TORONTO — Greetings from a city often described as a collection of small villages with a “world famous” sandwich.
No, not Pittsburgh. Toronto.
In addition to sandwiches, this Canadian city and Pittsburgh share a common hog history.
In Pittsburgh, 19th-century pigs went hog wild. With no sanitation system to speak of, hogs played a role in cleaning up trash. But the animals also posed public health and safety issues themselves, according to “Hogs, Dogs and Dirt,” an article in The Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography.
By the 1840s, newspaper accounts detailed hogs wandering the streets, damaging gardens and entering homes. Despite fines for loose hogs and rewards for capturing them, they remained a problem for years.
In addition to pigs’ role in the city’s cleanliness, or lack thereof, they also constituted a major industry.
Within the memory, perhaps, of some Pittsburghers, Troy Hill and Herrs Island (now known as Washington’s Landing) were hubs for the meatpacking industry. Herrs Island was one of the largest stockyards in the U.S. in the 19th century.
Hogs were driven from the stockyards up Troy Hill’s infamous “Pig Hill” — the steep 24% grade of Rialto Street — to the slaughterhouses on Spring Garden Avenue. The industry declined, however, in the 1960s.

Similarly, Toronto claimed the largest pork processing and packing company in the British empire, the William Davies Company. Established originally by an English immigrant in 1854 as a stall selling cured ham and bacon, it found greater success as a meat processor and exporter. In the 19th century, Davies processed millions of pounds of pork for export, largely Canadian bacon. The company hit its peak during World War I.
Today, after two mergers, Maple Leaf Foods is the successor to the William Davies Company.
This dominance in porcine products may have been the reason Toronto was dubbed “Hogtown.” However, the moniker was also used at the turn of the 20th century as an insult by smaller Ontario cities resentful of Toronto’s tendency to monopolize the Canadian Parliament’s time and attention, to the detriment of other issues.
Whatever the origin of the nickname, Toronto has come to embrace it.
In 2016, John Tory, mayor of Toronto at the time, proclaimed the peameal bacon sandwich Toronto’s signature dish in honor of the city’s porcine legacy.
Peameal bacon, invented by William Davies, was fashioned into a sandwich by Carousel Bakery in the 200-year-old St. Lawrence Market in Old Town Toronto. Peameal bacon was so named because Davies’ butchers rolled the unsmoked, wet-cured lean pork loin in ground yellow peas to prepare it for shipment overseas. Today it is rolled in cornmeal, which forms a better crust.
The peameal bacon sandwich is still an attraction at Carousel Bakery for locals and tourists alike. Like the Pittsburgh Primanti Bros. sandwich, peameal bacon’s fame is loudly proclaimed in signs at the stand.
At Carousel, four fried yet moist slices of the meat — which bears no resemblance to American fatty, crispy bacon — are deposited between halves of a Portuguese bun. The bun is slightly firm and somewhat chewy. A classic addition is sweet, tangy maple mustard.
A simple, satisfying snack. No muss, no fuss — just meat and bread.

Yet peameal bacon isn’t the only popular sandwich here. For those looking for a maximalist approach to a pork sandwich, you couldn’t do much better than Porchetta & Co.’s House Special: 4 ounces of porchetta, cracklings, “truffle” sauce, parmesan, mustard and hot sauce.
I couldn’t say there was much difference, though, between that sandwich and the Just Porchetta sandwich — and probably not worth the $3 Canadian upcharge.
I added rapini, aka broccoli rabe, and roasted potatoes on the side.
Judging by online comments, Porchetta & Co.’s rep has come down in the world since its 2010 beginnings on Dundas Street West. Its current location, in the Financial District in an underground shopping concourse, is clean but lacking in charm.
Despite what I had read, I had absolutely zero wait time during a mid-afternoon visit and couldn’t have been happier with the sandwich. To make its eponymous porchetta, the fast-casual spot begins by marinating pork shoulder, then wraps it in cured skin on pork belly and roasts it. The skin is double-baked to give the cracklings — mmm — an extra-crunchy texture.
Tender, moist, chunky morsels of pork are layered onto a crusty roll with the chosen garnishes on top. In the case of the Just Porchetta, only pork, cracklings, mustard and hot sauce.
It’s a worthy item on Toronto’s menu. Peripatetic chef Anthony Bourdain once expressed his approval, couched in poetic terms, for the Toronto’s porky moniker on his series “The Layover.”
"I want to go to Hogtown,” he said. “A magical place, for magical animals, where a pig is always turning slowly, slowly on a spit somewhere close, and the scent of bacon lingers like wildflowers in the air.”
And while Toronto may call itself Hogtown, Pittsburgh once lived that name just as fully. Different cities, different sandwiches — but with parallel histories echoing with the sound of trotters.
I hope to return soon to enjoy life high on the hog.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.