If you’ve been following the Russells’ clenched-teeth scrabble to the top of New York society on HBO’s “Gilded Age” series, you may want to move one step closer to this tumultuous and lavish era by cooking some festive recipes of the time.
As chef Walter Staib says in the introduction to “The Gilded Age Christmas Cookbook: Cookies and Treats From America’s Golden Era” (Globe Pequot, $35), “The Gilded Age was a period of great affluence and opulence” and that extravagance extended to Christmas celebrations.
You can see this in the book’s gingerbread and butter cookies, elaborate cakes, luscious pies, pudding, custards and candies — beautifully photographed with decor to evoke the late 19th century.
Then, food was a way of displaying wealth and status.
Still, as cookbook author Becky Libourel Diamond noted during a video call from Seattle — where the Bucks County resident was promoting her book — not everyone had equal access to the era’s advantages. New York was very stratified, as we see in the television series.
“The term is not really endearing,” Diamond said. “It’s gilded on the surface, and then underneath is this layer of corruption.”
In the television series’ first episode, we watch as Bertha Russell (Carrie Coon) excitedly prepares for a “home visit” to impress New York’s very upper upper crust, to which she aspires. She has her chef prepare a sumptuous meal for 200 guests, only to see few accept her invitation.
Despite Bertha’s bitter disappointment, Diamond confirms that the food on display was authentic to the period.
“I really tried to stop and look at the different dishes,” Diamond said. “I do feel like that they did a good job.”
An opportune moment
Diamond, who works as a business librarian at Rutgers University, had already written gastronomic history books centering on the Victorian era, which encompasses the Mark Twain-named Gilded Age (1870s-1890s).
And as a complement to her research on her earlier books, she had investigated period recipes and recreated them for her blog.
“After a while I had so many I said, ‘Why not put it into a cookbook?’”
This thought process became her first cookbook focused on the era, “The Gilded Age Cookbook.” She published it in 2023, the year after the TV series began.
She continues to build on the historical theme with her Christmas cookbook, which also encompasses small passages on the origin of Christmas rituals (stockings, Santa Claus, Christmas cards), the celebrations of the epoch’s Black elite, as well as New Year’s and Hanukkah celebrations.
The wide lens is fitting for a period when people from many different cultures were coming together in the United States and sometimes sharing or being influenced by one another’s customs.
“If you saw your neighbor putting up a Christmas tree, you’d kind of be like, ‘What is that?’” Diamond said.
As her book shows, there were even different styles of gingerbread representing different parts of Europe from which immigrants had come.
It was also a period of great technological innovation, from the small scale to the grand.
Things like baking powder, baking soda and rotary egg beaters were new to the world. But the century also brought techniques for canning, and — crucially for all manufacturing, including the food industry — trains.
“The railroads were a game changer in getting foods around the country that people couldn’t have before,” Diamond said.
Suddenly lobster and oysters were available inland. Strawberries and citrus fruit arrived in northern states on trains from Florida in the dead of winter.
Historical recipes modernized
Though there are many historical tidbits peppered throughout the book, the main focus is the recipes. Sourced from historical documents — including her own family’s stash — Diamond has made them accessible to modern tastes, cooking methods and ingredients.
Despite ornate-looking results, the book’s recipes are easy to follow. For the few cases where she includes unfamiliar ingredients (citron, rosewater, orange flower water), Diamond includes a chapter on ingredients and techniques beginning bakers might find particularly helpful.
As a librarian, she had access to databases that contained 19th century periodicals like Ladies’ Home Journal, Good Housekeeping and Godey’s Lady’s Book. These sources were also useful for information on trends, traditions and decor of the time.
The historical recipes often needed extensive revision for a variety of reasons. Some recipes had scant instructions or no list of ingredients. Measurements might be vague: “a dessert spoonful,” “a wine glassful,” a “medium” oven temperature. Chemical leavening ingredients were new, and were different from today’s versions.
Even eggs were much smaller then.
“Some recipes might call for 10 eggs and you don’t need that many,” Diamond said.
To test the recipes and taste-test the results, she leaned on her membership in the Historic Foodways Society of the Delaware Valley, a Philadelphia-area organization that aims to promote and understand food history. Some members are professional chefs, and they offered suggestions.
“None of these recipes are overly complicated because I want people to be able to make them in their modern kitchens,” she said. She also offers options to substitute ingredients, if necessary.
As Diamond writes in the introduction to her book, her goal was to bridge the past and present — like she did in examining now-obscure sugar plums — while revisiting favorites that have endured for more than a century.
Scotch Shortbread
Cookbook author Becky Libourel Diamond notes that during the Gilded Age, shortbread was sent as a gift to friends at Christmas, often baked in a round pie shape. White sugar icing could be used to write the name of the recipient in the center and decorate the edges.
2 sticks (1 cup) unsalted butter
2 cups flour
1 cup cornstarch
1 cup confectioners’ sugar
Granulated sugar (for sprinkling on top)
Preheat oven to 325 degrees.
Melt butter in a saucepan over low heat.
Remove from heat and stir in flour, cornstarch and confectioners’ sugar. Mix well (may need to use hands to mix, as the dough can be crumbly).
Place dough in an ungreased 8-inch pie plate, pressing down to cover the bottom of the pan. Prick all over with a table fork.
Bake for 25-30 minutes (edges can brown, so check after 25 minutes).
Sprinkle with granulated sugar and cut into wedges immediately.
Place pie plate on a wire rack to cool.
Makes 8-10 wedges.
— “The Gilded Age Christmas Cookbook” by Becky Libourel Diamond






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.