Cheryl Johnson has always been a rock for people caught in hard places.

The middle child of five and University of Pittsburgh grad spent her entire career as a social worker, working with Allegheny Family Network and the office of Children, Youth and Families to protect children and support families caught up in the Allegheny County court system.

On the side, she ran a successful catering business. So when she retired in 2016, no one would have batted an eye if she’d dialed it back a little. But Ms. Johnson didn’t view retirement as an opportunity to kick back. Instead, she kicked off another food adventure and opened a restaurant in her hometown of Braddock.

Aunt Cheryl’s Cafe is right in the heart of town, directly across the street from the library where she spent hours reading as a child. Tucked into the lower level of the Nyia Page Community Center at 416 Library St., it’s a family affair. Her daughter, Precious Chambers, runs the kitchen from 11 a.m. to 6 p.m. Tuesday through Saturday.

Advertise with us
Aunt Cheryl Johnson with her daughter, Precious Chambers. ((Pam Panchak / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Cooking is in Ms. Johnson’s DNA and she picked up the skill at a young age. One of her fondest memories from childhood is going into Guentert's Bakery and taking a whiff because it smelled so good.

Her maternal grandmother’s house smelled wonderful, too, always thick with the aromas of baking bread. Otelia “Tiny” Richards worked as a family cook in Squirrel Hill and introduced Ms. Johnson to veal, tongue, brains and sauerkraut. Then there was her grandmother’s lemon meringue pie. It was so stellar that Ms. Johnson has never dared to try to recreate it.

Her mother-in-law, Mary Chambers, also was a great and inspiring cook who instilled in Ms. Johnson the importance of using only the best, freshest ingredients and real butter.

“She always told me, ‘You eat with your eyes first,’” Ms. Johnson recalls.

She lived in Penn Hills for years and learned about the community center space proposal through a friend. She was intrigued.

Advertise with us

“But I kept putting if off,” she says with laugh, waiting until about 15 minutes before the deadline to turn in her paperwork. Four months later, she got the approval.

At first, Ms. Johnson didn’t know what she was doing, other than to make good food and serve the community. But eventually, it all fell in place.

“I just fell in love with the people and energy here,” she says.

Her catering business wasn’t her first foray into food.  As a young mother in the early 1990s she made Christmas cookies to sell at flea markets and then mom-and-pop shops across Braddock and Homewood. That led to an opportunity to share space in a wholesale bakery in Highland Park where she would make sweet potato pies, using a family recipe.

Her sweet potato pies are so famous, that when the United Way of Southwestern PA teamed up with Eat'n Park last September to host a virtual pasta dinner for 500 families facing food insecurity, everyone got one for dessert.

Advertise with us
Aunt Cheryl's sweet potato pie. ((Pam Panchak / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

She started the catering business after her youngest, twins, were born after her reputation as the Cookie Lady grew. She’s done countless  weddings, birthday parties and church events over the years and even had a kiosk in Heinz Field’s East Club.

In 2016, she launched the annual Thanksgiving Feast for Peace event to bring Braddock residents and police officers together to break bread. The goal is to reinforce that the police aren’t “wooden soldiers,” but are people who also love the Steelers and other things like anyone else, she says.

Last July, she embarked on yet another project, partnering with the United Way to become one of several vendors preparing meals for those struggling with food insecurity because of COVID-19. It is done through the nonprofit’s Student and Families Food Relief Fund and funded by the CARES Act.

Assembled at the  American Legion in East Pittsburgh, some are family-style dinners served once a week to people in senior and public housing complexes. She and her team of nine prepare “backpacks” filled with two days’ worth of oatmeal packets, granola fruit, noodles and other nutritious snacks for hundreds of children who don’t have access to free breakfast or lunches because they’re not in school.

“I’ve seen how people of low income are so disenfranchised, and it makes me tear up,” she says.

Advertise with us

“Her spirit is always in the right place, giving back to those in need,” says UWSP’s manager of school initiatives, Cheyenne Taylor, who estimates she prepares around 1,100 meals a week. “Her sweet potato pies are to die for. They’re magnificent.”

Back at the cafe, Ms. Johnson’s menu was originally Panera-style, focusing on cold sandwiches, salads and smoothies. But now it includes soul food like chicken and waffles, fish sandwiches, burgers, cobblers and snacks like “squid fries” topped with chicken, cheese, barbecue sauce and bacon bits. Prices range from $8 to $12 for most items.

Her signature dish is her turkey salad, a simple and creamy mix of fresh turkey and five secret ingredients. The star of any party, it’s won the praise of local celebs such as Franco Harris, Jerome Bettis, Judge Jeffrey Manning and gospel singer CeCe Winans.

“And every time I go to California, I take some to [singer and actress] Marilyn McCoo,” she says.

For many, though, her sweet potato pie, with its buttery crust and velvety filling, is the siren call.

Advertise with us

“There’s nothing like them,” says Lamar Feagins, a longtime Braddock resident who visits the cafe at least three times a week. “Everything is delicious but they’re unbelievable.”

“I want to make something I’m proud of,” says Ms. Johnson, adding that every time  she makes the creamy orange filling, she thinks about her ancestors and cooks who instilled the importance of creating something of quality.

She includes as many local ingredients as she can source. Sandwiches are built on bread from Triangle Bar & Grill in Swissvale, for example, and she gets her vegetables during growing season from Braddock Farms, just down the street.

A billboard along Braddock Avenue advertising Aunt Cheryl’s Sweet Potato pie. ((Pam Panchak / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“It can’t just be about the register,” she says. “It’s about making good food that pleases people’s palates.”

With her shoestring budget, Ms. Johnson for a while relied on social media and word of mouth to get customers. It was only last year, during the social unrest over Black Lives Matter, that a logo was developed and featured on a billboard on Braddock Avenue and inspired the mini-mural on the cafe’s front door. I

Advertise with us

It pairs the motto “Food from the Heart” with an image of the cook in a chef’s hat holding a pie. It was created by  Leslie Stem, a  graphic artist who created the artist collaborative Transformazium based in the Braddock library.

Ms. Johnson says she was talking with Precious on her back porch one night, and decided she wanted to be known as the next Aunt Jemima.

“Everyone said, ‘Are you sure? Do you know who Aunt Jemima is,’” she recalls. Quaker Oats had just been forced to change the brand’s name and remove its image from its pancake mixes and syrup because of racial stereotyping.

“But I was like, ‘She made millions of dollars,’” she says, with a laugh.

Ms. Stem says she has been trying to convince Ms. Johnson to use her own image for marketing for some time, because she’s such a vibrant person and the best representation of her brand. The chefs hat and pie she’s holding “radiates the same things we associate with comfort food,” she says, “and is reliably delicious.”

Advertise with us

The mural on the cafe’s front door was painted by muralists Shane Pilster and Max Gonzales, who met Ms. Johnson while they were painting a small food truck for boxer Monty Meza-Clay in Rankin last summer.

Aunt Cheryl's Cafe mural ((Pam Panchak / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

As for the future? Ms. Johnson says she’d love to see her sweet potato pies in grocery stores across the country. Meanwhile, she’s content to do what she’s always done — serve.

“I stand on what I do, and have a passion for it,” she says.

Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter/IG @gtmckay.

Grandma Tiny’s Oyster Stuffing

Advertise with us

Thanksgiving was Cheryl Johnson’s favorite holiday growing up, and a stuffing, flavored with smoked oysters, made her grandmother, Otelia “Tiny” Richards, was a must at the feast. “The smells that came out of the kitchen would make you happy as soon as you walked into the house,” she says.

Ms. Johnson has adapted the original recipe to include boxed stuffing mixes for those who like to make quick and easy but amazing food. It also gives the dish a modern touch.

1 box of stuffing mix

2 cups of dried bread cubes

1 small box of corn muffin mix

Advertise with us

1 stick of butter

1 small onion, diced

1 small green pepper, diced

2 (16-ounce) cans of chicken or turkey broth

1 egg, beaten

Advertise with us

Seasoned salt and black pepper, to taste

2 cans of smoked oysters

Preheat oven to 375 degrees.

Add boxed stuffing, bread cubes and corn muffin mix to a large bowl and mix well. Set aside.

Melt butter in skillet over low heat, then add onion and green pepper. Cook, stirring occasionally, until tender. Pour in chicken or turkey broth.

Advertise with us

Add butter, onions, green peppers and broth to the stuffing.

Stir well. Add egg and toss until mixture is moist. Season to taste with salt and pepper,

Add smoked oysters, including all the oil, and mix well to combine. (The oil adds great flavor to the stuffing.)

Spray a 9-by-13-inch baking dish with a nonstick cooking spray. Pour stuffing mixture into the baking dish and spread evenly. Cover with foil and bake for 40 minutes. Remove foil and continue to bake about 15 to 20 minutes.

Serve warm.

Advertise with us

Serves 8 to 10.

— Cheryl Johnson