There are too many chefs at Sea Monkey, but I've yet to see one of them in the kitchen during service.

The swish Strip District venue credits David Racicot, Ryan Hart and Michael Taylor with designing the menu, which promises to take “guests on a culinary journey through the Mediterranean and Japan, blending vibrant flavors into a modern MediterrAsian experience.”

Confusing enough on a website. Even more so when you're actually trying to order.

The Richard DeShantz Group has been giving Pittsburgh the razzle-dazzle since opening Meat & Potatoes in 2011. Its portfolio — Poulet Bleu, Fish nor Fowl, gi-jin, Butcher & the Rye, täkō tôrtä, Golden Gai, Pre-Amp, Sally Ann's and Coop de Ville — runs on a formula of high-design, escapist fun geared toward specific audiences while maintaining mass appeal. That formula has worked for 15 years, sometimes spectacularly, and the group has yet to permanently close a single concept.

Advertise with us

At Sea Monkey, DeShantz's immersive design instincts once again hit the mark. You'd never know this place used to be an ahead-of-its-time supermarket left vacant for a decade. But the end goal is still unclear to me after a couple of visits.

The room reads something like a Fantasy Island resort bar. With lounge seating, low couches and chairs arranged in pods, plants and colorful globe lanterns hanging overhead, it feels more like an outdoor rooftop than a dining room. There's a long bar lined with additional seating and a luxe speakeasy-style cocktail lounge called Vieux Carré hidden behind the kitchen.

After 10 p.m., Sea Monkey becomes a 21-plus ultra lounge, complete with bottle service à la 2026 Las Vegas pool party or a club in Los Angeles circa 2005. It’s not for me, but passing by on a recent Friday night the space looked active with people having a fun time, and that’s certainly a good thing.

The first thing you'll likely notice is the LED screen absorbing nearly the entire wall of the main room. On any given night it cycles through zen-inspired jellyfish pulsing through dark water, a music video synced to whatever the DJ is playing, or images that range from soothing to “what the heck is happening?”

That last category captures its role as a dinner destination for a general audience.

Advertise with us

Racicot is a genuinely creative chef who helped DeShantz open täkō and spent nearly a decade as executive chef of The Commoner at Hotel Kimpton before returning to the group this year. Taylor was the primary chef at gi-jin and as executive chef and partner of Golden Gai has cemented his role as one of the city’s most engaging chefs. Hart, a Culinary Institute of America graduate, is a longtime DeShantz chef who opened Poulet Bleu to much acclaim as chef de cuisine and later led the charge as the group’s corporate chef to open täkō tôrtä and gi-jin.

But it feels as if three talented people each wrote a menu that got cut and pasted together.

Mezze and tapas sections overlap redundantly and, with no apparent logic, include very non-Mediterranean clam dip and truffled grilled cheese. Then there’s a raw bar detour toward Japan with a touch of South America, plus a whole section of maki rolls. Also, caviar. Very expensive caviar.

There are, by the way, no prices listed on the digital menu. The smaller-plate bites land in the $12-$20 range, with larger-format plates about twice that. Be aware that the establishment also tacks on a 3% operating fee, which is meant to “offset the rising costs of operations and allows us to continue providing you the best experience possible.” The fee isn’t in lieu of a gratuity and is not distributed directly to the front-of-house staff.

Service is enthusiastic and well-intentioned. The staff are there to foster a good time and generally succeed, but they need to know the menu better. This isn’t on them, however. It’s a management issue. On one visit, a server couldn't help choose between two dishes because she'd only had the opportunity to try one of them.

Advertise with us

We ordered savoy cabbage. Dressed with chili crisp, cashew, yuzu mayo and a garlic and onion crumble, it was a smoky, spicy and sweet star turn for a vegetable that had a real moment over the winter.

On my first visit, the best thing on the menu was manti: marble-sized Turkish dumplings, tender with a pop, swimming in seasoned yogurt and chili crisp, hitting savory, sour and spicy notes in quick succession. By my second visit, the labor-intensive little bites were gone. Alas.

There were standouts that night, too. Salt-roasted beets, earthy-sweet and tender, arrived with preserved lemon labneh, pomegranate vinaigrette, candied pumpkin seeds and citrus segments, and played together like a band. Triple-cooked wings, a level-up from Racicot's thrice-cooked version on the earliest täkō menus, are top tier: juicy and wicked crispy, with a sauce that hits every note. Compressed celery with sesame alongside offered an elegant counterpoint.

The raw fish menus don’t cohere conceptually with the rest of what’s offered, though bluefin tuna, dressed with a dose of salsa macha and citrus koshu, is worth your attention, as is the hamachi with green apple and wasabi.

The DeShantz Group does raw fish better than just about anyone else in Pittsburgh but, as a pal said, “I'm having a hard time making the mental transition from the hummus to the raw tuna to the wings.”

Advertise with us

Just about everything else needs an edit or a keener eye before being sent out.

Pork belly calls for more heat, and with the too-sweet banana miso served alongside it reads like a midnight snack; a sharper counterpoint would help. A sweet potato arrived near-burnt on the edges and undercooked elsewhere, as if it had gone briefly through a fryer, surrounded by elements that didn't cohere.

Lamb rack had the mealy quality of meat sous vide but never seared, though the hot sauce and chimichurri served alongside it both had a nice pop. At $38 for three small chops, it also was the dish on the menu where portion, execution and price were most mismatched.

Cocktails feel like a lost opportunity, too. The blue negroni riff, listed as “like a negroni but blue," drinks like something ordered at a late-’90s bar primarily for its alcohol content with the addition of rum to a classic cocktail that doesn’t need it. The Amalfi Coast cocktail is better: apricot and nectarine add complexity without tipping into sweetness.

Toward the end of one visit, I was told only four portions of a gin and tonic riff remained, though it wasn't late and the bar was not busy. Whether the drinks are pre-batched isn't clear, but it felt at minimum like a failure to anticipate that gin and tonics are generally very popular drinks.

Advertise with us

I haven’t yet visited Vieux Carre, where I expect the drinks are much better given the DeShantz Group’s long history of running destination cocktail bars.

On two dinner visits, a Wednesday and a Thursday, the expansive room was fairly empty and didn't fill up as the evening went on. My hunch is that’s because it’s unclear who Sea Monkey is designed to attract before 10 p.m. It's a club for adults, but not exactly.

Are you a millennial and feel like you’ve “graduated” from Coop de Ville next door and arrive here seeking something more sophisticated? Kind of. Is it aimed at the Gen Z cohort living in the Strip District who want a meal in a cool spot? Could be.

According to a representative from the restaurant group, Racicot is running the day-to-day execution of the menu, and I wonder if giving him full rein might make the situation more cohesive. Sea Monkey needs streamlining and a through-line, even a tangential one. He's a talented chef who shines when given the right support, something the DeShantz team demonstrated at täkō.

They could also look to Pre-Amp, the Squirrel Hill outpost DeShantz opened a few months prior to Sea Monkey.

Advertise with us

Pre-Amp may be the group's most cohesive project since opening Poulet Bleu in 2018. The compact, rectangular space takes its cues from 20th-century Japanese record listening rooms and modern Mexico City audiophile bars, and it delivers on that concept with uncommon discipline. The room is cozy and cool at the same time, with a staff and much of the clientele exuding a youthful ease.

Danny Ryan runs the beverage program, which goes deep on coffee. If you can appreciate the difference between a nitro cold brew and a Kyoto-style one, this is your new favorite Pittsburgh coffee spot. The tea menu is equally considered, and the intentional emphasis on non-alcoholic options of all kinds feels very of-the-moment.

The menu shifted this spring from focaccia sandwiches to a focus on hot dogs and hamburgers, which are technically sandwiches but exist in their own categories. The move feels a bit disconnected from the rest of the vibe but the execution is excellent and who doesn’t love a hot dog and hamburger summer? Pre-Amp’s classic burger, a lacy double-patty smashburger with charred onions, cheese, mustard, ketchup and sweet pickles, is a major success at $12.

It’s notable that this burger is a scaled-down version of the one Racicot created while at The Commoner.