As spring and summer emerge in Pittsburgh, there’s a dessert that seems to always make its way to cookouts, picnics and holiday spreads: strawberry Jell-O pretzel salad.

There’s a debate about the treat’s origins — with some claiming it has southern roots in the 1960s — but John Chamberlin and Rachael Rennebeck believe strawberry Jell-O pretzel salad is a Pittsburgh thing.

That’s why Chamberlin and Rennebeck, co-founders of YaJagoff! Media, started the Strawberry Jell-O Pretzel Salad Stand-off in 2022.

Rennebeck said the media company had watched Picklesburgh grow bigger and bigger, and as small business and nonprofits struggled to regain momentum following the COVID-19 pandemic, they asked: “How do we use that concept of Picklesburgh with something else?” And the standoff was born.

Advertise with us

“I had an aunt that made it every picnic — Aunt Jean O’Laughlin brought the strawberry Jell-O pretzel salad,” Chamberlin recalled. “And it was a thing, everybody had that aunt or grandmother or grandparent that brought it. And that's why we thought, well, this is something we can kind of hang our hat on.”

The competition has grown through word of mouth alone, Rennebeck said, and has attracted more people than she and Chamberlin could have imagined.

“Now we’re like, we need to sit down and think about how this becomes a destination next year, because it has grown organically each year. We want to be able to be able to celebrate it, because Pittsburgh loves Pittsburgh,” Rennebeck said, “and we love things that are affiliated with Pittsburgh — so, things like pickles and pierogies and now strawberry pretzel.”

On May 10, the fourth annual standoff will take place at The Block Northway in Ross from noon-2 p.m. with 12 local contestants, all of whom will be making their own version of a strawberry-pretzel-salad treat.

The winner receives the opportunity to donate $1,000 to a nonprofit or charity of their choice (courtesy of Mancini’s and Preferred Insurance). The chosen nonprofits of each purveyor will join them at the competition, garnering votes for their respective contestant.

Advertise with us

The winner will also get the chance to join Chamberlin and Rennebeck on the “YaJagoff! Late Night” show, a table next to them at the May 17 Pittsburgh Pierogi Festival on the South Side to sell their winning strawberry pretzel creation and, of course, bragging rights.

A rule was set for the first ever standoff in 2022 that has stood since: “It doesn’t have to be just strawberry Jell-O pretzel salad,” Chamberlin said. “It has to be your take on it.”

And so the standoff’s first-ever winner was Mancini’s Bakery, which won with a strawberry pretzel salad bread in 2022.

The typical ingredients are strawberries, strawberry Jell-O, whipped cream, cream cheese, crunched up pretzels and butter, said Chamberlin. But he and Rennebeck don’t provide an ingredients list — sticking with their tradition of creative freedom.

“I know of two purveyors this year alone who are not using Jell-O at all because they don’t like either the health benefits or that it’s so artificial,” Rennebeck explained. “Someone's actually using a Black woman-owned jam in lieu of Jell-O, so that it’s the same sort of essence, but you get away with not having to use the gelatin.”

Advertise with us

The entries — there is a debate among fans on whether strawberry pretzel salad is a dessert or a salad — will be judged by the event’s 300 anticipated attendees (who each get one vote and a chance to sample each offering) as well as a panel of five judges.

It costs $5 to attend, and tickets can be purchased online at YaJagoff! Media’s website, yajagoff.com.

“The overall winner is based on, as we say, yinzer taste buds,” Rennebeck said.

Though no one involved profits from the event — except the chosen nonprofit of the winner — the money collected from attendees this year will allow each contestant to receive around $100 to help offset the cost of ingredients, Rennebeck said, noting the increasing prices of food items.

The contestants for this year’s stand-off include: Aycho Melange bakery, Cafe Nero in Ambridge, Doug Heilman, Cooking Comedy Chaos, Cookie Cookie Ice Cream, Flour Power, Jay Obertance, Jenny Lee Swirl Bread, Kemi's Kitchen, Nothing Bundt Cake, Shayla Penn and Spectrum Fudge.

Advertise with us

Going into its fourth year, Rennebeck said they’ve enjoyed watching how excited Pittsburgh communities get over the recipes.

For some standoff goers, Chamberlin said it elicits a memory of “who used to make it and how they made it, what they were doing at every picnic.”

“Just to think one day we just had this crazy idea of strawberry Jell-O pretzel salad,” he said. “And now here it is in its fourth year, growing and it's doing good things.

“For us, that's cool, just to see how it's grown, the fervor for this silly little idea that we had coming out of COVID-19.”