When it comes to favorite Pittsburgh eats, one dish has stood head and shoulders above the rest for more than a half-century: the salty-sweet layered dessert known as strawberry pretzel salad.

Served at nearly every summer cookout, potluck, graduation party or family reunion —  and if you’re really lucky, with Thanksgiving and Christmas dinner — it’s an American classic, beloved both for its contrasting textures and colorful layers and the fact that you don’t have to be a whiz in the kitchen to be able to prepare it. It only looks fancy.

Unlike shortcrust pastry for pie, which takes a bit of technique to get just right, the crust for strawberry pretzel salad can be quickly blitzed together in a food processor or bowl with just butter, sugar and crushed pretzels. The middle layer is equally foolproof so long as you start with cream cheese that’s been softened at room temperature. And the strawberry Jell-O topping? If you’ve got a whisk, talk about easy peasy.

Popularized in the 1960s and ’70s, when desserts made with molded Jell-O were all the craze, the ruby-colored pretzel salad also is a nostalgic food that brings back wonderful memories. Maybe you first made it with grandma when you were little for a church gathering or are now cautioning your own son or daughter to be careful while dissolving the gelatin mix in boiling water. Wherever and whenever you first made or tasted it, it’s part of our culinary DNA.

Advertise with us

Calling the dish a “salad” is a bit of a misnomer as it’s almost always offered as a dessert (though some, including my own mom when I was growing up, serve it as a side to a Thanksgiving turkey and Easter ham). For the backstory, you have to look not just at the long tradition of “dessert salads” in American potluck culture but also how American cooks came to embrace the notion of a pie crust crafted from pretzels instead of all-purpose flour or graham crackers.

One of the first mentions of pretzel crust in a newspaper appeared in a column by New York Daily News food editor Alice Peterson on July 30, 1953, as one of the dishes in her “Food Guide for the Week.” The recipe followed on Aug. 3 as the base for Lemon Chiffon Pie.

“Pretzels, those salty, cracker-like biscuits which are generally associated with beer, have unusual cooking possibilities when rolled into crumbs,” she wrote in the headnotes.

It must have sounded so good to aspiring cooks that in September, a story by food and market editor Gaynor Maddox was picked up in newspapers in Florida, Nebraska and California.

“Ever use pretzels to make a pie crust? Sounds dizzy but tastes great — crunchy, not too sweet and certainly new,” Maddox wrote atop a recipe for Pretzel Pie Crust With Ice Cream Pie. She added, “We picked up this one traveling through Pennsylvania, a big pretzel state.”

Advertise with us

By 1955, a recipe from Daily News food editor Ella Elvin (who was also a founding member of Les Dames d’Escoffier-New York) for apple pie made in a “novelty” pretzel crust was making the rounds in papers across the country and the crumbly, salty-sweet base was cemented as an accepted alternative to graham cracker crusts for chiffon and cream pies.

The jiggly Jell-O layer that defines strawberry pretzel salad dates to 1960.

First introduced to the market in 1897, Jell-O — instant gelatin sweetened with sugar and fruit flavors — became extremely popular in the early 1900s because it was an affordable luxury seen as “modern.” (Before then, people had to boil bones to make gelatin.)

The arrival of electric refrigeration in the 1920s boosted the popularity of gelatin desserts; in the 1930s, congealed salads both sweet and savory entered the domestic scene thanks to aggressive marketing with illustrated recipe books that showed home cooks how to stretch ingredients or transform leftovers into neat and filling meals.

A second Jell-O craze followed World War II with inventive concoctions like Ring-Around-The-Tuna (lime Jell-O mixed with salt, vinegar, diced cucumber, celery and albacore tuna and unmolded on lettuce) and Vegetable Trio Salad, which was made in three glorious layers with lemon Jell-O, shredded carrots and cabbage, chives and spinach, allowed working wives  to whip up a filling and inexpensive dinner quickly.

Advertise with us

Who first thought to pair a pretzel crust with strawberry Jell-O and a whipped cream filling, and whether the recipe originated in the South, Midwest or here in Pittsburgh isn’t as certain.

Some, incorrectly, believe the dish first appeared in “Joys of Jell-O,” an illustrated paperback cookbook published by General Foods in 1963 to celebrate the brand's versatility. (I paged through the entire cookbook and can attest it’s not in there.) Others say it’s a Midwestern dish, as evidenced by a 1972 recipe submitted by Mrs. Gordon Salley of Moline, Ill., to The Daily Dispatch.

A more likely story — and one Yinzers will certainly take to heart — is that the dish originated in Pittsburgh.

The first “known” recipe for Strawberry Pretzel Salad appeared in a booklet published in 1960 by the Brentwood Civic Club. It was contributed by Gerry Franz Sullivan, a second-generation German immigrant who founded the Brentwood Historical Society in 1992 and was a community force for decades.

There’s no mention of servings, and if you’re not a practiced cook you may have to read it two or three times to figure out the sequence of its three distinct steps (crust, filling and topping). She also adds crushed pineapple, an ingredient that becomes optional by 1975, when the dessert got its big break at the Florida Strawberry Festival in Plant City, Fla.

Advertise with us

In March that year, as reported in the Tampa Tribune, Clara Stephan “got the surprise of her life” when she won the festival’s strawberry recipe contest with an “unusual” recipe she’d gotten from her sister Katherine, who lived in Illinois, and had proved a big hit with her garden club when she brought it to one of her meetings. (Unlike Sullivan’s recipe, it used brown sugar and “chilled or very cold” strawberries.) The win earned the 77-year-old a new 15-foot freezer.

Variations soon spread to other papers across the country, including the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette in 1980, followed by The Pittsburgh Press in 1982 and countless other publications, recipe columns and community cookbooks in the years since.

More than 60 years after Sullivan’s recipe made its colorful splash in a suburban Pittsburgh cookbook, strawberry pretzel salad has only grown in popularity as one of our city’s favorite go-to retro desserts.

YaJagoff! Media co-founder John Chamberlin, who hosted the fifth annual Strawberry Jell-O Pretzel Salad Stand-off with business partner Rachael Rennebeck on May 16, thinks he knows why.

“Everybody has a story,” he says. “Somewhere along the way, it’s a thing that somebody’s aunt or grandmother was known for making every year” to bring to picnics, graduation parties and other family gatherings.

Advertise with us

When the pair started the contest five years ago at the Mall at Robinson to help restaurants and nonprofits coming out of the pandemic, it drew just a handful of contestants and 200 attendees. (Nick Hartner, who runs Mancini’s Bakery, won with a creative take on strawberry Italian bread.) This year’s event at The Block Northway in Ross drew 13 contestants and a sold-out crowd of 500, each of whom paid $10 to attend. Proceeds supported its participating local nonprofit partners.

Papa J’s, which dished up a Strawberry Pretzel Salad Gelato, was named 2026 People’s Choice Champion. Caffe Nero in Ambridge took home the Judges Choice award for its Strawberry Pretzel Salad Tart.

While Rennebeck didn’t eat the dessert growing up — in her Italian family, it was considered “too American” — “it’s so much fun to see how people celebrate it in every way.”

As evidenced by this year’s contest, countless cooks continue to put their own, creative spin on the original recipe.  Some of us are happy to remain traditionalists.

When Brentwood resident Mary Ann Hartigan recently made the dessert instead of a cake for her daughter Kimberly’s birthday, she reached for the classic, hand-written recipe her mother-in-law, Marie, gave her in 1981.

Advertise with us

Served at every picnic and family gathering, “I’ve been eating it all my life,” she says. “It’s nostalgic.”

Strawberry Pretzel Salad

PG tested

Gerry Franz Sullivan, who graduated from Brentwood High School in 1941 and was a longtime community supporter, shared this simple recipe in a booklet put out by the Brentwood Civic Club in 1960. It is thought to be one of the first recipes for Strawberry Pretzel Salad to appear in a cookbook.

Unlike other early versions of the dish, it calls for crushed pineapple to add a tangy, tropical sweetness. Fearing anarchy, I left it out of the dessert I shared with my co-workers. I also substituted 2½ cups fresh strawberries, even though frozen berries are often recommended to help the gelatin set faster and give the salad a firmer texture.

Advertise with us

For crust

2 cups pretzels, crushed

3 tablespoons sugar

¾ cup (1½ sticks) butter or margarine, melted

For filling

Advertise with us

1 8-ounce package cream cheese, room temperature

1 cup sugar

1 small contained whipped topping (such as Cool Whip)

1 large package strawberry gelatin

For topping

Advertise with us

2 cups boiling water

2 10-ounce packages frozen strawberries

1 small can crushed pineapple, drained

Preheat oven to 400 degrees.

Make crust: Mix crushed pretzels, sugar and melted butter or margarine in a bowl. Press into a 9-by-13-inch cake pan and bake for 7 minutes, then cool.

Advertise with us

While crust is cooling, make filling: In a bowl, blend cream cheese, sugar and whipped topping until smooth. (I used my KitchenAid mixer.) Spread over cooled crust in pan.

Prepare topping: In bowl, dissolve gelatin in boiling water. Add frozen strawberries and drained, crushed pineapple. Chill until almost set (about 1 hour) then pour over cream cheese mixture.

Chill until ready to use (at least 4 hours).

Serves 12-16.

— Gerry Franz Sullivan, Brentwood