Ed Stalewski pulled the sizzling pie from the 475-degree gas oven, then extracted it from an iron pan with the precision of a surgeon. As if on cue, James Brown's “I Got the Feelin’” came on the kitchen radio at Mercurio’s in Aspinwall and that unmistakable howl of “Baby! Baby! Baby!” appropriately heralded this piping-hot pizza into the world.

He took it to a counter, hunched over it, and dressed it with bright green stripes of basil pesto sauce, followed by a golden mixture of garlic and Corto olive oil. He then decorated it with hand-ripped chunks of fresh, white mozzarella and lobes of red peppadews.

“I like a lot of colors,” he said.

That complemented the homemade giardiniera, tomato sauce and Calabrian pepper sausage, and his signature “roses” — 14 pieces of pepperoni fashioned into a flower with the aid of a medicine cup.

Advertise with us
Stalweski’s Detroit tavern-style pizza is named for his late mother, Rose Bar­toni Stalew­ski. (Steve Mellon / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

And the winner is: Rosie’s Tavern Pizza

Mr. Stalewski, a demand planning specialist for PPG, is a home cook turned semi-pro pizza maker. In late March, he was lauded at the International Pizza Expo in Las Vegas, one of the biggest trade shows and competitions in the pizza industry worldwide.

His creation, Rosie’s Tavern Pizza, was named best non-traditional pizza for the northeast region. It’s a hybrid of a tavern pizza (a round pie with a very thin, super crispy crust) and a Detroit-style with charred, cheesy frico edges.

“Him winning is like the Americans beating the Russians in 1980,” said Joey Mercurio, referring to the legendary “Miracle on Ice” game at the Lake Placid Olympics. He is the co-owner of Mercurio’s, the family-run pizza and gelato shop with locations in Shadyside and Aspinwall where Stalewski moonlights two nights a week. (Stalewski’s high school-aged daughter Lily Rose also works there.)

Although his winning pizza is not a regular menu item, the restaurant serves Neapolitan-style pizzas.

Advertise with us

“Ed is one of the best people I know in the entire world,” Mr. Mercurio added.

Stalewski grew up in Masontown, Fayette County. (Steve Mellon / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

A rectangular reckoning

The 53-year-old Mr. Stalewski grew up in Masontown, Fayette County, and lived off of Dolfi’s pan-fried Sicilian pizza.

“It was rectangular with diagonal [sauce] stripes. They used DiCarlo’s pizza shells and a blend of provolone and mozzarella,” he said. “That was the pizza that I grew up on. I didn't even know pizza was round until Pizza Hut came to town. It was just good, wholesome pizza.”

A lifelong pizza enthusiast, it was a trip to Ross Park Mall in 2013 that changed his life.

Advertise with us

“My supervisor at the time bought me a gift card to Crate and Barrel. And so we're looking around this place. I happen to like zero in on this end cap display. And I'm seeing pizza peels, and all these pizza cutters. And there's some pans — of course it drew my attention. It's pizza, right?

“And then I see this book on the shelf. And there, lo and behold, was “The Pizza Bible” by Tony Gemignani. I take it home and I start reading it from front to back. What really drew me in on the book was the way that Tony Gemignani finishes pizzas, the way he decorates them almost like a painting. I just got taken by that, so I just started making every single recipe in the entire book.”

The more he dove into it, he said, the more he learned about “this whole pizza society out there that I had no idea even existed.”

A basil pesto finishes the Rosie’s Tavern Pizza. (Steve Mellon / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

School of Za

He cooked pizzas nonstop. He read. He studied. He befriended pizza makers. He followed them and corresponded with them on social media. He built a following of more than 11,000 on Instagram. He took a part-time job at a now-closed Il Pizzaiolo in the North Hills, learning what he could there and, starting in 2019, at Mercurio’s.

Advertise with us

Of Mr. Stalewski, Pittsburgh-based pizza journalist Dan Talarico wrote: “He was able to build a community online and soak in the knowledge of pizza experts around the world like a fermented Sicilian dough ball fermenting in a pan covered in oil.”

He entered Pizza Expo last year and, no pun intended, got a taste of the competition. This year, after developing his recipe, he spent weeks on end practicing at Pete Tolman’s Iron Born Pizza.

“It’s like I was in training camp,” he said.

This year’s Pizza Expo was a Who’s Who of Pittsburgh pizzaiolos either competing or attending. In addition to the Mercurio family, it included highly decorated past world champion Eric Von Hanson of Caliente; Mr. Tolman, who is also a past world champion; Rico Lunardi of Slice on Broadway; Ryan Smith of Benny Fierro’s; and Sean Jefairjian of A Slice of New York.

But Mr. Stalewski was the one who went home with the hardware.

Advertise with us

His pizza was thoughtfully constructed and perfectly balanced. Texturally interesting, no one ingredient overpowered the others — the sweet, bright, piquant and savory notes complemented each other — and they came on a crust that positively crackled and detonated like a live wire.

His inspiration was his deceased mother, Rose Bartoni Stalewski, for whom the pizza is named.

“My mom, she always wanted to see smiles on people's faces, whatever she was making, and I feel I do the same thing. I want to see people excited and smiles on their faces whenever they get the pizza from me,” he said.

“She never cut corners, either. She put every amount of effort into what she was doing. That's the way I approach making pizzas. I want to touch people's lives with what I do.”