Jeremiah Seltzer, 40, grew up on a 30-acre livestock farm in Mercer County. But unlike a lot of country kids raised near the water, he was never big on fishing, despite working as a fishing guide in Jackson Hole, Wyoming, after high school.
He did, however, harbor a dream of one day owning property with a creek running through it. Which explains, in part, how he and his wife, Meredith, came to start Mill Creek Trout Farm in the tiny borough of Utica 11 years ago. They sell fillets, whole trout and trout jerky at three Pittsburgh farmers markets.
In 2009, the couple boomeranged back home after more than a decade in Lancaster for his job with a farm machinery dealer. Searching the internet, they found a 15-acre property not far from where both of them had grown up. On the market for years, it boasted a freshwater spring and a sizeable stretch of Mill Creek, an 11-mile tributary of French Creek, meandering smack through it. They bought it.
Strewn with garbage and seven garages in serious disrepair, the property would take some serious work to bring it back to life. The couple spent their entire first year there tearing down buildings and scraping bits of glass and other debris from the topsoil.
One fall day while cleaning up the property, they discovered a small hole fed by the farm’s coldwater spring. Ten or so native trout were swimming around in the water.
“So we dug it out a little so they could winter over,” Seltzer recalls.
The following spring, they made the hole a little bigger and added more trout purchased from Laurel Hill Trout Farm. They dug it out again to accommodate even more fish, and before long the spring-fed pond was a favorite fishing spot for family members and friends.
“I enjoyed the science,” he says.

Raising trout might have remained just a hobby had Seltzer’s mother, Terry, not suggested that maybe he should be selling trout along with the meat he helped her sell at local farmers markets.
“And so I started the whole glorious road of [figuring out] the health regulations,” Seltzer says with a laugh.
Not sure whether there was an appetite for fresh trout, he started slow in 2012 with just two markets: Farmers at Phipps and North Side (Citiparks) Farmers Market. Finding an eager audience, he started selling in 2013 at the Squirrel Hill Sunday market. Stands in Sewickley and Bloomfield on Saturdays eventually followed.
The farm has grown along with his customer base: Seltzer today is raising tens of thousands of brook, rainbow and golden rainbow trout each year in six natural spring-fed ponds and a hilltop nursery.
When Mill Creek started, “we thought 50 pounds of fish a week was a lot,” he says. “Now, we’re doing 50 pounds a day.”
The largest fish can weigh as much as 30 pounds, and some of his broodstock — the mature fish used for breeding — are bigger still.
“We have some trout that would break the world record at 45 pounds in the wild,” he says.
That’s big enough to put your hand inside its mouth.
From roe to fillet
Raising healthy trout via aquaculture is a labor-intensive pursuit, especially when you do it while also holding down a full-time job. It becomes even more difficult when the fish are grown to organic standards, without antibiotics or steroids.
“It’s been a real learning curve,” says Meredith, who grew up a “city girl” in Greenville. “I had no idea what I was getting into!”

Her husband, who became maintenance supervisor for Sandy Lake borough in 2020, gets up each day at 4 a.m. to begin catching the day’s trout with an 8-foot cast net. After tossing the bright-green net hard and flat into the water, he allows it to fan out and sink to the bottom of the pond. Then, he gives it gentle little tugs to close up the weighted end and pull the fish in.
Trout skin, he explains, has a membrane layer that protects them from infections and bacteria. The cast net can rub that slime off and make the fish susceptible to an infection, “which is why we don’t return any fish to the pond once we remove them.”
Most anglers allow fish to slowly suffocate in the air before gutting and filleting them — a stressful death that causes adrenaline and lactic acid to show up in their bodies, and can make fish taste bad and smell “fishy.” Seltzer butchers his trout quickly and humanely with a precise blow to the head that instantly separates the spinal cord from the base of the skull.
Every fish is in ice water and gutted within 10 minutes of being caught, after which it is filleted by hand or cut into strips for jerky, vacuum-packed and frozen for market.
Feeding comes after work, when buckets of fathead minnows, silver shiners and native crayfish Seltzer grows in a two-acre pond are thrown into the water. The fish also dine on handfuls of krill-based pellet feed specially blended by Optimal Fish Food in Nebraska.

Mill Creek’s broodstock start spawning in the fall, with a single female laying between 20,000 and 30,000 eggs. After being harvested, the bright-yellow eggs are laid on trays to hatch in a nursery. Once or twice a day, Seltzer checks their progress and immediately — and painstakingly — removes any with white or fuzzy spots with a turkey baster. It takes about a year for baby trout to reach 6-8 inches, after which they grow an inch a month so long as they’re healthy.
If trout consume 1 pound of food, they’ll gain a pound of weight, Seltzer says. But they’re not really big enough to eat until about year 3, and it takes a least five years to get a hearty 1-pound fillet.
Trout need at least 47% protein in their diet, he explains, and you also have to carefully watch to see how they’re eating; if they’re not jumping to the surface and striking within seconds of food landing on the water, something’s wrong.
To thrive, trout also need fresh, clean water. At Mill Creek, each spring flows at least 250 gallons of water per minute and stays at a frigid temperature of around 62 degrees year-round. A Venturi system keeps the dissolved oxygen level at 14 ppm on three of the ponds while a fourth on a hillside gets similar results with waterfalls and rock formations. A floating Casko aerator on each pond provides backup.
“It keeps them more energetic and healthy and as strong as can be,” says Seltzer.
Each pond is drained and cleaned every three years (the fish are rotated) and Seltzer tests the water every day for nitrates, metals and other contaminants caused by rain. Being near farmland, pesticides and insecticides in runoff is always a concern.
Trout will often jump into an outflow pipe “just to travel,” he says. They also will eat anything half their size, so the fish are grouped by age, with the tiniest in the screen-covered nursery.
Their only natural predator are birds — herons and eagles, in particular, love to snack on them. “But trout are very sight-oriented,” says Seltzer, and know to hang out at the bottom when they see them coming.
It’s not fishy — really!

Trout has reputation for being one of your fishier species, but that’s because most people are eating fish that have been poorly raised or improperly handled, Seltzer says.
You might think that beautiful rainbow you hooked in your favorite fishing spot is wild, he says, but it probably is a stocked fish grown on the cheapest food possible and then released into water it can’t survive in. “And that’s not good.”
Or maybe you threw it onto the river bank while you continued fishing, or let it slowly suffocate in a bucket of warm water. Of course it will taste fishy — it’s spoiled!
Mill Creek hopes to change those perceptions with its fresh, bone-free fillets, which you can buy either plain ($25 per pound) or smoked over apple and cherry wood ($35/pound) at the Sewickley, Bloomfield and Squirrel Hill farmers markets.
Using skills he learned during arctic training with the military in Alaska, Seltzer also offers a labor-intensive but still affordable trout jerky ($10/package). He brines strips of fillet for four hours, then smokes them until they reach 160 degrees.
Cooked with care, trout actually has a fairly mild flavor and delicate texture that even young customers will enjoy — all three of their kids eat it several times a week, Meredith says, and their two oldest, 7-year-old Judah and 5-year-old Jax, love to help catch it.
One of the family’s favorite ways to prepare trout is sauteed in a pan with a caramelized mixture of browned butter, honey, garlic and orange juice. It also can be grilled, baked, fried or broiled with any number of seasonings, marinades or toppings.
Like so many small businesses, Mill Creek experienced substantial losses during the pandemic. The fish still had to be fed and cared for, even though they had nowhere to sell them. Restaurants sales, which accounted for 40% of business pre-COVID, fell off completely. Mail order wasn’t an option because the shipping costs were more than the fish, which is already expensive.
Once they reopened, the Squirrel Hill and Bloomfield markets were instrumental in helping the farm bounce back to where they now sell some 200 pounds of fillets, 50 pounds of smoked fillet and 20 pounds of jerky a week during the summer months.
“If people try it, they’ll love it,” says Seltzer.
Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay.
Pan-roasted Trout in Browned Butter

PG tested
This is the one of the Seltzer family’s favorite ways to prepare trout — even 3-year-old Hallie loves it. The dish comes together quickly, so Jeremiah recommends having all your ingredients ready to go before heating the pan. Using orange juice instead of lemon juice will result in a sweeter dish.
2 pounds trout fillet
Salt and pepper
¼ cup butter
¼ cup fresh minced garlic
¼ cup honey
¼ cup fresh lemon or orange juice
Pat trout fillets dry with a paper towel, then season with salt and pepper.
Heat a thick-bottomed skillet on medium heat. Melt butter over medium heat, swirling butter in the pan or stirring occasionally to make sure it cooks evenly. As butter melts, it will begin to foam. Keep a close eye — the color will go from a bright yellow to a golden tan, then quickly to a deep golden brown.
When the butter has a nutty aroma, is deep golden brown and browned milk solids appear in the bottom of the pan, add garlic, honey and lemon or orange juice. Cook for 3-4 minutes over medium heat, until everything is caramelized.
Add fish fillets meat-side down. Cook, constantly basting with the browned butter, for 5 minutes, then flip the fillets over. Continue cooking for another 2 minutes, until it’s cooked through and flakey in the thickest part. Serve immediately.
For crispy skin, place cooked fillets on a baking sheet, cover with the pan sauce, and stick under the broiler for 2 minutes or until the skin is crispy and golden brown.
Serves 4-6.
— Jeremiah Seltzer, Mill Creek Trout Farm







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.