Jimmy Costanzo knows a thing or two about fried fish.
Before he retired in 2006, he cooked thousands of filets for sandwiches and dinner, and not just on Fridays during the fish-crazy Lenten season, but seven days a week for patrons of Jimmy’s Post Tavern on Smithfield Street, Downtown, which he opened in 1978.
It didn’t take long after the Banksville native bought the 20-by-80-foot building in the shadows of One Oxford Centre to build a dedicated customer base. Lawyers, judges, clerks and other workers from the nearby City-County Building popped in for quick lunches, and the working man’s bar also drew a steady stream of steel mill workers, fireman, cops and people in the newspaper business who paid just 35 cents for a 12-ounce bottle of beer or 3 cents more for a one-ounce shot of liquor.
“They were the best customers,” Costanzo says of the reporters, printers, mailers and drivers who hung out there. “A big part of my success.”
While his ham-and-cheese sandwiches and fries were popular bites, it was his cod sandwich — also served at Jimmy’s Downtown Pizza across the street and at Up Above Jimmy’s on the second floor — that garnered “best of” awards. Costanzo sold up to 100 pounds of the lightly battered fish a day in three sizes, all expertly fried to golden perfection.
“We had close to 12 fryers going, and lines, during Lent,” he recalls with a chuckle.
In a 1990 story in the Pittsburgh Press on how to hook the best fish sandwiches in town, restaurant critic Betsy Kline proved a fan.
“You’ll need the jaws of a shark to wrap your lips around this [sandwich],” she opined, awarding it the Golden Hook Award “by a fin stroke” over 12 other eateries, including Benkovitz Seafoods, George Aiken’s, Original Oyster House and Wholey’s.

The Nashville Network handed out similar props in 2001, naming it Pittsburgh’s “best fish sammich” at a contest at PNC Park that aired in an episode on “Pop Across America” on August 24.
All well and good, but eventually, Costanzo — who always dreamed of being a cowboy, and took up roping at age 40 on the 250-acre farm in Hickory he owned at the time — hung up his apron and retired. “And I swore I’d never make another fish sandwich.”
Or so he thought.
Once a month for the last seven or so years, Costanzo, 72, “un-retires” by hosting a fish fry on the final Friday of every month at St. Anthony of Padua in Wickenburg, Az., where since 2012 he and his wife, Debbie, spend six months each year. (They spend spring and summer in Rennerdale.) Proceeds benefit the local Knights of Columbus.
When the couple joined the church around 2012, one of the first gatherings they attended was a K of C meeting in which members fretted about how they couldn’t get their fish dinners together fast enough for the community.
“I sat on my hands until I couldn’t stand it anymore,” Costanzo says with a laugh. “Then I jumped up, and said you guys are doing it all wrong!” To which one of the knights responded: “Son, no one will ever buy a fish sandwich in this town!”
After the meeting, he took members aside and explained that was because they were baking fish for sandwiches in small ovens, which take more than twice the time as fried.
“So I explained what I did,” and before he knew it, they were brainstorming on how to collaborate on a better fish experience.
One of the first steps was buying 2 small basket fryers on Amazon. A second was revealing the secret to a great fish sandwich, which he learned from his mother, Mary, years ago: Use TLC with everything you do in the kitchen.

“You have to take your time,” he says, by first washing the fish “real good” so there’s no fish smell, and then straining it to get out all the moisture. He also cuts the large filets into smaller pieces so they are easy to dip in an egg wash and breading before dropping it into the fryer.
He also continuously strains the batter so it’s nice and light and never with any lumps, “and we always use good, clean oil,” he says.
With Costanzo’s experienced hand and his mother’s recipe guiding them, the monthly dinners have exploded in popularity. Sometimes queues are so long, in fact, that customers have to wait nearly an hour in line to get their fish, which local restaurant owner Dave Qorri helps him purvey to the tune of 150 pounds per fry.

They recently added a third fryer for a total of nine baskets “and now we get about 300 people a month,” Costanzo notes with pride, adding that he couldn’t do it without assistance from around 20 dedicated volunteers, including Jack Zulik, a former cement plant supervisor from Michigan who bakes the buns, makes the coleslaw “and does whatever else needs done in the kitchen.”
Costanzo says what really makes their dinners unique is that, as is the case with Pittsburgh’s Lenten fish fries, everything from the bun to the coleslaw to the tartar and cocktail sauces are made by hand, usually with help from his wife of 49 years.
“Even our applesauce is made from scratch,” he says.
At this month’s fry on Feb. 24, diners will get a second, sweeter taste of Pittsburgh: 300 individually wrapped snickerdoodle, chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin and other cookies from Good L’Oven Cookie Shop in Ross.
The shop’s catering manager, Jim O’Connell, used to work with Costanzo, and when he told owner Deanna Soost about the fish fries, she thought it was “super cool” a Pittsburgh food tradition was being represented in the desert. Since she regularly ships her cookies around the country anyway, “I thought I should send him some,” she says, adding. “It’s just something good to do.”
Now that he’s retired, Costanzo admits he’s able to take a little more care with his fish than when he was running his restaurants back in the day on Smithfield St.
“I can take the time to make it perfect,” he says.
It’s also allowed him the time to become the cowboy he’s always dreamed of. In 2019, after roping three steers in 32.83 seconds with teammate Ray Lafromboise, he won a national team roping title at the NTR National Finals V at Rancho Rio in Wickenburg while riding his beloved red roan American quarter horse, Red Dog.
Raising money for a good cause while also feeding his fellow parishioners and others in the community a great meal is “very, very gratifying,” he says, because people are so appreciative.
“They have never tasted a good fish sandwich before,” he says.
Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on X @gtmckay.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.