Kirsten Peffer and Joanie Sinz formed what they call an “instantaneous” connection after meeting through a mutual friend. They have been baking together ever since.

The two Harmony residents both love to laugh and grew up baking with their mothers and grandmothers — Mrs. Peffer with her German oma and Mrs. Sinz with her Hungarian mother and grandmother. They got together on weekends to bake cookies, pastries, breads and other goodies to give away to friends.

The best friends baked so much, and so well, it soon became a running joke that they could start a bakery. About seven years ago, they thought “why not?” and got Mrs. Peffer’s kitchen certified. The Two Fraus Bakery was born.

Working from home allowed the women to keep their day jobs while testing the entrepreneurial waters. Their husbands also signed on, pitching in on weekends to make what’s become one of the bakery’s most popular items: at least seven flavors of fresh-baked Bavarian pretzels. They’re only available on Saturdays and always sell out.

Advertise with us

Depending on the day or season, customers can also find everything from sourdough bread to cinnamon rolls to pizza hand pies or soft molasses cookies.

When the coffee shop Wunderbar expanded its operations in 2016 and offered the women its storefront on Mercer Street in Historic Harmony, “we jumped right in,” says Mrs. Sinz.

Today, Two Fraus has such a dedicated following for its all-natural, scratch offerings that it routinely sells out before closing time. It’s also one of the most popular stops on Butler County’s new Sweet Tooth Trail. Launched in April, the self-guided tour features local bakeries, ice cream shops and candy stores that give the region its unique flavor.

“Butler County is filled with so many wonderful shops,” says Tiffany Hernandez of Butler County Tourism.

As many struggled during the pandemic, the tour has given residents and visitors “something to do on their own time, in a safe environment,” while exploring the area and helping local businesses bounce back.

Advertise with us

“It benefits everyone,” Ms. Hernandez says.

Here’s how it works: Tour-goers pick up a paper “passport” at any of the 18 vendors on the trail or the tourism office in Zelienople, then stop at their leisure at each location to get the card stamped. Once complete, the passport can be turned in for an apothecary jar filled with nostalgic candy and a special gift certificate to use at participating shops.

To date, nearly 80 people have completed the entire trail, with hundreds more making multiple stops. Many learn of the tour by word of mouth or through social media.

Vicki and Susan Craig of San Antonio, Texas, saw the tour in a travel guide and were so charmed that they visited during a trip to Pittsburgh in July. They hit all 18 spots in just three days, between trips to the Kinzua bridge and dam and Niagara Falls.

The mother-daughter duo always seek out “off-the-beaten-trail” activities or places during their travels, Vicki Craig wrote in an email. The Sweet Tooth Trail not only allowed them to get to know the area better, but helped them “fill up on amazing sweets.”  They say the peach danish from P&B’s Sweets and Eats in Evans City and the blackberry scones from Mainstreet Bake Shop in Saxonburg especially stood out.

Advertise with us

Ms. Hernandez would love to see the trail grow a little, but wants to keep it manageable so people aren’t overwhelmed by too many stops. That hasn’t been an issue so far. One “very aggressive” couple from Ohio recently completed the tour in 24 hours, she says.

Speckled Hen Chocolate Co. in Saxonburg, which produces handmade gourmet chocolates, is among the original stops. Owner Valerie Cannon says the trail has brought in both new and repeat customers.

“They know how to get boots on the ground,” she says of the tourist bureau.

Like many retailers, Ms. Cannon says the pandemic forced her to innovate. Speckled Hen began offering premade baskets for pickup and novelty COVID-related gifts like chocolate toilet paper rolls. These days, a chocolate vaccination card made with edible paper is a hot seller, and chocolate-covered Chambersburg peaches were a winner during that season.

All the candy is made with a proprietary blend of seven chocolates for a signature taste.

Advertise with us

“We want it to be unmistakable,” says Ms. Cannon, who became a chocolatier in 2013 after a career in Oregon in quality control.

The shop also is famous for its chocolate raspberry towers and 21 flavors of fudge.

“We did anything we could to reach out and let people know we were still out there,” she says.

Baldinger’s, an old-school candy store in Zelienople, is the oldest business on the tour. It’s been around since 1933 and is famous for its scoop-yourself bulk candies and old-fashioned novelty candy such as Goo Goo Clusters, Turkish Taffy and Bun Bars. Manager Jean Zajacs says Sweet Tooth Trail-goers also are crazy about its triple-dipped malted milk balls.

“If we run out, people start twitching,” she says.

Advertise with us

The landmark store also boasts more than 300 cookie cutters and lots of candy-making supplies.

Some candy has been hard to get during the pandemic, but customers have been incredibly loyal, even when COVID-restrictions meant Mrs. Zajacs had to do their scooping for them or a favorite item was out of stock.  “It’s been a real adventure.”

Customers at Two Fraus also never know what they’re going to find on any particular day, but that’s entirely by design. They “frau up” old recipes and come up with new ones based on availability of ingredients or how they feel that day.

“We get bored really quickly so it’s never just the same old cookies,” says Mrs. Peffer.

“It’s always a surprise,” agrees Mrs. Sinz.

Advertise with us

Passports to Butler County’s Sweet Tooth Trail are available at all 18 participating locations as well as at the tourism bureau, 310 E. Grandview Ave., Zelienople, or on the bureau’s 35 brochure racks throughout the county. For more information, go to www.visitbutlercounty.com/SweetToothTrail or call 724-234-4619.

Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter/IG @gtmckay and @pgrecipes.