With so many briny treats about to be trotted out at the 2026 Picklesburgh fest on Thursday, the pickle-lovers among us may be wondering: How far is too far when it comes to pickle-flavored foods?
I thought I may have reached the breaking point when I tested a recipe for a candied bread-and-butter pickle sundae last week. Turns out local pastry chefs are cooking up something even crazier.
Eat’n Park on Monday introduced its limited-edition Pickle Smiley Cookies, which are being sold in celebration of Picklesburgh, which runs July 16-19 in Downtown. All I can say is that it’s an acquired taste.
Deep-fried pickles on a stick, pickle-brined chicken sandwiches and pickle martinis are one thing. Pickle-flavored icing is quite another.
“The Mr. Yuk of cookies!” a colleague quipped when I sent her a picture of the cookies, which are hand-iced with a bright-green, pickle-flavored icing and matching bright-green, cheek-to-cheek icing smile. They’re being sold individually — not by the dozen, as fans of the original Smiley know — at select Eat’n Park restaurants for $1.99 each.
Even the store manager at my local restaurant gave a subtle wince when I asked him if I could buy a half-dozen to take my co-workers for a taste test.
Read More
“But we also have a banana Smiley,” he said with a sheepish grin, pointing in the direction of the cookie display near the front door. “And they’re really good!”
Because they’re so sweet (and cheerful), Smiley Cookies have probably always been made with kids in mind. But much as it kills me to say it as a lover of all-things Pittsburgh, I have a hard time imagining my 2-year-old grandson, Theo, who loves the free Smiley that follows his weekly breakfast there on Saturdays more than his pancakes, would take more than a single bite.
The cookies are made in the restaurant’s cookie factory in Robinson, with the same sugary dough as the original Smiley cookie (which the restaurant chain introduced in 1986). It’s just that the “pickle” flavoring in the icing tastes more like something a chemist concocted in a test tube than a baker stirred together with vinegar and salt. Meant to add a briny contrast to the sweet dough, it’s instead off-putting.
Eat’n Park is participating as an official Picklesburgh sponsor for the first time this year, so I understand why its “smile makers” at the factory — who, along with its restaurant bakers collectively make and ice more than 6 million cookies for fans across the country each year — decided to debut a pickle-flavored cookie. Over the years, the chain has introduced dozens of seasonal and holiday designs, and has also immortalized local sports figures and personalities like Pittsburgh Pirates pitcher Paul Skenes and documentarian Rick Sebak in icing. Smiley himself is a celeb, as the official cookie of the Pittsburgh Marathon.
But unless you’re really into the novelty of the situation and just have to eat something green, I’d stick to its traditional Smiley Cookies when visiting the Eat’n Park booth at the fest.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.