There is just a scattering of independent butchers in Pittsburgh who break down whole animals raised on local farms. What was common practice a half-century ago is now a hard-to-find retail trade, so it’s welcome news that Fat Butcher is opening in Lawrenceville on Nov. 12 with a refrigerated case stocked with locally raised cows, hogs, lamb and chickens, all hand-cut in the Butler Street shop.
“When you work with a whole animals, if you know what you’re doing as far as butchering goes, you give yourself a lot of options to do what you want and offer something special to your customers,” says owner and head butcher Steve Dawson.
Dawson is a Westmoreland County native and trained geologist who left the region in 2000 to work in California’s oil and gas industry. His work in environmental remediation took him to northern Virginia, Montreal and Madison, Wisconsin, which is where he picked up the craft at Underground Butcher, a shop with an emphasis on whole animal, pasture-raised meat, in 2014.
“I really liked the balance of the mix of work and technique at the butcher shop. It was something I was really drawn to,” he says.

Although Dawson is opening in a newly constructed building, he’s reviving a tradition of butchery on the 5100 block of Butler Street, which previously was home to Ferlan and Son (1950-1985) and Foster’s Meats (1985-2012) and, later, Butcher on Butler, which closed in 2017.
A big draw at Fat Butcher is that Dawson is dry-aging his beef, a time-intensive method that concentrates flavor as it naturally tenderizes the texture of the cow. (It also results in a significant loss of water weight, which is part of the reason dry-aged beef is more expensive than wet-aged beef.)
Dawson is planning on getting in half a side of beef per week to begin with, but he expects that’ll ramp up to at least one whole cow per week in the future. The first steer, delivered earlier this week, came from Pasture Perfect Beef in Grove City and the next one, a grass-finished cow (not finished, as is typical, with corn and silage), will come from Rolling Hills Heritage Farm in Worthington.

He’s working with Brad Thoma, a fourth-generation butcher at Thoma Meats in Saxonburg, for processing, as well as for sourcing some of the hogs and lamb he’ll use in the shop. Dawson also plans to bring in 100% pasture-raised hogs from Fallen Aspen Farm in Volant, Birch Creek Farmery in Burgettstown (who also will supply Icelandic lamb) and Wildom Farm in McHenry, Maryland. The chickens come from Spur Hollow Farm in Grove City.
“In addition to what’s in the case, you can definitely call up and get what you want butchered for you. Custom cuts, custom sausages, custom ground beef blends. We’re here for that,” Dawson says.
Working with whole animals, especially cows and pigs, is a hurdle for a butcher shop owner because there’s a lot on the animal that isn’t considered a prime or popular cut. Every cow, for example, has hundreds of pounds of bones, fat and trim that need to be turned into something else, such as ground beef, sausage, stock, suet and even dog food.

“One of the reasons people don’t open whole-animal butchery shops is that it’s hard to figure out what to do with all the stuff that doesn’t sell well in the case. So, most butcher shops end up buying primals and boxed meat, which isn’t much different than what you’d get at Giant Eagle or Costco,” Dawson says. “And then you’re trying to compete on price, which is something you’re not going to win.”
And while Dawson hopes to keep prices fairly competitive (brisket, for example, is $9 per pound and Denver steaks go for $12 per pound at opening), especially considering the quality of the farms he’s working with, he knows he’s going to have to do more than that to stay in business.
To that end, he hired Jesse Barlass, formerly of Colonia at Smallman Galley and Bodega Off Butler, as Fat Butcher’s chef. He’ll prepare sandwiches, such as meatloaf with white barbecue sauce and pepper jack, porchetta, a sausage-of-the-week (the first one is longaniza) and a double-stacked smashburger.
In addition to the hot items, Fat Butcher has products such as house-made sausages, pastrami, corned beef and bacon, stocks and tallow for sale. There are a few shelf-stable meat-adjacent products such as barbecue sauces, charcoal and salt at the shop, too.
Dawson started working in restaurants during his second go-round in Madison, which is when he quit his day job and began working his way up the ladder under the wing of James Beard Award-winning chef Tory Miller, who had four restaurants in the city.
“I just jumped in with him and over the course of the next few years worked just about every station he had,” Dawson says.
He first worked with whole animals while at Miller’s restaurant Graze, where he learned how to make, among other things, sausages with the trim of the meat. On his day off, he volunteered at Underground Butcher to learn how to break down whole sides of beef.
Later, he took a full-time job at Underground Butcher. He eventually became the shop’s head butcher and ran the operation until it closed in 2019. After that, he made sausages for a Madison brewery, but got laid off once the coronavirus pandemic hit. He’d also torn his meniscus and needed knee surgery. So when his wife landed a job at the University of Pittsburgh, they decided it was time to move.

“The whole time, I was looking at places to open a butcher shop,” he says.
Dawson found the right spot on Butler Street, and it took a little more than a year from the architectural drawings to the full build-out to be completed.
It’s a promising opening, but not one without obstacles. In addition to Butcher on Butler, new-open butcher shops including Heritage Craft Butchers, DJ’s Butcher Block and the meat counter at Marty’s Market all had relatively brief runs in the past decade. Dawson believes that his experience, and the possibility that Pittsburghers are more open to trying non-traditional cuts of meat, is going to help him have a business that operates longer.
“I think our biggest hurdle at first is going to be educating customers. That’s what we learned in Madison and as I talked to other butcher shops as I was looking to open this place. How do you sell the lesser-known but very tasty cuts such as Denver steaks, bavettes (flap steak), sirloin tips and things like that? Especially when they’re at a higher price point than you’d find in the grocery store,” Dawson says. “That education is going to be a challenge. It’s one I think we are ready to handle.”
Fat Butcher: 5151 Butler St., Lawrenceville; fatbutcher.com
Hal B. Klein: hklein@post-gazette.com, Twitter @halbklein and IG @halbklein.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.