It’s inexpensive. It’s a ubiquitous takeout. It’s a weeknight dinner savior. And, by golly, it is insanely aromatic, delicious and comforting.

We are talking about the precooked rotisserie chicken sold at supermarkets. Crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside, it’s perfect to feed a hungry brood. No mental strain or fussy attention is required. Once the bird is on a platter and carved, dinner is ready.

In Allegheny County, seven supermarket chains with deli counters/hot foods sell original-flavored chickens under 4½ pounds. We decided to rank them.

Chickens from specialty grocery stores were not included for this taste test. Nor were the budget-friendly big birds from wholesale stores like Sam’s Club and Costco, which require a membership.

Advertise with us

All the stores we visited offered piping hot, freshly roasted chicken in plastic containers or bags, and the temperature held up well even during long car rides. Appearance, flavor, amount of meat and how the birds stood on their own without accompaniments were considered in determining which rotisserie chicken ruled the roost.

Here’s how the grocers’ chickens ranked:

1) Fresh Market, Mt. Lebanon

Stats: $7.99 for 1 pound, 10 ounces. $5 on Thursdays.

Calories: 980.

Advertise with us

Ingredients: Vinegar, sea salt and sugar.

Other flavors: White wine and herb, lemon-rosemary and butter-garlic.

Available: Placed in the hot case every four hours starting at 8:30 a.m.

Verdict: It didn’t sit out on a hot stand but was taken from a hot case when ordered. The legs and wings were neatly held close to the breast with a twine, making it a contender for a beauty contest. The skin was crispy, and the meat was unbelievably moist, even though the chicken was packed without any drippings. Every part of the bird was cooked through just right. The flavor was real and the seasoning spot on.

2) Walmart, Frazer

Advertise with us

Stats: $4.50 for 1 pound, 13 ounces.

Calories: 140.

Ingredients: Lemon juice, salt, black pepper, garlic powder, onion powder and dehydrated onion.

Other flavors: Lemon-pepper and butter-garlic.

Available: Put out four times a day with the first batch at 10:30 a.m. and the last one at 3 p.m.

Advertise with us

Verdict: Brown with charred spots, this broad-breasted chicken had skimpy legs. But appearance isn’t everything. When sliced, a tantalizing aroma of garlic and onion enveloped the bird, which was a lot juicier than it let on. Underneath the crackling skin was deliciously seasoned meat that was uniformly tender in both the legs and breast. It was excellent, just excellent.

3) Giant Eagle Market District, near Aspinwall

Stats: $6.99 for 2 pounds.

Calories: 170.

Ingredients: Salt, sodium phosphate, seasoning, sugar, salt, oil of lemon and oil of orange.

Advertise with us

Other flavors: None.

Available: Cooked six times a day and put out from 11 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.

Verdict: Twine that went under the deep golden brown bird and around the wings was there for a reason. The meat just fell apart when it was carved. It was so moist that two forks could have done the trick. Then there was the delicious crisp skin. You could almost buy it just for that. The disappointment came with the breast meat — there was not much of it. More meat, with the delightful citrus seasoning, could have earned the bird the No. 2 spot.

4) Fresh Thyme Market, Collier

Stats: $6.99 for 1 pound, 12 ounces.

Advertise with us

Calories: Not available.

Ingredients: Garlic pepper, dehydrated garlic, salt and black pepper.

Other flavors: Naked (no seasoning), lemon-pepper, barbecue and Cajun.

Available: Put out four times a day, starting at 10 a.m.

Verdict: This bird, with a glistening and beautiful brown skin, was a looker. The legs were pointed at the right angle, the breast was nicely puffed out, and as a whole, the chicken looked wonderfully appetizing. (The Illinois-based chain uses cage-free birds that are devoid of antibiotics.) The meat looked super juicy, and the thighs and wings were succulent. But the breast was a letdown. It was drier and underseasoned.

Advertise with us

5) Whole Foods, Upper St. Clair

Stats: $7.99 for conventional; $9.99 for organic. Both weighed 1 pound, 12 ounces.

Calories: 230 for conventional; 200 for organic.

Ingredients: None listed.

Other flavors: Herb, lemon-pepper and garlic herb.

Advertise with us

Available: Cooked twice and put out at 10 a.m. and 5 p.m.

Verdict: If chickens were judged just on their beautiful, crisp brown skin, both the organic and conventional birds were winners. But that uniformity didn’t extend to the texture of the meat in both versions of the plain rotisserie chicken. While the organic meat was juicy, the conventional one was dry. Tastewise, they lived up to their name. They were plain, to the point of tasting bland and flavorless. They needed a sprinkling of salt or something.

6) Shop ’n Save, Penn Hills

Stats: $6.99 for 4 pounds.

Calories: Not available.

Advertise with us

Ingredients: Salt, dehydrated onion, paprika, chili pepper, dehydrated garlic and red pepper.

Other flavors: Lemon-pepper, Cajun, barbecue and bruschetta (Italian seasoning).

Available: Put out at 10 a.m. and 3 p.m.

Verdict: It had the elements of a decent rotisserie chicken, and the beguiling aroma held up all the way home. When carved, the legs came off easily, and so did the wings. The lightly browned bird had a good-sized breast and legs that were symmetrical. However, the breast was dry, the legs were chewy, and the seasoning was not uniform.

7) Kuhn’s, Banksville

Advertise with us

Stats: $6.49 for 2 pounds, 8 ounces.

Calories: Not available.

Ingredients: Salt, paprika, onion powder and garlic powder.

Flavors: Cajun, lemon-pepper and garlic.

Available: Put out three to four times, with the first at 8 a.m. and last at 5:30 p.m.

Advertise with us

Verdict: The bird had a lovely golden tan, but the meat was another story. The legs and thighs were dry, and the breast was drier. All that schmaltz at the bottom of the plastic container didn’t help in tenderizing the bird one bit. In fact, it tasted more like second-day meat that had been reheated. The onion-garlic seasoning was lively, but it could not camouflage the texture.

_______________

What’s your take?