You may not think of Erie as a hotbed of hot peppers, but that is where Kevin Keiller, proprietor of Scorch Garden hot sauces, grew up.

His grandmother Doris got him started on pepperoncini when he was just a wee lad.

“My grandmother got me addicted to hot peppers back when I was 5,” Keiller said, chatting amiably during a rainy Taco Tuesday at Bethel Park Farmers Market.

Besides selling a lineup of 14 hot sauces online at scorchgarden.com ($12-$17 each), Keiller, now a Beechview resident, also operates Tacos 2 Go food truck at local markets.

Advertise with us

He got the knack of brining and fermenting by watching his grandma make pickles, skills that later came in handy when he needed to ferment peppers for his business.

As a boy, he would challenge himself with questionable heat-seeking activities.

“I would drink hot sauce and then go outside and do yard work to see how long I could go without drinking,” he recalled. “One day I found myself eating raw hot dogs and Tabasco just to get the hot sauce in me.”

The hot dog stunt seemed like a good idea until “a few hours later,” he admitted.

Scorch Garden's pepper mash fermenting in jars. (scorchgarden.com)

Sauces for chiliheads

Keiller says his hot sauces are for aficionados, or “chiliheads.” He defines these superfans as people who either “don’t have any capsaicin receptors” — capsaicin is the chemical that gives chili peppers their burning sensation — “or they’ve burned their tastebuds out” and need extreme heat to taste anything at all.

Advertise with us

He puts his sauces on a heat index that goes from 6.5 (“not mega hot”) to 10 (“just below weapons grade”), with evocative names like Molten Inferno and Toilet Breaker.

Scorch Garden sauces do not use artificial colors, preservatives or thickeners. His website also denigrates pepper extracts found in some hot sauces as “a cheap shortcut” that necessitates the use of preservatives.

When Keiller began experimenting with creating hot sauce in 2016, his mental starting point was the popular Louisiana-style hot sauce Frank’s RedHot, the only bottled sauce that he liked. Frank’s has a simple recipe of five ingredients, and one type of pepper (cayenne). But Keiller wanted more.

“I needed more heat and more flavor,” leading him to add ingredients like onion, herbs, lemon and even pineapple.

For the heat in his hot sauces, he turns to his “Gang of Nine,” which he mixes and matches: Greek pepperoncini, Hungarian wax, jalapeño, Mexican serrano, cayenne, red habanero, bhut jolokia, Trinidad Scorpion and the grimly named Carolina Reaper, one of the hottest chili peppers in the world, according to the Guinness Book of World Records.

Advertise with us

The list trips quickly off Keiller’s tongue like a spicy tongue twister.

He estimates that he grows 10-15% of his peppers in containers at his Clairton production site, but gets the rest from a Mennonite farmer who owns West View Acres in Somerset County. They met at a produce auction at the Maryland border.

“It’s this wonderful little family,” he said. “He’s got like nine kids running around. When you go into the barn, you’re going to see cats hanging from the rafters.”

It was a fortuitous meeting, just about when he was hoping to ramp up his business, in 2018.

“Most farmers, they don’t do the superhot [peppers] because that’s very niche,” he said.

Advertise with us

Scorch Garden now requires 1,800-2,000 pounds of peppers annually.

Scorch Garden owner Kevin Keiller with his Tacos 2 Go truck at the Greater Pittsburgh Food Truck Festival at Hollywood Casino at The Meadows. (Sono Motoyama / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Returning to his roots

Keiller, 51, is a long way from his previous, tech-centric job as a multimedia producer. When he retired at 48, he decided to finally return to his boyhood loves: cooking and peppers.

At 15, his first job was at Erie’s Waldameer Park, where he would cook oxtail sandwiches, hot sausage, corn and hot dogs for corporate picnics — up to 700 people.

“That’s when the bug bit me,” he said.

Always fascinated by the Industrial Revolution, Keiller said he “loves” mass production.

Advertise with us

“So catering for 700 people, that was right up my alley.”

He doesn’t usually cook for hundreds of diners these days, but he is expanding his reach. Scorch Garden sauces were picked up by the Hudson Group, which supplies airport vendors. In addition to farmers markets, they are for sale at Pittsburgh International Airport and may be available at other airports shortly.

“I decided now I’m retired, I'm going to go do my thing,” Keiller said.