Lunch at the Pittsburgh Theological Seminary now comes scratch-made by a team of Pittsburgh-based chefs. A weekday hearty hot lunch might include items such as shepherd’s pie, scratch-made soup, build-your-own salad and just-baked oatmeal cookies.

While the hungry seminarians are eating, those same chefs are working on their own projects. On any given day, Jen Saffron and her team from Sprezzatura, an events and catering company, could be heavy into soup production while on the other side of the expansive kitchen, the crew from Pittsburgh Pie Guy gets busy building savory and sweet hand pies.

The new four-way partnership between Sprezzatura, Pittsburgh Pie Guy, Benjamin Bishop Pastry Chef and the seminary is a resourceful way to turn an underutilized space into a win-win for the institution and food business owners aiming to advance their enterprises.

“This is something I never considered until Jen came to me about it,” says Pittsburgh Pie Guy’s Lou Butler. “You wouldn't think of something like this because it's so outside the normal route of business. It's allowed me to think about growing my business in ways I didn't expect.”

Advertise with us

Here’s how it works: Saffron, Butler and Bishop, partnered under an LLC called “LBJ Lunchtime,” prepare hot meals for the seminary and its guests and oversee catering for board meetings, retreats and other events. In return, they pay a sharply reduced rent, which includes the use of cooking equipment and storage space.

“This was an old-school, corporate cafeteria before COVID. There was a lot of fried food and hamburgers,” Saffron says. “Then, they would call in outside caterers to handle board meetings and the like. It didn't make sense.”

Pittsburgh Theological Seminary, founded in 1794, is one of the oldest educational institutions in the United States. Its students pursue master’s and doctoral degrees in various theological fields on a beautiful 10-acre campus in East Liberty.

The seminary’s kitchen was closed for the early months of the pandemic, later reopening for partial service. The organization decided to improve the food program following an internal study.

“The way that I talk about food and the table is something that often gets overlooked in the Christian faith,” says the Rev. Dr. Asa Lee, president of the seminary.

Advertise with us

“It's actually something that's central to the narrative of fellowship. One of the core practices of our faith, communion, happens after dinner. So, often what I say is, not only is the soul redeemed in the act of communion, but tables are redeemed to be a place of encounters.”

Representatives from the seminary connected with Saffron, who was temporarily working at Fulton Commons following a 2023 electrical fire in the basement of Millvale Food + Energy Hub that forced her to move from the space she’d cooked in since 2018. Butler was also working in Fulton Commons, but was hoping to have more physical space to grow Pittsburgh Pie Guy.

“What an opportunity it is for us to have the time, space and energy to think about our businesses, where we are also here to help assist the hospitality program of this institution,” Saffron says.

Butler started his operation in 2012. A couple of years later, he took what turned out to be a more than seven-year hiatus. During that time, he was in and out of Pittsburgh, traveling in Europe and working at restaurants on the West Coast. Butler relaunched Pittsburgh Pie Guy two years ago, selling a globally inspired assortment of savory and sweet hand pies, quiches and traditional fruit pies at five farmers markets and for home delivery.

Bishop worked in fine dining early in his career and later taught baking and pastries at a culinary school in Lancaster prior to changing lanes to work in social services for people with severe mental illness for 15 years. A life rethink during the pandemic drew him back to the pastry kitchen.

Advertise with us

For the past couple of years, he’s worked on a small scale, crafting artistically prepared sweet treats for individual clients.

“This is a big opportunity to be in a space to grow my business in a way that I might not have been able to do otherwise,” Bishop says. “I can afford to have a space where I can prepare bulk orders and generate more business while being fiscally sound as I do it.”

LBJ has free reign to design the food program for the seminary so long as it meets the nutritional needs of students and staff.

“We listen to the community here. Their feedback informs what we serve,” Butler says, noting that there are typically vegan and gluten-free options available. “We're still learning what people here like to eat.”

Saffron says she hopes to begin adding public events such as “Meatball Madness” and wine tastings in the not-too-distant future. The seminary’s large dining room is flooded with natural light, but could use a bit of love to make it feel less humdrum.

“We're thinking now about how we're going to zhuzh this space up,” Saffron says.