Driving through Wheeling, an aging steel town on the Ohio River, you would never imagine that nestled in a Victorian townhouse on 14th Street lay an Ali Baba’s cave full of imported food and wine.

Engineer Dominick Cerrone bought the building — known as the Good Mansion because it was owned by a merchant named L.S. Good — almost on a whim in 2003. Unsure of what to do with the historic home, he at first rented it out to students to cover some costs.

A few years later, Cerrone and some friends got to talking about how there wasn’t a good wine shop in this part of West Virginia. He realized the townhouse had already, in the past, attracted people who simply wanted to tour its interior. Adding the sale of a carefully curated wine selection would only enhance the site’s appeal as a destination.

“And so that’s what I did,” Cerrone said, opening Good Mansion Wines in 2006 with a focus on Italian and French wines.

Advertise with us

‘Right place at the right time’

Wheeling’s location, at the nexus of West Virginia, Ohio and Pennsylvania — about 60 miles southwest of Pittsburgh — also gave the fledgling business access to a varied market, including Pennsylvanians who were “not necessarily happy with the state store system.”

When he was opening, he also found that some West Virginia wholesalers had a fine selection likely because they were catering to the luxury Greenbrier resort in White Sulphur Springs.

The wine shop immediately attracted the attention of the then-growing market of wine drinkers.

“I was at the right place at the right time,” he said. “We got Pittsburgh and Western Pennsylvania customers right away.”

Clients began voicing their other desires. Incrementally, Cerrone added cheese and salumi, imported olive oil and balsamic vinegar, truffles and truffle products. Of Italian descent, Cerrone expanded his list of imports with frequent trips to Italy, where he met local producers and began establishing strong relationships.

Advertise with us

“We didn’t go crazy all at once,” he said. “We tested the market and expanded over time.”

In terms of the breadth of its offerings, Cerrone compares Good Mansion Wines to Eataly, the international chain of stores, restaurants and events that highlight Italian products.

Let them eat cake

In the midst of this growth, Cerrone met his now husband, Olivier Thiry, in 2012. Originally from Toulouse, Thiry was living in Paris at the time, working as an IT consultant.

After the couple’s marriage in 2013, Thiry moved to Wheeling in 2015 and — in a striking career change — became the pastry chef at Good Mansion when the business added a full-scale bakery in 2016. Thiry had attended brief courses at the Lenôtre Culinary Arts School in Paris, but learned largely through experience.

He creates everything from breakfast pastries to elaborate desserts from scratch. For the Christmas season, he offers three kinds of bûches de Noël — seasonal desserts that bakers in France often spin into ornamental fantasies.

Advertise with us

“If you read the recipe and you see the different steps, it’s pretty simple,” he claimed of French patisserie.

He is aided by simply being French, and having been exposed to the high level of pastrymaking in the country. He has often been disappointed by renowned bakeries in the U.S., he said, where the chefs have not had the benefit of his native experience.

“What makes a difference is the experience that I have as a consumer,” he said. “I’ve known since I was a kid what a croissant should taste like.”

Cerrone — also after brief training in France — took on duties as the chief bread maker with a team of two other bakers.

“Luckily, we’re confined to a small market here, so we’re able to keep the quality control tight,” said Cerrone, who buys imported French flour and uses live starters for his crusty, golden loaves.

Advertise with us

The couple are perhaps aided by their technical backgrounds — Cerrone’s a civil engineer — and their aptitude for patient experimentation.

“There’s so much trial and error,” Cerrone said. “You get the initial training and then you tweak things.”

After more than eight years, they seem to have gotten it down to a science.

‘Seminal memory’

The pair share a passion and respect for food, as well as a near mania for getting things exactly right.

Cerrone is still inspired by sense memories of his early trips to Paris to visit Thiry, who was living in the Belleville neighborhood.

Advertise with us

“There was just this incredible nondescript neighborhood bakery there,” he said. “To this day when we go back to France, I think it's one of the best that I've ever been to.... Just down the stairs and cross the street, and it was the most incredible thing I ever tasted.”

At Good Mansion, Cerrone wants to replicate that experience of deliciousness.

“You know how you try to reproduce a memory, a seminal memory?”

Cerrone, whose mother’s family is from the Marche region and whose father grew up south of Rome, is equally inspired by Italy. He admires the small rural farmers and artisans who have a deep pride in their products.

“It’s a country that makes things,” he said. “There's an emerging market in Italy over the last 20 years of these family producers who are so close to their land, their product.”

Advertise with us

Good Mansion was able to establish contacts with many small businesses through an Italian food broker. And it found a willing home market that literally ate everything up.

“People want a more vertical food selection than what the current market in small middle American town has to offer.”

Holiday inspiration

Vertical is right. In the townhouse, food is stacked high and stuffed into every corner and placed decoratively ascending a staircase. The abundance of distinctive, high-quality products makes this an obvious destination for food lovers and those who have gourmets on their holiday gift lists.

 
 
 
View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Good Mansion Wines (@goodmansionwines)

The merchants have a solid customer base from southwestern Pennsylvania, but folks come from as far away as Columbus and Cleveland, Ohio.

For the holiday season, the business is staging a post-pandemic return of weekly wine tastings and bûches de Noël will be available the Friday before Christmas. They’ll have housemade and imported Italian fruitcakes, and a handpicked list of hundreds of imported Italian and French food products, including cookies, chocolates, liqueurs, fruit confit, pastas, tomato products, olive oils, balsamic vinegars, jams and crackers. And of course, imported and domestic wines are here to be scooped up.

Advertise with us

If you happen to have built up an appetite on your drive over, a small café offers soups, quiche and sandwiches on Good Mansion bread.

And they do big business in panettone. Good Mansion has a wide selection of panettone made by specialty bakers in Italy, with different fillings and flavor profiles.

“We’re Panettone Central,” Cerrone said. “I almost don’t want to tell you too much because it’ll give other retailers ideas. But we sell a lot of it.”

Even Cerrone seems a bit overwhelmed as he contemplates the bounty of goods and anticipated influx of holiday shoppers — problems of his own making. But he is content.

“It's a lot of work, but this is a comfortable business for a couple,” he said. “There's a symbiosis between selling wine and baking. If you get that marriage, it's good.”

Good Mansion Wines is located at 95 14th St., Wheeling, W.Va. Open daily 9 a.m.-7 p..m.; goodmansionwines.com