Domenica Merante Pry may not have Greek origins — she is Italian — but she has 28 years of experience in Greek cooking, specifically for the Philoptochos Autumn Food Fair.
The annual fair, held at Mt. Lebanon’s Holy Cross Greek Orthodox Church, is set for 11 a.m.-8 p.m. Oct. 1-2 at the church’s community center, 123 Gilkeson Road. It is a much anticipated fall event because of the homemade marvels that come from the church’s kitchen, including the beloved butter cookies koulourakia, the chicken rolls known as kotopitas, and grape leaves.
Organized by the church’s women’s group, the Ladies’ Philoptochos Society, the event benefits such charities as the KDKA Turkey Fund, Lending Hearts, Neighborhood Resilience Project, International Orthodox Christian Charities, Walk for Missions and Light of Light Missions. It attracts up to 4,000 people.
‘They just pulled me in’
Trained in Tuscany as a chef, Pry has become central in making all of the church’s specialties. But she had never cooked Greek cuisine until she was drawn into the church’s orbit nearly 30 years ago.
Pry’s children attended Holy Cross’ preschool, she said. From the preschool, she could smell the cooking upstairs in the church’s kitchen.
“I’d go up and see what they were doing, and they just pulled me in. I’ve been in there ever since.”
Previously Catholic, Pry became a member of the Greek Orthodox Church just this past May.
The Dormont resident was taught the intricacies of Greek cooking by the late Calliopi Hagelios, a church member who was known for her culinary prowess.
“She just got me involved in the community and the energy,” Pry said. “That church is amazing.”
One of the first things Hagelios taught Pry was how to make dolmades, or grape leaves. For a long period, the church had grape leaves made by local Greek restaurants for the fair. The homemade dolmades were revived three years ago.
Rolling 2,500 dolmades
Though the recipe doesn’t require many ingredients, each step takes time. Just rinsing the brine from the grape leaves, which are imported from Greece, takes two hours since the church makes 2,500 of the delicacies for the two-day festival.
“It’s a labor of love,” Pry said.
Despite the quantities made, the grape leaves (three for $4), sell out.
A couple with a vegetable and herb garden, Frank and Monica Moore, prepare the rice mixture that goes inside. They grow all of the herbs that go into the mixture.
“The chives, the parsley, the dill — everything that we put in comes from their garden,” Pry said. “It’s kind of awesome.”
Then up to 20 church volunteers form a production line to place the uncooked rice mixture into the grape leaves — an important instruction to note, Pry said.
“If you cook the rice first, you’re going to have a really mushy, unattractive filling,” she said. “Your grape leaf has to have a bite to it.”
(The church recipe accompanying this article recommends partial cooking.)
The grapes leaves are then rolled up and placed in pans. To keep the layers of leaves from sticking to the bottom of the pan or to each other, church volunteers place each layer atop sliced potatoes.
“That’s the best way when you’re making 2,500 of them,” Pry said.
The cooks place the pans in the oven to steam for three hours.
Pry said she used to make stuffed cabbage with a Slovenian neighbor, and calls grape leaves “the stuffed cabbage of the Greek world.”
‘So much butter’
In fact, both grape leaves and stuffed cabbage are part of a centuries-old tradition of stuffing vegetables, with roots in Ottoman cuisine. Former Ottoman countries – Greece was part of the empire for almost 400 years — all have their own customs and varieties of stuffed leaves or vegetables.
Being from an Italian background, none of this was familiar to Pry when she began. However, her subsequent training as a chef, and experience helping to run a Merante Brothers market, restaurant and coffee shop in Canonsburg for several years, all came in handy. (She currently works as a private chef and is a partner with her son Tony at Little Tony’s Mini Mart in Downtown.)
What surprised her at first about Greek cooking was the butter — in cookies, in phyllo, in sauces.
“I never used so much butter in my life,” she said. “The Italians do not use butter.”
But now that she’s been cooking Greek for nearly three decades, Pry might have a thing or two to teach native Greeks.
She went on a trip to Greece to the Moores’ vacation home on Ikaria. Her family and the Moores ordered grape leaves at a restaurant.
“It was our second night eating there and we were so excited,” she said.
“[Monica Moore] looks at me and I look at her and we’re like, ‘These are canned,’” she recalled, laughing. “The old lady who was cooking said, ‘I can’t do everything.’”
Pry said she understands where the woman was coming from, but said pointedly, “You’re getting the real stuff here in Pittsburgh, PA.”
The Philoptochos Autumn Food Fair will be held 11 a.m.-8 p.m. Oct. 1-2 at Holy Cross Greek Orthodox Church Community Center, 123 Gilkeson Road., Mt. Lebanon. More info at holycrosspgh.org.
Dolmades (Grape leaves)
This version is vegetarian, but Pry notes that you can use chicken broth instead of water and add meat such as beef or lamb. The version the church sells also includes chopped tomatoes.
2 cups olive oil, divided
2 cups yellow onions, chopped
2 cups rice
1 cup lemon juice, divided
2 bunches fresh green onions, chopped
1 cup parsley, chopped
2 tablespoons chopped dill
2 tablespoons chopped mint
Salt and pepper to taste
4 cups water, divided
1 large jar grape leaves
Heat 1½ cups olive oil in a large saucepan with a lid over medium heat. Add chopped onions and cook until golden brown.
Add rice, ¾ cup lemon juice, green onions, parsley, dill and mint and season to taste with salt and pepper. Add about 1 cup of water.
Cover pan and simmer for a few minutes; let cool.
Rinse and drain grape leaves.
Fill each leaf with a teaspoon of the mixture carefully, making sure that the shiny sides of the leaves remain on the outside. Do not roll too tightly to allow rice to expand.
Place a few coarse leaves on the bottom of a 9- by 13-inch pan and arrange dolmades, side by side and layer upon layer, until all leaves and filling are used.
Add remaining 3 cups of water, remaining ½ cup of oil and remaining ¼ cup of lemon juice to the pan.
Cover dolmades with a few coarse leaves and foil.
Bake at 350 degrees for about 1 hour 45 minutes, or until rice and leaves are cooked.
Serve cold.
Makes about 40 grape leaves.
— Holy Cross Church Philoptochos Society 1994 cookbook







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.