Even if one isn’t privy to his family’s growing reputation, Jason Frye’s T-shirt immediately gives away their dairy affinity with the slogan “Cheese. Cheese. Cheese.”
Frye is head cheesemaker and co-owner of Pleasant Lane Farms, a family-run artisan cheese producer in Latrobe.
Four years after adding cheese production to their farmstead in Westmoreland County, the Fryes are working to grow Pennsylvania’s artisan cheese market and winning some major awards along the way.
At the American Cheese Society Conference’s Judging and Competition Awards ceremony held in Buffalo, N.Y., from July 10-13, Pleasant Lane Farms took home six awards while competing against 1,596 entrants. This year marked Frye’s third competition, and his highest award tally yet.
They included first place for their quark and cheddar cheese curds, second place for their roasted garlic cheese curds, and third place for each of their 1976 reserve farmstead Gouda, blackjack, and sharp farmstead cheddar.
Frye grew up on the dairy farm with his parents, who bought the land in 1976 from legendary golfer and Latrobe native Arnold Palmer and siblings. However, the family’s farming presence dates back much further: They started farming in this county in 1795.
To this day, “there are quite a few cousins once removed, twice removed, that are farmers milking cows right here in Westmoreland County,” Frye said.
Pleasant Lane Farms is considered a small farm today. But when Frye was growing up, “this was an average-sized dairy farm in Pennsylvania [with] 50 cows typically worked by the family,” he said.
After being raised on the farm, he left rural Pennsylvania for 20 years to live in Philadelphia and work as the CTO of a software engineering company.
When he returned to life on the farm in 2019, the family faced a big decision: They could sell the dairy farm, become “gentleman farmers' and go non-commercial, or start manufacturing a product that brought in greater profit.
Before then, Pleasant Lane Farms had never produced cheese. The shift to artisan cheesemaking was strategic, as the Fryes wanted to fill Pittsburgh’s locally produced “artisan cheese desert” and add value to their operations.
The economics of the milk business had not kept up with inflation, but when Pleasant Lane Farms started making cheese, they got a fair price for their product, Frye explained.
“Now we're able to maintain our family and we have several full-time employees. We're able to bring back profit and provide jobs in our community,” he said.
The Fryes have been keeping an eye on cheese competitions since they started experimenting with cheesemaking. They even chose a “cheese consultant,” Neville McNaughton, president of Sanitary Design Industries, to help develop their production process.
McNaughton, who has worked with many award-winning cheesemakers and purveyors, helped Pleasant Lane Farms with plant design, sanitary design, process and recipes. When the Fryes made their first batch of cheese in April 2020, McNaughton even oversaw the process from a Zoom screen.
The farm started with a single 200-pound cheesemaking vat and has increased its equipment and capacity considerably since then.
“We're up probably 300-400% since the first year that we started making cheese,” Frye said.
Four years in, approximately half of the farm’s milk production goes toward cheesemaking.
“Pittsburgh has been supportive of our products,” Frye said, noting he is especially grateful for Giant Eagle.
“They took a chance on us before we won any awards almost three years ago.”
Pleasant Lane Farms also sells to Whole Foods and Fresh Thyme Market, as well as local restaurants like Downtown’s Eleven and The Eastwood Inn in Ligonier.
Cheese purveyors in states with more crowded markets, such as Wisconsin, often focus on a short list of products. That’s not the case here.
“We have a pretty broad product line here, which is a bit uncommon in the artisan cheese world,” Frye explained.
Pleasant Lane Farms’ product line is wide ranging, with each cheese’s taste depending on the aging process and ingredients.
They make quark overnight, and Frye suggests it as a substitute for cream cheese on a piece of sourdough bread. The blackjack, which Frye uses on burgers, ages for 28 days. The aged Gouda sits for about 14 months, giving the cheese a slight crunch due to the cheese crystals that form inside as time passes.
Pleasant Lane Farms uses competitions, like the American Cheese Society Conference, as an opportunity to gain feedback on their products.
The contest serves as a “benchmark” indicator in their industry, Frye said.
“It's not necessarily about winning or losing. It's like, what are the judges saying? What are the experts saying about your product? And that matters.”
Frye was especially proud that his sharp farmstead cheddar received a third-place medal in the cheddar category.
“Cheddar cheese is a big category at that competition and we’re placing up there with you know, Beecher’s and Cabot,” he said.
Those brands might be the “big cheese,” but Pleasant Lane Farms is certainly catching up.
Elena Eisenstadt: eeisenstadt@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.