The Carmody family has been serving diners throughout the North Hills for more than 70 years, and like most longtime restaurateurs, they’ve tweaked the menu here and there to keep up as food tastes have changed.
Joseph and Ethel Carmody’s offerings were fairly low-key when they opened the original eatery on Wexford-Bayne Road in Franklin Park in 1952. Geared to local farmers and millworkers who lived nearby, the small restaurant that got its start as a gas and convenience store featured a simple menu of chipped ham sandwiches, bread pudding and homemade pies that “Eth” would leave out on the counter. Customers paid on the honor system, putting money into a box on the bar.
By the time their son Mike, a former mechanic at the airport who went into the Army after high school, took over after his father’s death in the early 1970s, the restaurant was known for its signature Club Burger and fancier dishes like veal scallopini and flounder stuffed with crabmeat. It added dining rooms and downstairs banquets rooms as it expanded over the years.
When third-generation brothers Paul and Sean Carmody opened their upscale pub that shares the family name on Neville Island in 2016, it debuted with an all-scratch menu featuring flatbreads, sandwiches, steak-blend burgers and fish tacos. The plan was to eventually serve more seasonal restaurant fare like the salmon and crabcake dinners offered today.
Still, one dish has stood the test of time — even as palates have evolved across generations, changing what and where Americans eat.

It’s the restaurant’s turtle soup, made with a rich, tomato-based broth flavored with ground carrots, celery, peppers and frozen snapping turtle meat that’s seasoned just this side of spicy with a secret blend of spices.
Carmody’s Grille (pronounced “car-ma-deez”) goes through two 32-quart batches of the spicy soup each and every week. Some customers, the brothers say, love it so much they make a special trip to the restaurant on Grand Avenue just to order it. Others buy several containers of it to-go to enjoy later at home.
“Grandma and [their father’s sister] Aunt Kate ran the kitchen, and it was their recipe,” says Sean, who was raised in Ohio Township and attended Avonworth High School.
Both men grew up working at the restaurant, which in 1970 was moved 100 feet to a new location on Nicholson Road to make way for the construction of Interstate 79. (The building was put on rollers and moved by truck.)
“In high school, you never wanted to be home on a Friday afternoon because if somebody called off, guess who worked,” says Sean.
The original Carmody’s, which closed in 2014 after 62 years, ended up being run by their aunt Eileen Mayer of Richland after their father died of cancer in 2001. Sean was busy working as a lawyer after earning a law degree from Duquesne University and Paul, who studied criminal justice there, ended up working in the construction business.
Still, “Paul and I always wanted to run a place together,” says Sean. So when they saw the building at 4905 Grand Ave., formerly the home of Neville Hotel Bar & Grille, was for sale, they took their chances.
As expected (and longtime customers of the original Carmody’s hoped for), they brought their family recipes with them to the new space. That, of course, included their grandma’s turtle soup. And since day one, “we always have a pot of it going,” says Sean.
Wealthy man’s dish
There is a rich history of eating soup made with green sea turtle in the Caribbean, with some scholars tracing it back to the 14th century. The dish made its way to England in the mid-1700s when transatlantic seamen who had to eat turtle meat out of desperation to survive learned to love it and sing its praises.
In the latter part of the 18th and early 19th centuries, turtle dressed in the “West India way” to make soup “after the English fashion” became a status marker for European and American upper- and middle-class diners.

Because turtle was an exotic — and extremely pricey — meat, “it had a reputation as a rich person’s dish” that reached its zenith in the early 19th century, says Paul Freedman, a history professor at Yale University and co-author of “Bite by Bite: American History through Feasts, Food, and Side Dishes” (Atheneum Books for Young Readers, $18).
Long enjoyed by Native Americans, turtle was served in Andrew Jackson’s White House, as well in some of the fanciest restaurants in on the East Coast, including New York's famous Delmonico’s and Philadelphia’s Bookbinders. Turtle soup also was featured in books like Edith Wharton’s 1920 novel “The Age of Innocence” as a sign of luxury and power.
But it’s actually a more complicated story in the the U.S., Freedman notes, because it was not exclusively a wealthy man’s food in Southern cities like New Orleans.
The soup stirred together in the U.S. a century ago featured highly prized diamondback terrapin, a small coastal turtle native to the brackish coastal swamps of the Eastern and Southern United States, including the Chesapeake Bay (which is why it was popular in cities like New York, Baltimore and Philadelphia). Yet historically, it was made with green sea turtles found in the Caribbean, “so it was something a lot of African American chefs specialized in and knew how to make,” he says.
Also, when terrapins became harder to find due to overfishing and cooks had to substitute common snapping turtle, the soup fell out of favor. What was once the epitome of high living became more identified as a rural, poor Southern kind of dish “because snappers were all over the place,” says Freedman.
Both Heinz and Campbell's jumped on the terrapin train in the 1920s and ’30s with more-affordable “real” canned turtle soups and “mock” turtle soups made of calf's head that mimicked the flavor and gelatinous texture of their turtle-based counterparts. But by the 1960s, as American tastes changed, they were discontinued (though you can still find a mock turtle soup in a can from Cincinnati-based Worthmore).
Concerns about conservation also contributed to it disappearing from American menus; the diners who loved it had children and grandchildren who grew up with different foods and ideas about what signified luxury and what was ethical to eat.
Consider the fact that many people found (and still find) the thought of eating a reptile off-putting, even though it can be delicious, and it’s no surprise it no longer appears on very many menus.
As Freedman — who was surprised to learn of the soup on a Pittsburgh menu — puts it: “Once it plunged through a period of unfamiliarity, it becomes like, ‘Why?’”
Finished with a dash of sherry
Depending on where it’s made, turtle soup — also sometimes called snapper soup, leading some to believe it’s fish — can vary in taste. Creole versions tend to be a little spicier and often include hard-boiled egg while up North it’s a little more rustic and stew-like.
What’s universal is that turtle soup starts with a tomato base and includes lots of chopped vegetables. And it’s almost always finished with a dash of sherry just prior to consumption.
At Carmody’s, they do it a little differently. Cooking sherry is added to the soup as it simmers for three hours instead of being offered as a garnish. But occasionally, a customer will insist on a shot to top their bowl with some extra flavor.
While the name turns some customers off, “people are mesmerized by it,” says Paul. “The first question is always, ‘Is it really turtle meat?’”
But once you try it? “The mystery is gone,” says Sean. “It’s almost like a spicy vegetable soup ... People would cry if we took it off the menu.”
Back in the day, local farmers would bring giant snappers they caught in local ponds to the restaurant in Franklin Park and there would be races before the animals were butchered and cooked on site. Both brothers remember playing with turtle shells that had been painted with numbers and stashed in a corner of the bar when they were little kids.
Today, the under-shell meat is farm-raised in the South and bought wholesale in frozen, 5-pound blocks that resemble a pot roast.
If the thought of eating a reptile makes you queasy, we get it. You can always dig into a bowl of “mock” turtle soup made with ground beef, veal or oxtail if you’re lucky enough to find a restaurant that serves it.
But if you’d like to follow in Carmody’s footsteps and bravely take a crack at it in your own kitchen, we offer two recipes from trusted sources: Brennan’s Restaurant in New Orleans, which has been around since 1946, and the Old Original Bookbinder’s restaurant in Philadelphia.
While the sale of green sea turtle meat is not legal in the United States due to federal protection under the Endangered Species Act, you can find farmed, boneless snapping turtle meat at Strip District Meats. Sourced by Land & Sea, it comes frozen and costs $26.99 a pound.
Brennan’s Restaurant Turtle Soup
4 tablespoons unsalted butter
1½ pounds turtle meat, trimmed of all sinew and cut into ¼-inch cubes
8 cloves garlic minced
2 medium-size onions, chopped fine
4 stalks celery, chopped fine
2 medium-size green peppers, chopped fine
1½ tablespoons kosher salt, plus to taste
1 teaspoon freshly ground black pepper
2 medium-size Creole tomatoes, seeded and chopped fine
¾ cup all-purpose flour
3 quarts beef stock
1 cup Worcestershire sauce
2 tablespoons Crystal brand pepper sauce, or other relatively mild pepper sauce
2 tablespoons finely chopped Italian (flat-leaf) parsley leaves
2 tablespoons finely chopped fresh thyme leaves
5 large eggs, hard-boiled, chopped fine
6 ounces fresh spinach, washed, stemmed and leaves sliced fine
Zest from 3 lemons, chopped fine
⅓ cup fresh lemon juice
½ cup good-quality sherry
Over medium-high heat, melt the butter in a heavy 7-quart saucepan.
Add turtle meat and garlic.
Cook until the meat is no longer pink, about 5 minutes, stirring occasionally.
Stir in onions, celery, sweet peppers, kosher salt and pepper.
Cook until the vegetables start to become translucent, about 10 minutes.
Add tomatoes and cook about 5 minutes, stirring often so the bottom of the pan does not scorch.
Reduce the heat to medium.
Dust the vegetables with flour and cook 5 minutes, stirring constantly and scraping the pan bottom clean so the flour does not burn.
Slowly add stock, stirring and scraping the pan bottom constantly to prevent dough balls from forming.
Stir in Worcestershire, pepper sauce, parsley and thyme.
Simmer 30 minutes.
Add eggs, spinach, lemon zest, lemon juice and sherry.
Continue simmering 10 minutes more.
— brennansneworleans.com
Old Original Bookbinder’s Snapper Soup
The original recipe in this 50th anniversary cookbook from 1965 calls for cooking a 5-pound frozen snapping turtle. That’s hard to find in 2025 (and anyway, who wants to cut up and cook a turtle?) So we approximated the amount of meat you’d need instead.
3 quarts beef stock
2 carrots, peeled and chopped
2 stalks celery, chopped
3 onions, chopped
½ teaspoon marjoram
Salt and pepper, to taste
2 cups tomato puree
Dash of Tabasco sauce
1 bay leaf
2 cloves garlic, minced
½ cup melted butter
1½ cups flour
1½ pounds snapping turtle meat
3 hard-cooked eggs, chopped
1 cup sherry
2 lemons, halved and thinly sliced
In large soup kettle, combine beef stock, carrots, celery, chopped onion, marjoram, salt and pepper, tomato puree, a dash of Tabasco, bay leaf and garlic.
Simmer for 30 minutes, then strain.
Mix ½ cup melted butter with 1½ cups flour and beat into the soup until smooth.
Cut snapper meat into small pieces and add to soup.
Stir in chopped hard-cooked eggs, and mix to combine.
Stir in sherry and lemons, then allow soup to simmer for 30 minutes.
Serve soup in a tureen. Into each soup bowl, ladle some of the snapper meat, 2 half slices of lemon and some soup.
Pass a small pitcher or beaker of sherry, and let each person add some to his own taste.
Serves 12.
— “A Treasury of Great Recipes, 50th Anniversary Edition: Famous Specialties of the World's Foremost Restaurants Adapted for the American Kitchen” by Vincent and Mary Price






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.