The Mancini family has been baking its Italian twist bread in the West Park neighborhood of McKees Rocks for nearly 100 years. But the face of the operation for many Pittsburghers, says Nick Mancini Hartner, is its satellite operation in the Strip District.

Even on a quiet weekday, customers stream in one after the other in search of the bakery’s iconic loaves and signature pepperoni rolls, all made fresh daily using no preservatives or additives. It can be absolutely crazy on weekends, when the smell of freshly baked bread can’t help but lure the throng of shoppers on Penn Avenue inside for a loaf or two.

The tiny bakery under the dark green awning next door to Wholey’s is also the company test kitchen, because that’s where the third-generation bread baker and company co-owner has created (and continues to create) much of its expanding line of bread products — everything from marble rye and multi-grain to cranberry walnut, wheat and paska (which they sell year-round) along with several varieties of dinner rolls.

“When we do things here, we get 100% feedback,” Hartner, 44, says with a laugh. “Customers react.”

Advertise with us
Pepperoni rolls are a best-seller at Mancini's in the Strip District, with the bakery selling between 1,000 to 2,000 rolls a week.(Gretchen McKay/Post-Gazette)

Unlike at the McKees Rocks facility, where baking occurs around the clock to produce some 10,000 loaves a day, there are no strict time deadlines at the 1,400-square-foot Strip location. Even though space is tight, “Down here, we get to play with things,” says Hartner.

A good example is the bakery’s best-selling pepperoni rolls.

When Hartner was first learning his craft by shadowing journeymen bakers on the night shift in McKees Rocks, they would often make him a larger version of the pepperoni- and cheese-stuffed rolls for lunch as a thank you, “and it was the best thing,” he says. Yet when he asked why Mancini’s wasn’t selling what was sure to be a hit with customers, the Franklin Park resident always got the same answer: All that portioning, stuffing, rolling and proofing was too much work!

But in the Strip? “We had the downtime” in the beginning because business was slow, Hartner says, and he had to make more products to build a brand since he “didn’t have the luxury of being in a place for 75 years.”

Today, with the process boiled down to a science, Hartner and his employees are able to make and sell upwards of 2,000 fresh and frozen pepperoni rolls a week in the Strip, depending on the season. And surprise, surprise: They now also are available (and extremely popular) at the McKees Rocks location.

Advertise with us
Nick Mancini Hartner is a third-generation owner of Mancini's Bakery, which got its start in McKees Rocks in 1926.(Gretchen McKay/Post-Gazette)

All in the family

November had yet to be proclaimed National Bread Month by Congress to celebrate the power of grains when James Mancini immigrated with his parents to Pittsburgh from Abruzzo, Italy, in 1910. But bread was certainly an important staple, and Jimmy, as he was known, was determined to learn how to make it. After apprenticing himself to a baker as a teenager, he started his one-room bakery in 1926 at age 20.

To give his breads their distinctive Old World taste, Mancini baked in a continually heated, gas-fired oven that was eventually lined with refractory brick similar to that used in crematoriums to withstand high heat. (Loaves are baked at 400 degrees.) His twist bread, made by flipping a yard-long strand of dough over and under and then tucking the ends under, soon became his trademark. It became a family business when his youngest brother Ernest joined him after World War II, and the pair operated the bakery as a partnership until Jimmy died of metastatic lung cancer in 1970. Ernest retired a year later.

Ernest’s daughter and Hartner’s mother, Mary, took over the bakery in 1977, after her younger brother (and heir apparent) Frankie was killed in a motorcycle accident. Nick Hartner became a co-owner in 2003, shortly after opening the bakery on Penn Avenue, which he originally called the McKees Rocks Bread Co., with his younger brother Ernie and cousin Reed, both of whom have since left to pursue other interests. It was rechristened Mancini’s in 2006 with an original sign from McKees Rocks.

Though bread was always his destiny, it took Hartner a hot minute to actually figure that out. He had studied biomedical engineering at Marquette University, after all, with dreams of a career in prosthetics. Yet when he couldn’t immediately find a job after returning home in 2000, his mother asked him to consider working at the bakery for a year to see if he might be interested in taking over one day.

Advertise with us

“And surprise, I fell in love with it,” he says.

Fresh loaves cool at the Strip District Mancini’s.(Gretchen McKay/Post-Gazette)

Twenty-two years later, with a few classes at the San Francisco Baking Institute also under his flour-dusted apron, he still has fun every day on the job, whether he’s sitting in front of a computer in his McKees Rocks office evaluating production, writing the recipe for his next artisan bread, or is wrist-deep in dough in the Strip District bakery while most of us are still sound asleep and dreaming.

Mancini’s is the last remaining bakery that delivers seven days a week in the Pittsburgh area, so work is often a juggling act, Hartner says. He typically bakes for a few hours in the Strip before heading to McKees Rocks and, regardless of location, there’s always something to do or a new problem to solve.  During the pandemic, for instance, he had to make the tough decision to slightly raise prices when the cost of eggs for their sliced Italian shot up 140% and the 50,000 pounds of milled flour the bakery trucks in every week to McKees Rocks cost 60% more. “I have to roll with it.”

Most of Mancini’s business is wholesale to restaurants and grocery stores, but whether you’re buying it at one of their two stores or enjoying it at your favorite Italian eatery, the process is the same. It takes almost five hours to make a loaf of Mancini bread using the original recipe, because you have to let it ferment to get the right flavor.

The bakery’s pepperoni rolls take longer still because they need to raise three times. Each 8-by-4-inch rectangle of dough gets exactly 21 slices of Hormel pepperoni along with a handful of shredded mozzarella and provolone cheeses and a sprinkle of Mancini’s proprietary seasoning.  And the three shallow cuts made on top of the rolls have to be at a specific angle to optimize “oven spring.”

Advertise with us

Care is also taken to roll and seal the ends closed with a karate chop, “so you get pepperoni with the first bite,” says Hartner. Italian red sauce — made by Dei Fratelli in Johnstown under the Mancini’s label — comes on the side to keep the rolls crispy.

While the bakery is only 15-feet wide, it’s bigger than you think because it stretches 100 feet deep to Mulberry Way. Its two ovens pump out around 6,000 bakery items using 4-5,000 pounds of flour a week.

Always looking for ways to improve the customer experience, Mancini’s this month will supplement their iconic white paper bread bags — in short supply during the pandemic —  with micro-perforated polypropylene bags. The thousands of tiny pin-sized holes allow moisture and air to flow, Hartner says, keeping the crust crusty while also keeping bread fresher longer.

Unlike other bakeries that trot out seasonal offerings for holidays like Thanksgiving, Mancini’s offers the same roster of products — including regular and its newish jalapeño cheese croutons for stuffing — every day of the year.

“We just make a lot more of it,”Hartner says.

Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay or IG @pittsburghpgfood.