Whether you’re in charge of cooking it, or are simply an invited guest, Thanksgiving dinner often comes with a certain amount of stress.
Hosts worry about getting everything on the dinner table at the same time, whether a diner has a food allergy they didn’t tell you about, or if someone remembered to buy the Cool Whip for the pumpkin pie.
Their guests, meanwhile, might be afraid of being drawn into an uncomfortable conversation about politics or being asked intrusive questions by a relative who’s had a little too much to drink. (It happens.)
The good news? At least you don’t have to fret about whether you’ll be able to find — and afford — the meal’s star ingredient. Frozen whole turkeys are in plentiful supply this year, experts say, and they’re going to cost pretty much the same in Western Pennsylvania as they did last year.
Shoppers may have felt their stomach drop when U.S. Department of Agriculture reported earlier this month that the wholesale price for frozen whole turkeys will average nearly $1.32 cents per pound for 2025 — a whopping 40% increase over last year’s price of almost 94 cents per pound.
The USDA attributed the increase to outbreaks of a severe form of bird flu known as highly pathogenic avian influenza, which affected hundreds of commercial flocks across the U.S. and millions of birds. Farmers are also raising about 5 million fewer turkeys in 2025 than they did in 2024, according to the report — 195 million this year, down from 200 million last year and 218 million in 2023.
“But growers and processors have been very resilient in this challenging time to meet consumer needs and make sure there’s a turkey on the table” at Thanksgiving, said Leslee Oden, president and chief executive officer of the National Turkey Federation.
Best known for the live domestic turkey it presents each year to the U.S. president (who “pardons” it), the New York-based trade association is the national advocate for all segments of the turkey industry in the U.S., including family farms and processing facilities.
Now in year four, avian flu has played “a significant role in our ability to raise turkeys,” Oden said. But while production for 2025 is significantly lower than in the previous two years, “you have to look at it in context in an entire year.... Everyone sees the numbers with what we’ve lost, but they don’t realize how hard our growers work year round.”
As for prices, Target this week was selling frozen Butterball turkeys for 99 cents a pound while Walmart was offering whole Shady Brook Farms or Honeysuckle White for 84 cents per pound, and Butterball All Natural Frozen Whole Turkeys for 97 cents a pound.
A turkey is free at Giant Eagle for shoppers who spend $350 by Nov. 9 (It can be redeemed through Nov. 30), after which holiday pricing of 99 cents per pound kicks in. And like last year, when the chain sold more than 250,000 turkeys, “we expect to be in a very strong in-stock position,” said spokesperson Jannah Drexler.
At Aldi stores, a Jennie-O whole frozen 14½-pound turkey is currently priced at $11.17, or 77 cents per pound.
Tom Charley, a fourth-generation grocer whose family owns two Shop ‘N Save stores in Greensburg and one in Murrysville, was cagey on whole turkey prices this season, but said it was comparable with what consumers paid last year. Frozen turkey breasts are currently advertised at $1.29 per pound at Shop ‘N Save through Nov. 5 on the chain’s weekly specials circular.
“If you are shopping with us, you will not be disappointed with price,” he said.
Charley added that there also will be “plenty” of turkeys to go around. “I got product. I’ve had no issue with inventory.”
He likens the hype by some media outlets about shortages and higher prices to the desire for clicks on an article.
“When people see the biggest item of the year [is going to be expensive], it’s easy to get them outraged or scared,” Charley said.
“It’s like the Weather Channel, where they say, ‘This is going to be the worst storm ever’ and it rains for five minutes.”
Oden noted that consumers often don’t realize that frozen turkeys sold for holidays often do not correlate with wholesale prices because grocery and big box stores use whole birds as “loss leaders” that make a minimal or non-existent profit to attract customers into the store to buy everything else for the Thanksgiving table — high-margin items like stuffing mixes, beverages and ingredients for side dishes and desserts.
“Retailers are wanting to keep that price low so more consumers come into the store,” Oden said.
The vast majority — 80% — are frozen, “and we are processing birds early this year into cold storage. So if you look at those numbers, they are up. We’re very confident in our frozen supply.”
According to the National Turkey Federation, between 30 and 35 million birds are sold for Thanksgiving, another 20 million over the December holidays and between 10 and 15 million for Easter. Minnesota was the country’s top turkey producer in 2024, raising 32 million birds, followed by North Carolina (27 million), Arkansas (25 million) and Indiana (20 million). Pennsylvania ranked eighth in production last year, with 7.7 million birds.
Each turkey producer is a little different when it comes to sizes, but on average, the most popular whole turkey size is a medium-size bird between 14 and 16 pounds that will comfortably feed six people, Oden said.
To make sure consumers are able to find that “iconic piece on the table,” she encourages cooks to shop early and pick one that fits the needs for your gathering.
To estimate how much turkey you need, go to eatturkey.org. A general rule of thumb is 1 pound per person for dinner and 1½ pounds per person if you want leftovers.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.