespie, left, of Plum, celebrates her 86th birthday at Dick's Diner with good friends Eldene Kuba and Carol Thomas, also of Plum. (Gretchen McKay/Post-Gazette)

On a recent Wednesday, best friends Judy Gillespie, Eldene Kuba and Carol Thomas, all of Plum, gathered at their favorite corner table with chicken salad sandwiches and onion rings to celebrate Gillespie’s 86th birthday.

“It’s like coming home,” she said.

“It’s a landmark,” agreed Kuba, 91, who has been coming to Dick’s for more than six decades.

While the diner is still largely a breakfast and lunch joint, at least 10% of customers stop by for dinner. Weekends are so busy that Dick’s sometimes sells nearly 40 pies made by longtime employee Wendy Storey. They come in eight varieties, including Boston and coconut cream and a mile-high lemon meringue.

Retzer sees a bright future, thanks to the many changes Fox has made over the past couple of years at the 80-year-old diner.

“It just needed a little TLC to take it into the future,” he says. “As we plateau, we don’t accept the status quo. We’re always pushing the business.”